6 ms·
The EPRs under consturction fraught with cost overruns and huge delays (some started 15 construction years ago) are evidence that big reactors in the real world
by fulafel 6y ago
The EPRs under consturction fraught with cost overruns and huge delays (some started 15 construction years ago) are evidence that big reactors in the real world are not very economical.
- derefr 6y agoYou get those very same cost overruns and huge delays in smaller reactors (at least, as long as you're building on the same fundamental technologies.) You can build cheaper by building e.g. a Thorium breeder reactor, but that just defers the problem of project management—building a thousand Thorium plants, like building a wind-farm with 1000 windmills, is still fraught with bureaucratic principal-agent problems. Really, the problem isn't any specific technology, but rather the fact that any industry where projects cost a billion dollars apiece, is going to result in a natural monopoly/oligopoly, which creates perverse incentives. The renewable energy sources you think of when you think of "renewable energy", aren't lower-overhead because of what's required to build them. They're lower-overhead because they're often built/sold as individual interchangable units that can be purchased on the open market at different times from many different companies; which creates an efficient, liquid market for such devices. Contrast with e.g. a hydro dam. Hydro power is also renewable energy! But a dam is just as large an infrastructure project as a nuclear plant; and so dam-builders and dam-buyers form just as small a market; and so said market is just as fraught with cronyist back-room dealings; and so the market ends up just as inefficient as nuclear, or coal, or oil-and-gas, or any other cartel-driven business.
- fulafel 6y agoI'm not sure if we are reading the same sources. The smaller ~1 GW BWR projects (using eg VVER-1000) have been completed with much smaller delays and overruns in recent years, with construction start to operation times around 5 years.