5 ms·
The problem with price gouging is that it opens doors to people hoarding supplies and reselling them at higher cost. Sitting in an armchair reselling things at
by dheera 6y ago
The problem with price gouging is that it opens doors to people hoarding supplies and reselling them at higher cost. Sitting in an armchair reselling things at a higher price is an inefficient allocation of resources during a pandemic, prevents people in need from being able to access those resources, and is an all-around waste of someone's two hands reselling things when they could be using those hands to directly do social good instead.
It doesn't help the world at all if only rich people are able to afford certain things like disinfectant and PPE; the virus is far more effectively controlled if everyone, no matter their socioeconomic class, has access to these things.
- goodside 6y agoWhile free-market pricing may create an incentive to hoard for resale, price ceilings also create an incentive to hoard for personal use. If I’m on the fence about whether I might need an N95 mask soon, and I learn they’re being sold at below-market prices due to ceilings, I’ll hoard because I’m worried they soon won’t be available at any price. I’m motivated to forecast the duration of the shortage and stockpile what I think I might need. If I overestimate, I don’t turn into a reseller, I just swallow the storage cost until I use them. When someone hoards for resale they can at least liquidate their oversupply to other customers, even if not at the price they hoped for. Prices don’t just discriminate between rich and poor, they discriminate between desperate needs and casual wants. Everyone agrees it’s a good thing for the poor to have access to things they desperately need, but price controls also ensure that wealthy people can buy lots of the available supply on a whim. Someone with a mold remediation business might be willing to stockpile thousands of N95’s if available at pre-COVID prices — storage is cheap, and they’ll be used eventually. But if they’re being sold at a 5x the normal price, they’re motivated to stretch their current supply through re-use and buy only what they immediately need. That’s why price controls and rationing should always happen at the same time, and the severity of price controls is constrained by the effectiveness of rationing. If you can easily defeat rationing (e.g. ordering from multiple online stores) it’s as though it doesn’t exist. In those cases, market prices make more sense for ensuring availability.
- erik_seaberg 6y agoPrice controls are the reason no retailer had extra warehouses full of toilet paper and hand sanitizer. They can only make short-term decisions when we don't allow long bets to pay for themselves.
- goodside 6y agoToilet paper also has relatively high storage costs and low shipping costs compared to other goods, which skews things. It obviously doesn’t spoil, but it’s physically large for how cheap it is and presents a fire hazard in bulk quantities. A typical consumer could actually afford to fill their home with stockpiled toilet paper until it becomes unlivable if they really wanted to, which isn’t true of most consumer goods. There’s also subtleties related to the segregation of consumer and commercial toilet paper markets.
- sokoloff 6y agoTP has relatively high shipping cost, especially as compared to its value. Dimensional pricing (charging by volume) is what kills you trying to ship TP.
- goodside 6y agoFor consumers you’re definitely right, but I don’t think this is true when buying by the truckload. Paper manufacturers produce both very high-density products (office paper) and very low-density products (toilet paper). Office paper is so dense that you have to ship it in trucks that are half-empty due to safety regulations on truck weight, so I’d expect a customer that needs both products can receive toilet paper in the same truck without much marginal increase in fuel consumption. I don’t work in the industry though, so I admit I’m mostly speculating.
- ghaff 6y agoDo you seriously believe that Scott Paper would keep warehouses of TP laying around if only they knew that they could charge $5 a roll if there were a shortage for some reason? Honestly, large manufacturers/retailers are probably the least likely to price gouge because, laws aside, any extra profit that, say, Home Depot can make by selling snow shovels for $50 before an unexpected early blizzard is 1.) Trivial for their overall bottom line and 2.) Likely to result in a very expensive reputational hit.
- BurningFrog 6y agoWith price controls, what happens is not that everyone has access to things. It's that they sell out, and no one can buy any.
- colejohnson66 6y agoSo we need price controls and rationing.
- BurningFrog 6y agoThat's a classic approach. Better that only price controls, probably. But I believe the free market will handle it best.
- devit 6y agoReselling at higher price is only profitable if the original seller are selling at a price that is too low because they failed to raise the price properly, and in that case the resellers are correcting the prices. The advantage of having higher prices is that only people who REALLY need an article will buy it, so limited supplies will go to them. For instance, if FFP2 masks are in a limited supply and cost $0.01 each, then everyone is going to try to buy in lots of 1000, and they will run out immediately, with the supply going to random people who probably will not even use most of them. But if FFP2 masks cost $100 each, then people will buy and use them only when strictly needed, and they will be available for those who absolutely need them and are thus willing to pay any amount of money. The only problems are: - People who irrationally try to price gouge when the price is already correct, costing themselves money and making the article unavailable - The potential inability of people who are highly needy to obtain loans or have sufficient basic income to purchase high-priced supplies The former is fixed by providing the forecasts that are used to set prices, thus providing a credible insight that there will be no shortage at current prices, while the latter by having better ways of ensuring that loans are repaid and generally making it easier to give out loans.
- cortesoft 6y agoPrice controls also encourage hoarding, though, because there is no cost to buying too much now. Take toilet paper; people hoarded it, because it wasn't more expensive than normal and people feared they wouldn't be able to buy more in the future. If the price went up, people might only buy what they need, because there is an extra cost to buying more than you need now, when the price might return to normal in the future.