4 ms·
> in a lot of cases the money has already been spent Then they can take out loans or go bankrupt. I mean, if you paid for a Ferrari and the car dealer can onl
by michaelt 6y ago
> in a lot of cases the money has already been spent
Then they can take out loans or go bankrupt.
I mean, if you paid for a Ferrari and the car dealer can only give you a Corolla, they owe you a refund - irrespective of how big their rent and salary bills may be.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoIf they were forced to choose between going bankrupt and having traditional in-person classes, they would be offering in-person classes right now and allowing people to “opt-out” to the remote version. These companies aren’t arbitrarily choosing to educate people remotely. They’re adapting to the situation. Likewise, it would be unreasonable for employers to cut people’s compensation for working remotely under the assumption that remote work is less efficient and therefore the company deserves a refund.
- gowld 6y agoSalary is governed by contract. People get pay cuts all the time.
- klmadfejno 6y ago> These companies aren’t arbitrarily choosing to educate people remotely. They’re adapting to the situation. That doesn't really matter though. Like, it sucks, but they're giving a much shittier product and charging full price. Your example about people being less productive is not relevant because there's no doubt that the quality of education is much worse.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoDo you feel the same way about engineers working remotely? Is someone working remotely and communicating over Zoom delivering significantly lower quality work and therefore deserving of a lower compensation? Your assumption that there’s “no doubt” about the quality of education being worse is not a good assumption. Educators are working overtime to make the most of the remote learning situation.
- gbear605 6y agoEducators are working their best, but that doesn’t mean that it is equal, because the stresses that have been put on students and educators are significant and can’t easily be worked around. Also some things are simply impossible to do remotely, like music lessons or chemistry labs.
- klmadfejno 6y agoYou keep implying that the schools are doing their best in a trying time and deserve sympathy. Sure, that's fine. They're not acting in bad faith. But they aren't acting fairly. If the reason you went to a school was it had a cool robot building program, and you don't get to build any robots, that's clearly not what was offered to you. An online college is not worth the price of an in person college and it is very, very unfair to these students who are paying fortunes to get them. Much more unfair to the massively indebted students than the bureaucratically overbudgeted schools. Employed engineers working remotely is a really bad analogy because engineers are paid to be available on an ongoing basis. Contract workers are a much better fit. If they were a contract worker, contracted to complete a specific task, and they don't complete the task... they don't get paid. COVID or otherwise. There is a wealth of pretty reasonable legal literature of settling disputes over partial completion of work. > "While closing campus and transitioning to online classes was the right thing for Defendants to do, this decision deprived Plaintiff and the other members of the Classes from recognizing the benefits of in-person instruction, access to campus facilities, student activities, and other benefits and services in exchange for which they had already paid fees and tuition." Note things like "campus facilities". Obviously 0% of that thing that they paid for was provided. And it should be reimbursed.
- michaelt 6y agoAnd maybe a car dealer couldn't deliver your Ferrari due to difficult circumstances beyond their control, and giving you a Corolla is the best they can adapt to the situation. But they're still only delivering a Corolla so you don't have to pay the price of the Ferrari they promised you
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoBut you’re not car shopping and this isn’t a Ferrari vs. Corolla scenario. If you read the article, you’ll see that the Universities did give partial refunds. These students are demanding even more refunds, while still collecting the education. The education is still delivered, just through a different medium. If we believe that engineers can work just as effectively remotely, why can’t we believe that educators and educate just as effectively remotely? It feels like HN is picking and choosing when remote is good vs. bad based on how it personally benefits the commenter.
- asutekku 6y agoPeople do not pay to get only the education. Yes, it is a prominent part of it but more important are the facilities, the community and the networking capabilities. With remote teaching, everything else except learning is lost. There’s no reason to pay the sums the universities are charging considering you can get the same education from almost any university.
- PragmaticPulp 6y ago> There’s no reason to pay the sums the universities are charging considering you can get the same education from almost any university. I think you’re arguing against something other than the Coronavirus and remote education situation at this point.
- asutekku 6y agoNo I am not. Due the current circumstances, the universities are not able to provide the facilities and the networking capabilities to the students so they should not be required to pay the full amount. Also, as the students are going to be home anyway, the differences between universities shrink. If the education is somewhat similar in a university A and university B, but university A is five times more expensive during the normal times, why should the students of university A pay five times as much as the students at the university B. They have lost the reason why they pay so much for it.
- ralph84 6y agoEmployers are cutting people’s compensation. In any case, completely different scenarios. Except in very rare cases, employers don’t make huge upfront payments before the work is done. College students do.
- MattGaiser 6y agoDid the contract specify in person?