6 ms·
We should be distinguishing between "essential" activities and "constitutionally-protected" activities. They are different axes with only some overlap. Not ever
by ryandrake 6y ago
We should be distinguishing between "essential" activities and "constitutionally-protected" activities. They are different axes with only some overlap. Not everything that is constitutionally-protected is essential, and not everything that is essential is constitutionally protected. For example, the right to food is not guaranteed by the constitution but we can probably agree that stores providing food to the public are essential, because without food we die.
While freedom to believe in a religion is constitutionally protected, I think it can be strongly argued that congregating shoulder-to-shoulder in a confined space while shouting and singing is not an essential activity and should be restricted during a deadly global pandemic. Freedom of speech is protected too, but we don't see libraries in a rush to open up.
- perl4ever 6y agoI just find it weird that nobody is bringing up Matthew 6:5. I can hardly imagine any example of "praying to be seen by men" purer than the politicization of opening churches right now. I have this feeling like, surely the cognitive dissonance will hit any minute now? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Matthew_6:5 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Matthew_6:5
- Noos 6y agoYou are forgetting Matthew 18, 19-20: "Again I say to you, if two of you agree on earth about anything they ask, it will be done for them by my Father in heaven. For where two or three are gathered in my name, there am I among them." There is also the idea of Communion, which is a religious gathering instituted by Jesus himself, in Luke 22. Paul also exhorts believers not to "forsake the assembling of themselves" in Hebrews 10. Communal gathering as a church is actually a religious doctrine. The details of how one should do so is really a thorny issue, and the state saying "only so many may do so" is perilously close to breaching separation. It has nothing to do with praying loud to appear religious in public to get praise from men.
- perl4ever 6y agoI won't debate your interpretation of scripture, but it's not relevant to your last sentence which seems disconnected and unsupported to me. And palpably absurd. Trying to convince me is definitely not worth your effort. To act like you care what I think is an indictment itself.
- paulryanrogers 6y agoChurch services often involve singing and speaking loudly in confined spaces. Yet there's no evidence doing so is necessary to survive. Proven mitigations against real threats are more important than the unprovable 'benefits' of religion. No matter how old, popular, or eloquent the source of the religion.
- kmonsen 6y agoFirst of all, a religious text is not relevant in us court case, even if about a religious case. Secondly, Christianity as practiced today is very different and not something Jesus would have understood at all so in many ways the Bible and Jesus is not key to understanding American Christianity.
- aspenmayer 6y agoTo say Jesus wouldn't understand modern Christianity is presupposing the Trinity is false, isn’t it? Otherwise, Jesus is part of the tripartite godhead and is aware of everything the Tetragrammaton and the Holy Spirit are aware of, which is more than the totality of existence of space-time. Not to make this a religious discussion, just striving for a steelman interpretation of the religious logical stance.
- kmonsen 6y agoI’m not making an argument about Jesus but about his supposed followers. Anyway, the main point is that US law and the Bible are not connected. It’s still legal to eat shrimp and pork, and usury became legal when that was convenient.
- aspenmayer 6y agoI don’t mean to miss your point; however, to many people, US law and the Bible are connected. The Moral Majority[1] used and modern religious right use the Bible as justification for their social and economic policies.[2] It could be argued how Biblical their policies are, but to say they are not connected in many voters’ and believers’ minds is to misunderstand them and what they believe, religiously and politically. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_Majority https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_Majority [2] https://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2015/04/corporate-america-invented-religious-right-conservative-roosevelt-princeton-117030 https://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2015/04/corporate-am...
- toast0 6y agoIt's not really the Supreme Court's job to interpret a religion's sacred texts and tell the adherents that they're doing it wrong.
- perl4ever 6y agoNo, it's the adherents' job though to consider if bringing something to the Supreme Court is consistent with their beliefs.
- pnw_hazor 6y agoAs we know, rights are not absolute. US law has developed such that commercial activities, including commercial speech can be subject to more limitations than non-commercial activities. Also, US law has also generally held that political and religious activities are the most protected. This doesn't mean that anything goes, it is just that the government needs a really good reason to interfere. If Covid-19 rules restrict religious practices more than some commercial activities I think we have a problem. I feel the emergency stay should be left in place because the state is not equipped to measure the amount of irreparable harm that may be caused by interfering in an otherwise legal religious practice.
- gumby 6y ago> If Covid-19 rules restrict religious practices more than some commercial activities I think we have a problem. Oh come on. It's OK to pick and choose which activities are more important than a health rule -- a doctor or a plumber clearly should be permitted to perform some necessary activities or life would be at greater risk. And the law parses apart the cases: you can get respiratory care or chemotherapy but not plastic surgery. The plumber can fix a backed up sewer pipe but (for a while) not do new construction, etc. Perhaps your note was accidentally misworded. If they restrict religious practices that are physically identical to commercial activities that are not restricted then we would have a problem. If concerts were allowed but not churches that would be a problem. If outdoor concerts were allowed but not indoor ones, then outdoor religious congregation should be allowed even if indoor equivalent is not. Etc. But nobody, including the plaintiffs, is making that assertion.
- pnw_hazor 6y agoThe problem arises because the government is not supposed to judge the merit, efficacy, or importance/value of a otherwise lawful religious practice. The government needs a neutral independent reason that withstands strict scrutiny to regulate religion. For example, building fire codes can apply to religious buildings. But many zoning ordinances have to exempt religious buildings. Here the government is saying some commercial activities, like grocery stores are more important than going to church. The SCOTUS order is side-stepping the issue by trying to categorize religious practice as similar to going to see a movie. It would be interesting to see how the court would have ruled on an appeal of a fully developed case. Here, since they are evaluating an emergency stay order, rather than a fully developed case, I think they were comfortable cutting some corners.