3 ms·
Applying the same logic to 1A, we could say that the freedom of the press is not infringed - you can have as many as you want! - but it doesn't say anything abo
by int_19h 6y ago
Applying the same logic to 1A, we could say that the freedom of the press is not infringed - you can have as many as you want! - but it doesn't say anything about ink. Or laser and offset printers, for that matter.
In practice, the courts take dim view on such arguments, and if some element is required to practically exercise a right, it is usually protected under that right.
- kurthr 6y agoSee, I actually agree... it's the originalists who have a problem. If you want to talk about the press, and having rights abridged by not having ink then you better actually be in the business of printing (or maybe a potential member of a well regulated militia?). Waiting periods have been deemed perfectly constitutional so it's a lot harder to argue that those so horrifically unprepared and unwilling to wait for their mail order ammo (yep that's legal!) to be delivered are really having rights infringed more than my free speech is being infringed by being forced to wear a shirt and shoes (or even pants) to be served food.
- int_19h 6y agoMail order ammo is only legal until the state says it's illegal - CA did just that. My understanding of your original premise was that there are no venues available.