5 ms·
Sigh... Amazon needs to let prices rise. The market elastic goods is dictated purely by second and third order consequences. When prices go up, people realize
by exabrial 6y ago
Sigh... Amazon needs to let prices rise. The market elastic goods is dictated purely by second and third order consequences.
When prices go up, people realize there's more money to be made. More sellers/manufacturers enter the marketplace in response, increasing the overall supply pool and eventually causing a price crash.
Conversely, limiting prices rewards hoarders as they can justify their actions. It also rewards antisocial actors by constraining supply an increasing the amount of time they can be profitable. Finally it delays the onset of the price crash keeping prices high and making sure the poor can't afford said goods.
Also keep in mind stuff like hand sanitizer, lysol wipes, and tp all have replacements. Soap has been shown to be more effective than hand sanitizer, and bleach on a reusable rag is more effective effective than lysol... And for the last one I'll just let you figure it out ;)
- strstr 6y agoPrice gouging does cause users to associate the site with high prices. Particularly when third party sellers aren’t transparent about MSRP. Amazon risks losing customers to physical shops if they become known for being 3x+ as expensive. Amazon could start posting “surge price” ratios ala early Uber, so users can realize what’s going on, but realistically we are in a fairly unusual circumstance at the moment. Most gouging hasn’t lasted long for staples. There’s a bunch of off brand hand sanitizers/masks that have popped up in Seattle. The market has adjusted, and I’m not convinced gouging would have gotten us here faster. The toilet paper I bought is labelled in Korean, which is wacky, but it’s still TP. Producers can read through the lines, and ramp up production. If it was worth doing fewer at a particular price, it’s almost certainly worth doing 2x more at that same price (or, even better, with small reasonable multiplier). If a producer starts charging too much, other brands will eventually pop up to eat their lunch, so I suspect they won’t get too greedy during a short term spike.
- take_a_breath 6y ago== Price gouging does cause users to associate the site with high prices. Particularly when third party sellers aren’t transparent about MSRP. Amazon risks losing customers to physical shops if they become known for being 3x+ as expensive.== If I go to a marketplace in the real world, I don’t associate the vendor’s individual prices with the entity that runs the market. In a real marketplace wouldn’t we expect a vendor to notice the price gouging and take advantage of the arbitrage opportunity? Maybe Amazon isn’t really a marketplace?
- macNchz 6y agoI’d be curious to know what proportion of Amazon shoppers actually grok the fact that Amazon is a marketplace of many sellers. I was a longtime Prime member until last year, and spent a good amount of time discussing my concerns about the platform with family and friends before ultimately canceling. My impression from those conversations is that many folks just see Amazon as “Amazon” and have no real concept of who they’re actually buying from. A physical market in the real world makes it incredibly obvious who you’re shopping with, and that it’s independent of the marketplace itself. Amazon’s UI is clearly designed not to make this distinction, so marketplace seller behavior reflects more on the Amazon brand than it might otherwise.
- take_a_breath 6y agoSounds like another example of Amazon wanting to look like a marketplace (for regulatory reasons?) but not necessarily act like one.
- jariel 6y agoYou're mixing long-run and short-run economics. Factories and producers do not react to 'spikes'. When the time required to tool/re-tool is considerably longer than market corrections, then this goes out the window. Gouging is a thing, it's definitely not in Amazon's interest to allow it to happen, they make really not much more and the blow-back could be bad.
- chillacy 6y agoTo draw an analogy to the stock markets, long term growth or decline based on fundamentals is the market pricing a company’s profit potential. Gouging is something more like a short term pump and dump scheme. The SEC doesn’t appreciate the latter and has mechanisms in place to prevent them.
- erik_seaberg 6y agoThey didn't scale up the factory (or more likely the warehouse) because they knew the price would never be allowed to rise enough to pay off the investment. You have to charge extra for dipping into reserve capacity if you're going to compete with the leanest vendors who have none.
- Nursie 6y agoGouging denies essentials to people who need them that can't afford "surge" pricing. It's unethical in times of emergency, when the response needed is too short term for more capacity to be spun up to meet immediate needs. It allows the worried (wealthy) well to buy up supplies needed by petty, inconsequential bodies like health services. So no, Amazon does not need to let prices rise.
- ric2b 6y agoNot gouging also denies essentials to the same people, because the problem is the shortage but with low prices some people will buy larger quantities and leave less for others.
- Nursie 6y ago> Not gouging also denies essentials to the same people No, it doesn't, especially when used in combination with controls on the amounts bought or who can buy. Greed is not always good, however much you try to contort yourself to believe so.
- curryst 6y agoIt does work in some cases. I need some bleach to help clean out the condensation line in my AC unit. I looked and Amazon's lowest price that I could get in a short amount of time was around $30/gallon. I pretty quickly decided that hot water was working well enough for the moment. It also doesn't really prevent gouging, it just moves it to a private market. I'm fairly confident I could get toilet paper at any time on eBay if I needed it and was willing to pay the prices. The same people who cannot afford the gouged prices likely do not have a schedule flexible enough to constantly check whether the grocery store has toilet paper in stock. Meanwhile, those of us with cushy tech jobs can check out for 15 minutes to go check if there's toilet paper in the store. I think the unfortunate reality is that nothing short of rationing adequately addresses the problem. Rationing has it's own set of issues.