3 ms·
> If Covid-19 rules restrict religious practices more than some commercial activities I think we have a problem. Oh come on. It's OK to pick and choose which
by gumby 6y ago
> If Covid-19 rules restrict religious practices more than some commercial activities I think we have a problem.
Oh come on. It's OK to pick and choose which activities are more important than a health rule -- a doctor or a plumber clearly should be permitted to perform some necessary activities or life would be at greater risk. And the law parses apart the cases: you can get respiratory care or chemotherapy but not plastic surgery. The plumber can fix a backed up sewer pipe but (for a while) not do new construction, etc.
Perhaps your note was accidentally misworded. If they restrict religious practices that are physically identical to commercial activities that are not restricted then we would have a problem. If concerts were allowed but not churches that would be a problem. If outdoor concerts were allowed but not indoor ones, then outdoor religious congregation should be allowed even if indoor equivalent is not. Etc.
But nobody, including the plaintiffs, is making that assertion.
- pnw_hazor 6y agoThe problem arises because the government is not supposed to judge the merit, efficacy, or importance/value of a otherwise lawful religious practice. The government needs a neutral independent reason that withstands strict scrutiny to regulate religion. For example, building fire codes can apply to religious buildings. But many zoning ordinances have to exempt religious buildings. Here the government is saying some commercial activities, like grocery stores are more important than going to church. The SCOTUS order is side-stepping the issue by trying to categorize religious practice as similar to going to see a movie. It would be interesting to see how the court would have ruled on an appeal of a fully developed case. Here, since they are evaluating an emergency stay order, rather than a fully developed case, I think they were comfortable cutting some corners.
- ryandrake 6y agoIf the governments were smart, they would not pick and choose specific activities and industries to allow and disallow, but instead simply prohibited closely packed or indoor gatherings (by whatever measurement of "closely-packed" makes epidemiological sense) and left it at that. That way, if a church wanted to stay in service they could simply figure out how to comply, like by doing it outside and 2 meters between people. But no, governments instead editorialized and said these kinds of businesses are cool and these aren't, turning it into a politically charged value judgment of this industry vs that activity.
- pnw_hazor 6y agoAgreed. They could have made a blanket rule that set a base standard that applied to all business or orgs, including churches, and then stricter targeted rules for particular non-religious organizations if they needed to.