4 ms·
The only difference is a terms of service nobody reads which "allows" them to do what they want, no matter how abusive.
by matheusmoreira 6y ago
The only difference is a terms of service nobody reads which "allows" them to do what they want, no matter how abusive.
- cgriswald 6y agoIn some of the cases there’s no chance to agree with the TOS or leave before you are scanned. > For example, Citibank, Ameriprise, and TIAA-CREF immediately port scanned our computers when visiting the main page of the site.
- elliekelly 6y agoPerhaps EFF could bring a private cause of action under the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act.
- HenryBemis 6y agoNatWest App on Android also tries to connect to ThreatMetrix. I use NoRoot Firewall to block it (Global Filters).
- matheusmoreira 6y agoYes. Most if not all websites with typical "by continuing to use the site you agree to..." terms will drop cookies and fingerprint the user on their first visit, breaching their own contract. They do it even if lack of consent is made explicit by including Do Not Track in the HTTP headers. These terms are obviously an attempt to get away with questionable behavior. Instead of simply not doing bad things, they insist and point people to the legalese when they complain as if it excused everything.
- MereInterest 6y agoExactly. It's very easy to be compliant with privacy law if you aren't stalking your users in the first place. The best example I've seen for doing it right was from godbolt.org, whose GDPR notice is refreshingly direct. > The Compiler Explorer team believes the Compiler Explorer site is compliant with the EU's General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). Specifically, we store no personally identifying information, we anonymise the little data that we do have and we do not permanently store any user data.
- Silhouette 6y agoJust because someone puts something in a ToS, that doesn't mean it's necessarily lawful to do it or that the term carries legal weight in any other way. Consumer protection laws are full of rules that say, roughly speaking, "You may not do this, and any attempt to permit it shall be void/illegal". That's why in my country you often see signs in shops, usually underneath whatever guarantee/refund/exchange policy the store voluntarily offers, that say "Your statutory rights are not affected." It's the same sort of argument that results in contracts disclaiming liability for everything under the sun but also including a clause that says they explicitly do not disclaim liability for certain specific outcomes like causing serious injury or death.
- smichel17 6y agoAdditionally, website terms of service are (almost exclusively) adhesion contracts -- you don't have any ability to amend them before you accept, just say yes or no. There's a whole different set of precedents for these type of contract. Notably, unexpected/nonstandard terms are unlikely to be enforceable. IANAL, but this is coming from a business law course I took in undergrad.