6 ms·
The missing component in all of these green initiatives aimed at changing human behavior is a simple feedback loop. Put a fucking indicator somewhere in the sho
by throwaway894345 6y ago
The missing component in all of these green initiatives aimed at changing human behavior is a simple feedback loop. Put a fucking indicator somewhere in the shower that tells people how much water they used, or better yet, energy, or better yet, carbon. Show them their week over week, month over month, etc information and positively reward them (via tone—and other UI hints—of the message, e.g., “you reduced your shower carbon by X this month! Great work!”). If you do that even my backwoods relatives who still burn their garbage will start using less and less water, even all the while talking about how climate change is all a hoax.
- jononor 6y agoI started designing this kind of device. In addition to tracking consumption, the concept had automatic mixing of hot/cold water to get good stable temperature. And a timer to facilitate non-continuous showers, press once to get wet, then soap in while shower is off, press again to rinse off.
- mmm_grayons 6y agoI'm guessing you might be able to make money selling that to, e.g. the military, but not to regular people. Most take showers at least in part to relax, and that sounds like it would kill any possibility of relaxation.
- jononor 6y agoAgreed, at least in volume. Which is more or less needed for a hardware product like this. There might be one can reach some thousands via the Internet, maybe using a Kickstarter type platform. But probably would quickly saturate its own niche market.
- mattlondon 6y ago> tells people how much water they used, or better yet, energy, or better yet, carbon. If you want to really change behavior, show them how much it cost them. You'll see usage plummet as soon as people see the $/£/€ ticking up in front of their eyes.
- throwaway894345 6y agoYou’re probably right! Why not show both?
- m4rtink 6y agoThe Sunrize Izumo, one of the last two remaining japanese sleeper trainshas something like that - from necessity. The on board water supply is limitted, so a vending mashine on board sells a given ammount of shower-cards, that let you shower for an alotted number of minutes, counted with second precission on a LED display in the shower. This way the on board shower will not run out of water & you get the opportunity to do a shower speedrun. :)
- leetcrew 6y agoprobably depends on how meaningful the cost of utilities is to you. I try to use AC and heat sparingly just because I hate the idea of waste; it really annoys me if I have to turn on the heat a few nights later because I turned on my AC too early. but my whole utility bill is ~$70/month. I don't really care too much about saving 10-20% of that.
- techslave 6y agowater is far too cheap for this to work
- Shared404 6y agoDepends on your location. For example, this could be very effective someplace like the southwest US. Obviously it wouldn't work everywhere, but it could work for a few people I know personally.
- TrainedMonkey 6y agoSure let's gamify everything. "Congratulations you've responded to your emails 6% faster this week! To celebrate this a $5 gift card had been added to your amazon account!" I think this is not a tech problem, to change the behavior people need to care about the environment.
- op00to 6y agoTo change behavior you need to make people want to change, give them the ability to change, and create an environment conducive to change. Without all those pieces all bets are off.
- throwaway894345 6y agoFeedback loops are a psychological solution. Implement them without tech if you like, but good luck making that efficient. Anyway, if you have a magic wand to make enough people care enough about the environment immediately, please do wave it. :) Absent that, I can’t imagine feedback loops are harmful with respect to our collective political will; on the contrary, I would expect daily positive feedback to change attitudes over somewhat small timescales, especially as more and more people participate and it is more normalized. But this is pure speculation and optimizing showering is not where we should spend our limited political will anyway.
- mattigames 6y agoA lot of people ignore the problem because they don't see a direct correlation between what they do and the damage they are doing, it's conveniently abstracted away from their sight, I don't think gamification per se would help much but in general exposure to ones consequences would.
- masklinn 6y ago> I think this is not a tech problem, to change the behavior people need to care about the environment. I fail to see how they're incompatible. GP's suggestion is a way to put the impact of people's habits in front of them rather than have that information be mixed with a hundred other signals and only available from indicators somewhere in the basement. In the same way you might use a kill-a-watt or 3 to see how much your various devices and appliances are consuming in what mode. And having goals is a pretty well-known way to motivate people, hence the "gamification".
