4 ms·
If they built the Great Pyramid in the advertised 20 years, that means placing a 2.5-ton block every 4th minute, 24 hours a day, 365 days a year. If they stoppe
by ncmncm 6y ago
If they built the Great Pyramid in the advertised 20 years, that means placing a 2.5-ton block every 4th minute, 24 hours a day, 365 days a year. If they stopped at sundown, it's every 2 minutes. If they broke half the year to farm, that's one each minute. But let's guess they had enough surplus to work year-round; so, 2 minutes.
Suppose they took 600 years, instead; then it's one per hour.
Which is harder to imagine, cutting, moving, lifting and placing 30 blocks in every waking hour for 20 years, or placing one per waking hour, non-stop, for 600 years? Each seems less possible than the other.
I don't know of any firm evidence for when any of the pyramids were built. We can guess that the bent and red pyramids were built first, but they could just as easily be poor copies attempted a thousand years later, or ten.
There is a fluorescence technique to discover when a cut limestone face that has been covered for centuries was last exposed to sunlight, but I don't know of it being used on any Great Pyramid block. One would not expect Egyptologists to advocate for such a test, because only two outcomes are possible: they were far enough off to be embarrassed; or not, and it was useless. (Either way, better not.)
They built these things with perfectly straight, slanting tunnels a few inches wide running from inner chambers almost to the surface, for no known reason. Some people say they point at certain mythologically important stars on equinoctal days, but I have not been able to get confirmation of that.
One thing well established is that none of them were tombs. When somebody finally battered their way into each, maybe 4300+ years later, all the chambers were empty and unmarked. (Except one has an empty stone box in it big enough to be a coffin or bathtub.)
There are lots of examples of 20-, 30-, 60-ton basalt boxes cut from living rock with perfect right-angled inside corners, and moved through funerary complex tunnels barely big enough. Take off the (10-ton) lid and they're empty. It's anybody's guess what they were for.
- idoubtit 6y agoParallelization is not a concept that appears around 2010 when low-end computers gained multiple cores. Most of the blocks were at the bottom levels, where it was easy to put them in place. Teams moving hundreds of blocks simultaneously wouldn't be surprising. This addresses the first point, and I don't want to react to what follows, especially the theory that all archaeologists are in a conspiracy to hide the truth.
- ReptileMan 6y agoThe hardest part for me is the engineering of the building. The quarywork and positioning is a matter of having enough labor, carrots and sticks. But to imagine, make plans, adhere to them is hard.
- ncmncm 6y agoNobody suggested "all archaeologists are in a conspiracy". Egyptologists represent a very small slice of the population of archaeologists, but that subfield is deeply political.
- stallmanite 6y agoAs a cynic it wouldn’t surprise me but are you saying that Egyptologists as group have no interest in determining the truth scientifically? I could see the incentives you describe holding for the current “big dogs” but couldn’t a defector quietly perform the experiment and then gain notoriety and status by presenting the proof to the (presumably) more honest wider archaeological research community?
- ncmncm 6y agoThe dating technique is "surface luminescence" (I misrecalled the name). The only text I have found dating Giza stonework may be seen at <https://sci-hub.tw/10.1016/j.culher.2014.05.007> https://sci-hub.tw/10.1016/j.culher.2014.05.007>, published in the peer-reviewed "Journal of Cultural Heritage 16 (2015) 134–150". It includes a date from the Mykerinus (Menkaure) pyramid, the smallest on the Giza plateau, and presumed youngest, of 3450±950 BC, or 4400-2500 BC, compared to current estimates of 2613-2494 BC. A sample from the Valley Temple, presumed contemporaneous with the Great Pyramid, says 3060±470 BC, or 3530-2590 BC, with the same estimated age. One could interpret the measurements as corroborating the estimates, but only by squinting. It just seems notable that more work hasn't been done on, e.g., the Great Pyramid itself.