4 ms·
Well, at this point, screaming about these not being mental models is about as useful as complaining about re-posted imagery not being actual "memes." (In the o
by jvanderbot 6y ago
Well, at this point, screaming about these not being mental models is about as useful as complaining about re-posted imagery not being actual "memes." (In the original sense of the word meme).
A mental model is something you use to make predictions so that you don't have to store all the nuances of a system in memory. It's a reduced-entropy representation of a phenomena of the universe that you have to interact with. It's a simple oracle. Newtonian gravity is a mental model.
These are recipes and formalized guidance, i.e., wisdom, for dissecting problems and presenting solutions. These are algorithms.
If you believe these will work, you have a mental model of the world that you have checked to verify these steps. The model that the author has of readers is that they will enjoy this post.
- dandigangi 6y agoSlightly confused if you don't mind clarifying. Are you saying that what a mental model actually is isn't correct in how this article uses them?
- jvanderbot 6y agoYes. A model takes input, runs a process, and provides output. It's a model because it is simpler than the real process, but provides reasonable approximations. Newtonian Physics is a model of physical interaction from gravity and mass. A mental model is an internal construct the mind uses to represent parts of the world. You have a mental model of your body. You have a mental model of how physics works. You have a mental model of how your friends would react to certain situations. etc. A model says "If the world is in this state, then the next state is this one." Wisdom, or aphorisms, are things that are taught to people which are shorthand for solutions to complicated situations. They are algorithms. They say "These are the answers to problems that you might encounter". Sometimes, they provide guidance. They are heuristics. This article should be "Polya-like heuristics for designers" You would teach someone a mental model like this: "Think of a person as a robot programmed to reproduce and eat". This allows you to draw conclusions by querying your model of a robot and applying that to the person. You could predict how the person would make decisions. It might be wise to do that or not. You would teach someone wisdom or an aphorism like this: "If you encounter a hard problem, break it down into sub problems". True, there is potentially a model there: All problems are just collections of subproblems, but that's something you have to build up by following the guidance. It doesn't actually give you a model, it prods you to build one ... if necessary. The article does not provide any models, it only suggests steps to break down problems or communicate solutions. You, the reader, are using your internal mental models of the world to see if the stuff you are being suggested actually makes sense. If you start crafting new models, it is not because this article contains any of them.