5 ms·
Taking some arbitrary definition of the word "hacker" and interpreting that rather freely makes the title look like click-bait.
by tgv 6y ago
Taking some arbitrary definition of the word "hacker" and interpreting that rather freely makes the title look like click-bait.
- claes-magnus 6y agoAren't all definitions arbitrary? If we would only go by how words are used 'in general', who would want to be a 'hacker'? ;) And I don't think the definition of 'hacker' in The Jargon File is just... arbitrary in the context of Hacker News? However, I am guilty as charged of making a very free, playful interpretation. Also, I am guilty as charged for trying to have a title that makes some people curious. I am sorry you did not like the post, but that's life! Cheers and thank you very much for reading!
- iammyIP 6y agoyes, all definitions are arbitrary.
- ozim 6y agoYes and people should try to skip definitions without context. If you have technical document or research paper there are definitions at the start which are defined for the scope of a document or a paper. Those are still arbitrary but at least they have some value.
- iammyIP 6y agoubo glod floz ut inur tztzzt wrt?
- retsibsi 6y agoAnd yet we get your point, thereby undermining it!
- cl0rkster 6y agoFirst off, having a seven year old, I thank you for your words. They resonate with me. I think perhaps arguing about the arbitrary nature of definitions will devolve into pedantry. While you are completely correct (e.g. the meaning of "toilet" over time). There is perhaps a better current arbitrary word (mouth hole sound) that implies something deeper. There are immutable essences (or platonic forms) that cannot change that we have been describing with different language since the very beginning. It kind of reminds me of that scene in the matrix where Neo meets the machine father with his daughter who tells him how "love" is just a word. What it implies is what matters. It doesn't matter how you describe it visually or audibly, if you are communicating with someone else, and they are trying to understand you, the reason they ever can is because something exists independent of either communicator, and both have recognized that thing and are willing to acknowledge that.
- claes-magnus 6y agoGlad to hear so! About the later part: yes, I actually agree!
- cl0rkster 6y agoIf you missed it, that was my best 7-year old hack at Greek philosophy :)
- lowwave 6y agoI feel like words like 'hacker' or 'ai' is really becoming buzz words, just so writers can write articles for click-bait.
- claes-magnus 6y agoSome people contribute to the Web with opinions using cutesy one-liners, some people attempt to explore subject matters in articles and thus sometimes fail, sometimes succeed.
- gabordemooij 6y agoGive any word to a salesman and he turns it into crap. Words like AI and hacker mean nothing anymore.
- claes-magnus 6y agoHaha! I enjoyed your elegant reply. And yes, you're quite possibly right. When writing it I had many doubts, and they have still not left me. Perhaps this text did should not have been published.
- whatshisface 6y agoI'm writing a blog post titled, "if you think about it, hackers are kind of like AIs."
- midnightmonster 6y agoThis feels like a weird place to draw the line on a site intentionally and pedantically named with a not-most-popular definition of “hacker”.
- mjklin 6y agoFun fact: in Chinese the movie “The Matrix” is known as 黑客帝国 or “Hacker Empire”.