- red_admiral 6y agoI might be in a minority overall, but I really dislike gamification creeping into everyday life. I don't want some kind of cutesy "points" for showering ecologically, possibly linked to a virtual currency on an app (which conventiently also collects vital telemetry information).
- luckylion 6y agoThe point isn't really gamification, it's providing information to the user. If you don't have any information on your consumption, you'll have a hard time reducing it even if you wanted to. Typically, we provide that feedback by charging for resource use, and that works extremely well (most recent anecdote from my area: as the local rented garden community started measuring water usage and splitting the bill by usage instead of head count, usage dropped by 70% without any damage by under-watering), but that's generally a longer-term aggregate and immediate feedback works much better.
- throwaway894345 6y agoIt’s kind of gamification, at least the bit about explicit positive reinforcement. But “neutral” feedback loops are inherently positively reinforcing, as your anecdote indicates. I don’t like the gamification of everything either, but if the fate of the planet hinges on it (it doesn’t), I suppose I could stomach it.
- luckylion 6y agoI don't mind gamification personally. I'll do it to myself, even if it's just the harmless kind of "just keep running until you've reached that tree ... now that tree over there" to keep me going. Gamification works even if you know that it's gamification. I agree that it brings up ethical issues when you're using gamification for behavior modification of others, but on the other hand it's also a bit like communication (as in "you cannot not communicate", the absence of a signal is a signal as well), when you choose not to gamify something, you're choosing to strengthen the habits that are currently in place.
- 6y ago
- bchanudet 6y agoI've found such a device once in a hostel in Germany. The device was from Amphiro. [0] Being that hostels focus on savings, I understood why such a device could be useful. As for myself, after a day-long trip it ended up being a frustating shower. The thresholds were so low that you have to take a Navy shower to have a good grade. And the polar bear display reminded me that Germany is mostly coal-powered and that a KWh here has a much bigger impact on the environment than a KWh from France. I got out of the shower cold, wet, and worst of all, not feeling clean. I wondered if it would not have been better not to take a shower at all. It sure would have saved more water and energy. [0]: https://www.amphiro.com/en/ https://www.amphiro.com/en/
- _0ffh 6y agoWell a quick search turns up about 29.3% coal, that's a lot compared to specifically France (1.8%). That's because France is crazy into nuclear (71.6%) which the green movement made wildly unpopular in Germany (13.7%). To add one more comparison point, US is 23.5% coal and 19.7% nuclear. Natural gas is 10.5% in Germany, 7.7% in France, and 38.4% in the US. Used these sources: [1] D https://strom-report.de/strom/ https://strom-report.de/strom/ [2] F https://www.planete-energies.com/en/medias/close/france-s-overall-energy-mix https://www.planete-energies.com/en/medias/close/france-s-ov... [3] US https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=427&t=3 https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=427&t=3
- Confiks 6y agoI too discovered the device in a German hotel. For first-time users, it seems gamified towards the opposite goal. As I was under the shower for far longer than normal, I found out it was slowly drowning a polar bear.
- netsharc 6y agoA patronizing talking device would just make me swear at it every time I see it. But give me charts and graphs, and show me "You spent this much money for water/heating this week", and people will probably also be incentivized to save.
- mmm_grayons 6y agoThis is certainly an interesting idea, but what's the initial value proposition to customers? How do you convince someone to pay extra to install such an appliance?
- WillPostForFood 6y agoWe already get the feedback, in the utility bill. If people ignore it is because the prices are too low for water and power.
- chadlavi 6y agoA lot of people don't directly see that. For example if you rent in NYC, you have probably never seen how much water you consume, because the landlord pays the water bill. You might not even directly pay some other utilities like heat and hot water (a lot of apartment buildings have a single boiler for the entire building's heat and hot water).
- helsinkiandrew 6y agoAgreed, also if my shower had a button that turned the water on for thirty seconds, I’d use it for a Navy shower
- mydongle 6y agoPeople will probably just learn to ignore the meter. If mist showers are so good for the environment, they should install them into every home for free, or even pay people to do it. Too many times the environmental friendly solution costs $$$, pricing out the majority of people, so only wealthy and hip people could afford to use them and virtue signal on social media about it.