4 ms·
I find a part of the problem to also be that it simply doesn’t have a good channel for many of the problems I find on the maps themselves. Got a typo in a busi
by chrismorgan 6y ago
I find a part of the problem to also be that it simply doesn’t have a good channel for many of the problems I find on the maps themselves.
Got a typo in a business listing, wrong opening hours, &c.? Sure, you can fix that.
Got a road segment slightly wrong? OK, you can straighten it out.
Any other case where the underlying map data or presentation is wrong? Nope, you can’t report it, and any attempt to report the issue by the channels that are available will fail to have any effect.
And that’s the problem, Maps just doesn’t seem to be interested in providing, y’know, maps. It’s focused on being a business directory instead.
Take https://www.google.com/maps/place/Navarre+VIC+3384,+Australia https://www.google.com/maps/place/Navarre+VIC+3384,+Australi... as an example: that pin and label on the map is almost 5km south of Navarre, because they seem to have taken the entire suburb area (which in rural areas is regularly many kilometres across) and picked a point on its boundary—I dunno, maybe the furthest point south, maybe just the start position of the polyline—rather than taking a sane point that represents where the town actually is (e.g. its post office) or even a midpoint in the suburb area.
When you look through rural areas you find a substantial fraction of the labels are wrong by several kilometres. Head south to the next town, Landsborough, and it’s marked 4km down the road from where it actually is. I’ve seen some places 10km off the mark.
I’ve attempted to report the Navarre case six or seven times over the last few years while living there, by three different ways (none of which is properly applicable), and it’s still stubbornly in the wrong place.
(Yes, I’m mentioning this here on the off chance that someone relevant will see it and pay attention.)
- chrismorgan 6y agoUpdate: it worked! My brother just pointed out to me that Navarre is in the right place now, and Landsborough is too. Others that I didn’t mention aren’t fixed, though. As an example, Tooborac is labelled 6km south-west of the actual town.
- blackboxlogic 6y agoThis might be the right time to suggest OpenStreetMaps. I turned to it after not being able to fix things in Google and endless advertising. OSM data is flaky... but you can fix it!
- chrismorgan 6y agoAmusingly, OSM apps can suffer from similar problems, because the way things are done vary across the world, and the software tends to at least start by being designed to work best with the way things are annotated in a particular area. I filed https://github.com/QwantResearch/qwantmaps/issues/65 https://github.com/QwantResearch/qwantmaps/issues/65 because Qwant Maps was resolving “Navarre” to the centre of a rather large administrative boundary by that name, so that it’s 20km away from the village node that it should be using instead. (That particular issue is partly resolved by OSM data changes that have happened since: it’s still using the administrative boundary, which is the wrong thing for it to do, but seven months ago someone added an admin_center to that boundary so that Qwant Maps drops the pin on the right point rather than the centre of the boundary—though it still zooms to include the whole boundary, which is much wider than it should zoom.)
- gfxgirl 6y agoI don't see how OpenStreetMaps will do any better. On top of just mistakes there will be active fraud https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20237365 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20237365
- aaronax 6y agoIt's probably not controversial to say that Wikipedia is the "best" encyclopedia. What differences between Wikipedia and OSM do you think prevent OSM from becoming the best map?
- MauranKilom 6y agoHow exactly would you go about basing a map on secondary and tertiary sources?
- Godel_unicode 6y agoOne of the fundamental reasons Wikipedia works well is there's no profit in changing what an article says. Any time there is a motivation, the system falls apart and the article has to be protected and actively monitored.