6 ms·
"The weight of the batteries makes swapping infeasible" comment makes absolutely no sense. Make them modular, In sub units which can be handled, mount them at t
by ggm 6y ago
"The weight of the batteries makes swapping infeasible" comment makes absolutely no sense. Make them modular, In sub units which can be handled, mount them at the right points for C.G and design an airframe to permit module swapping with suitable equipment.
- swagasaurus-rex 6y agoIs there any room in the imagination for swapping these batteries mid flight? I'd imagine it makes even less sense than mid-air jet-refueling.
- rosywoozlechan 6y agoI imagine it would be mid-air recharging instead.
- ShorsHammer 6y agoTracking with lasers should be manageable for low level flight. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wireless_power_transfer#Lasers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wireless_power_transfer#Lasers
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoThis, by the way, has to be the future of electric ground vehicles too. A standardized external battery format, automated/mechanical battery replacement. In theory "filling up" vehicles like could be quicker than refilling a fuel tank with gasoline or diesel. And to ensure that I get marked down, I'll add that I'm fairly certain that only government(s) can make this happen (enforced standardization of the form factor across the industry).
- ggm 6y agoFlying is a fully regulated industry worldwide. Modular industry standard swappable batteries are achingly simple but so is regulated seat pitch and look how likely that is. Food cards? They did that. Intermodal containers? They did that.
- clouddrover 6y ago> A standardized external battery format, automated/mechanical battery replacement Nio does this with their EVs: https://insideevs.com/news/426014/nio-power-battery-swaps-500000/ https://insideevs.com/news/426014/nio-power-battery-swaps-50... https://www.topgear.com/car-news/big-reads/power-shift-battery-swapping-our-way-across-china https://www.topgear.com/car-news/big-reads/power-shift-batte... The idea is the easily replaceable pack gives you the option to charge, swap, or upgrade the battery as you like.
- postingawayonhn 6y agoSo did Tesla and Better Place. Neither do anymore.
- clouddrover 6y agoDid either one get to 500,000 battery swaps as Nio has done?
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoAs I noted, this is only going to work when the batteries are as cross-vehicle as current gasoline pump nozzles. And I would wager that this implies government action (or at least, the threat of government action) to bring about. It's not useless to do it on a smaller scale, but ultimately until you can just drive into what used to be just a gas station, put your car over the designated spots and in 20 seconds your battery is swapped out, then its still not a serious replacement for oil-derived liquid fuels.
- clouddrover 6y ago> this is only going to work when It's working right now. They've done it 500,000 times. You're being needlessly pessimistic. Battery swapping is simply an option they offer. You can use it or not as you like.
- gfxgirl 6y agoI like the idea of swappable batteries. I don't like the idea of taking someone else's battery in whatever condition it's in vs only using my own supply of swappable batteries.
- enchiridion 6y agoI would be alright with it if I didn't have to buy a battery with the car.
- Kerrick 6y agoIt's not unlike propane tanks for a grill. You turn in your tank and get a different, filled tank.
- slau 6y agoExcept for the part where batteries are chemical processes that can deteriorate when poorly maintained. Just look at how people abuse rental cars (e.g. Clarkson’s “Fastest car in the world”). Then there’s the added issue that if you get a dud gas tank, the worst thing that happens is that it leaks and you bring it back after letting it empty overnight in the garden. In this case, a battery catching fire would be near to guaranteed death for anyone on the plane. I don’t even lend 18650 cells to friends for this exact reason, let alone strangers.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoI admit to not knowing a lot about battery tech, but how exactly does a driver of a vehicle abuse the battery? Isn't that a function of the vehicle design rather than behavior by the driver?
- CydeWeys 6y agoPeople keep saying this but it never gets more practical. Meanwhile, battery ranges get longer and recharging gets faster. I'm not convinced that swappable batteries are the future of EVs at all.
- Animats 6y agoWhere battery swapping was used, in forklifts and other indoor handling machinery, it seem to be on the way out. Newer forklifts tend to use lithium-ion batteries. "Lithium-ion forklift batteries can be opportunity charged in any setting, eliminating the need for time-consuming battery swaps" - Toyota. Swapping half-ton battery lead-acid battery packs was a headache. Unless you run 24/7, it's easier to just plug in the forklift when you're not using it. Battery swapping was a bet against battery energy density getting better. Better Place, the auto battery swap company, lost that bet. (They were 90% hype, 10% about actually doing it, but that's another issue.)
- adrianN 6y agoIn addition, charge time is pretty much irrelevant in all applications except long distance road trips. The typical electric car uses 15-20kWh/100km. A car spends more than 20 hours a day parked and almost nobody travels more than 100km a day regularly. Charging at low single-digit kW as you can get from a normal socket is sufficient. For the rare trips that exceed normal battery capacity you can just rent a plug-in hybrid or deal with a small number of 45 minute breaks while you super-charge. Or take a train.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoIn the western US (at least), although most car journeys are short and daily charging makes the most sense, not being able to use a single vehicle for longer journeys without enforced long-ish breaks currently acts as quite a deterrent to the all-electric car vision of the future. Currently, with gas/diesel vehicles, the same car can function more or less equally well for just about every type of journey, and it has long been a dominant habit of the US consumer to target what they perceive as their most demanding use. In the US, at least, one version that most demanding use is "driving for two days or more". I love trains, but train travel across the western half of the US is a joke, and isn't a lot better in the eastern half. When the train can take you, it's great - we used it to get from Santa Fe to Chicago last thanksgiving. But change the destination or origin just a little bit, and it becomes almost absurd to thiking about using it.
- foolfoolz 6y agoit's such a good idea you can raise almost $1B, get a car manufacturer to build a car for you supporting this system, convince a country to be a guinea pig, and ??? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Better_Place_(company) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Better_Place_(company)
- bronco21016 6y agoAnd a Caravan is probably the best candidate for a battery swap system. Many of them come outfitted with a large underbelly cargo container.
- fernly 6y ago> design an airframe There's the problem for this plane, they were using an existing airframe. Which looks to me like it really needs the weight in the front third to balance that ungainly long passenger cabin, so I bet the batteries are in the long forward section.
- sandworm101 6y ago>>In sub units which can be handled, mount them at the right points for C.G and design an airframe to permit module swapping with suitable equipment. Swapping out stuff like that is going to be tricky. These are essential pieces of equipment. Whenever you plug/unplug important things from passenger aircraft you have to check and doublecheck that they are installed properly. You have to test them. Swapping out batteries would be like installing a new fuel tank. Swap and go may work for cars, but a faulty connector on a plane;s battery could mean the flight ends in flames.
- smadge 6y agoPersonally I would rather wait 30 minutes for it to charge than try to replace 2,000 pounds of batteries.
- yxhuvud 6y agoWhile you are not necessarily wrong, such a system would add complexity and currently they don't seem to need it to be competitive, so why bother? It is the kind of innovation which will come if the flight type becomes sufficiently common.
- iguy 6y agoElectric planes with swappable batteries exist: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pipistrel_Alpha_Trainer#Alpha_Electro https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pipistrel_Alpha_Trainer#Alpha_... I guess the use case is that a flight school could have 2 planes & 5 batteries, and get more student flights into a day by not waiting for charging. Operating from one fixed base, one owner, so no issue with getting someone else's pack. 126 kg, so not trivial to remove.