3 ms·
> If twitter is no longer just providing a platform for its users to provide content but is now providing content itself, then yes, it should be held to the sta
by mindslight 6y ago
> If twitter is no longer just providing a platform for its users to provide content but is now providing content itself, then yes, it should be held to the standards of a publisher, much in the same way it is responsible legally for the ads it publishes.
Every website provides their own content alongside user generated content. As you point out, Twitter is responsible for the ads they publish, as they're the party publishing them. Likewise, Twitter is responsible for the content of the disclaimer they put on Trump's shitpost, which was quite reserved. This is already the longstanding case.
This new line of argument is akin to saying that HN should be directly responsible for all users' comments because dang downvoted a post. It's nothing more than a hamfisted outburst by Trump trying to remove the protection from a company as some sort of summary punishment because the executive doesn't like what the company itself has said.
If this were a bill before congress, it would be worrying. As it stands, it's just pathetic. At least this instance of Trump not listening to expert advisors just results in us having to read and debate his tripe, rather than another 100,000 Americans dying.
- tathougies 6y ago> This new line of argument is akin to saying that HN should be directly responsible for all users' comments because dang downvoted a post. It's nothing more than a hamfisted outburst by Trump trying to remove the protection from a company as some sort of summary punishment because the executive doesn't like what the company itself has said. How is wanting twitter -- who is now scrutinizing and editing their user's posts -- to now be held up to the standards of a publisher (which is literally someone who publishes information written by others after having reviewed it) a 'new line of argument'? If HN were to actually start to modify user's posts, not because of voting but because of internal processes, then yes, HN should probably be held to the standard of a publisher. You can't just decide that regulations don't apply to you because you have more writers than the standard publisher.