3 ms·
> The last side door for smart noncomformist kids is now being slammed shut. How does a standardized test benefit nonconformists? I strongly disagree with elim
by MattGaiser 6y ago
> The last side door for smart noncomformist kids is now being slammed shut.
How does a standardized test benefit nonconformists? I strongly disagree with eliminating the SAT, but always viewed success at it as requiring one to conform to a certain template. You need to shift your thinking patterns and your style to match what test writers want.
Wouldn't nonconformists have some of the more interesting extracurriculars and essays, things which have increased in value?
I agree with the part about smart kids being disadvantaged by the SAT going away, but nonconformists and smart people are not the same thing.
- CDRdude 6y ago> I agree with the part about smart kids being disadvantaged by the SAT going away, but nonconformists and smart people are not the same thing. In this context, "smart noncomformist kids" refers to the intersection of "smart kids" and "nonconformist kids". The proposition of this sentence is that college admissions officers will reject all the nonconformist kids because they can't tell which ones are smart.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dntbnmpls 6y ago> How does a standardized test benefit nonconformists? Because it's an objective standard? You don't have to kiss your teacher's ass for good grades, you don't have to conform to extracurriculars to boost your standing, you don't have to frame your essay to win favors from the reader, etc. It's the only test that you don't depend on anyone else for. > but nonconformists and smart people are not the same thing. That's why he wrote "smart nonconformist kids". The intersection of smart kids and nonconformist kids.