3 ms·
But you’re not car shopping and this isn’t a Ferrari vs. Corolla scenario. If you read the article, you’ll see that the Universities did give partial refunds.
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
But you’re not car shopping and this isn’t a Ferrari vs. Corolla scenario.
If you read the article, you’ll see that the Universities did give partial refunds. These students are demanding even more refunds, while still collecting the education.
The education is still delivered, just through a different medium. If we believe that engineers can work just as effectively remotely, why can’t we believe that educators and educate just as effectively remotely? It feels like HN is picking and choosing when remote is good vs. bad based on how it personally benefits the commenter.
- asutekku 6y agoPeople do not pay to get only the education. Yes, it is a prominent part of it but more important are the facilities, the community and the networking capabilities. With remote teaching, everything else except learning is lost. There’s no reason to pay the sums the universities are charging considering you can get the same education from almost any university.
- PragmaticPulp 6y ago> There’s no reason to pay the sums the universities are charging considering you can get the same education from almost any university. I think you’re arguing against something other than the Coronavirus and remote education situation at this point.
- asutekku 6y agoNo I am not. Due the current circumstances, the universities are not able to provide the facilities and the networking capabilities to the students so they should not be required to pay the full amount. Also, as the students are going to be home anyway, the differences between universities shrink. If the education is somewhat similar in a university A and university B, but university A is five times more expensive during the normal times, why should the students of university A pay five times as much as the students at the university B. They have lost the reason why they pay so much for it.
- gbear605 6y agoI believe three things: 1) In a normal situation, some people are equally productive or more productive working remotely, and they should be able to. 2) In the current situation, almost everyone is less productive working from home, because they weren’t prepared and they have to deal with other stresses (family at home, too small of a space, fear of infection, etc.) 3) In the current situation, educators are less able to teach online than they would in person in a normal situation, and similarly students aren’t able to learn as effectively. It can both be true that working remotely in a normal situation should be an option while this situation makes it harder to get a good education.
- mikeg8 6y agoRemote work in engineering is completely different then remote learning. Engineers are self-directed, a particular type of thinker. Maybe the professors are just as effective at performing remote work, but that does not mean that all students can just flip a switch a perform at the same levels.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoAs a manager of remote teams, I can assure you that not all engineers are adept at working remotely. It’s fairly elitist to declare that engineers are good at remote work while assuming that students are not. You can’t make blanket statements about engineers while simultaneously arguing that students are too diverse for the same treatment.
- mikeg8 6y agoI never implied all remote engineers would be adept at remote work, but I'd easily argue that engineers, as a group, would be more adept at remote work than most other professions, including a group of college students.