4 ms·
The study itself looks like it's well done, result is statistically highly significant, but it was still just an internet study where people were self reporti
by nabla9 6y ago
The study itself looks like it's well done, result is statistically highly significant, but it was still just an internet study where people were self reporting. All you end with is suggestive evidence not be taken too seriously.
- JacobAldridge 6y ago> it was still just an internet study where people were self reporting And I wonder whether it would largely have been people contemplating a decision because they were dissatisfied/ unhappy with the status quo? My immediate thought it to Nassim Taleb’s via negativa - not necessarily any more well researched, but the view that in uncertainty do nothing or indeed do less to create a better outcome. That inaction is to be preferred where change and action has no clear benefit.
- ChrisHardman29 6y agoInteresting point. I haven't read that but maybe the appropriate approach depends on the situation / level of uncertainty. For example, in situations where we have little clarity on the options or what the outcomes will look like, it perhaps makes sense to resist any urge to take action because we can't make any sensible comparison between the change and the status quo (and 'action bias' may be more of a factor). In other situations, like leaving one job to go to another, we have a better (though definitely imperfect) idea of what the options / outcomes look like and so may be better placed to make a comparison (in which case loss aversion may be more important). This is just a theory though - I may be totally wrong!
- ChrisHardman29 6y agoI agree that (like most studies) it could be more robust but what I think is more interesting is the underlying explanation (which, like any theory, may not be correct). Making complex decisions is notoriously challenging - e.g. you are comparing factors across different scales and timeframes (see the book 'Farsighted' by Steven Johnson) - and no single rule should be wholly relied upon, but I think that being aware of the potential impacts of loss aversion / status quo bias during the process can only be helpful.