3 ms·
That arguably changes when the President starts to use it as a primary means of communication with the citizenry.
by CamperBob2 6y ago
That arguably changes when the President starts to use it as a primary means of communication with the citizenry.
- rbanffy 6y agoThey didn't remove his message. They merely pointed out it was misinforming the public. Speaking of which, shouldn't we make it a crime to lie or substantially mislead the public while holding public office?
- CamperBob2 6y agoYeah, I don't disagree with their actions in this case -- if anything, they didn't phrase it strongly enough. ("Get the facts about voting by mail," as opposed to "Caution: this Tweet is unadulterated horseshit.") But I also think that the more Twitter is used to disintermediate political communication, the more it starts to look like a vital public utility. It's tough to say where the line will or should be drawn. I don't envy Jack Dorsey's position, that's for sure. As far as making a law that prohibits politicians from lying to the public, I don't see a way to write a law like that without making the situation even worse.
- Izkata 6y ago> "Caution: this Tweet is unadulterated horseshit." Except it's not. Trump is right here; most of the confirmed voter fraud is on mail-in and absentee ballots, despite being less used than in-person in the past decades. Switching everyone to mail-in will cause a sharp uptick in voter fraud.
- jessaustin 6y agoI hear this from friends who are Limbaugh fans, but I'd like to see some other source. Many people on the Left seem to think this whole "voter fraud" concern is a fig leaf for denying minorities their voting rights. When I've listened and asked follow-up questions, the Left's narrative seems more plausible.
- Izkata 6y agoPDF of individual confirmed cases: https://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/whitehouse.gov/files/docs/pacei-voterfraudcases.pdf https://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/whitehouse.gov/files/docs/p... Spot-checking and using search for counts, most are manipulation of mail-in or absentee ballots (many being a bunch of ballots by a single person), with the next highest looking like individual people voting who didn't realize they were ineligible.
- CamperBob2 6y agoOK, now where's the .PDF of individual confirmed cases of in-person vote fraud versus vote-by-mail fraud? We can't compare fractions by their numerators, you know. The document itself admits that it is "only a sampling," which, in the absence of further methodological detail, should raise their hairs on the back of your neck. Nobody ever said that vote-by-mail is fraud proof, only that it's good enough. Which it indisputably is, at least as implemented here in Washington state.
- Izkata 6y ago> only that it's good enough Well.. How about another case I just learned of today? 'Cause it kinda doesn't seem like we're even at "good enough": > “Invalidate the election. Let’s do it again,” said Rev. Kenneth Clayton said amid reports more that 20 percent of all ballots were disqualified, some in connection with voter fraud allegations. [..] > In addition to apparent problems with the vote count in Paterson, NBC New York has shown video of ballots left out in building lobbies, of one voter handling many ballots, and reported on postal workers reporting finding hundreds of ballots at a time stuffed in mailboxes in Paterson – and even in a neighboring town, Haledon. https://www.nbcnewyork.com/news/politics/nj-naacp-leader-calls-for-paterson-mail-in-vote-to-be-canceled-amid-fraud-claims/2435162/ https://www.nbcnewyork.com/news/politics/nj-naacp-leader-cal...
- CamperBob2 6y ago'Data' isn't the plural of 'anecdote.' What are the actual statistics? Do we even have access to statistics that haven't been cherry-picked by the Heritage Foundation, the DNC, or another interested party? One good aspect of the vote-by-mail system we use here in WA is that the voter retains a code they can use to verify that their ballot has been counted. There is an auditable paper trail at every step that's accessible to all parties - the voter, the election officials, and the candidate. That's more than you get with many in-person voting systems, especially those involving closed-source machines made by companies with questionable ethics and engineering practices. Yes, I'm sure it's possible to build a vote-by-mail system that is more prone to corruption than in-person voting. But the point is, it's not necessary.
- perl4ever 6y agoMy understanding is that he supported the concerns about fraud with a specific lie (maybe more than one) about how the state authorities are sending out ballots to everyone, whereas they are only sending them to registered voters. This could, and presumably is intended to, mislead people on both sides of the political spectrum. Assuming for the sake of argument that someone could be trying to promote a fundamental truth using lies, it doesn't make it sane to trust or acquiesce as a result of lies. Maybe in our brave new world, disbelieving in something because it is supported with lies is an example of an ad hominem fallacy?
- newacct583 6y ago> Except it's not. Trump is right here; most of the confirmed voter fraud is on mail-in and absentee ballots, Thomas Bayes is screaming in his grave, something about cancer diagnoses... Actually I don't know if that's even true. And almost all the significant cases of any kind of election fraud aren't about ballots at all. It's stuff like voting in the wrong jurisdiction, or count fraud, or registration fraud. Please cite me where you got the info that most election crime is from remote voting. That info doesn't exist. What does exist is the facts in the WaPo article that twitter linked, which show that effectively zero mail-in ballot fraud is happening.
- username90 6y ago> They didn't remove his message. They merely pointed out it was misinforming the public. Why should a private company have this power? I don't think that people who run a successful website automatically are qualified to fact check the president and insert blurbs directly in his messages. That needs to be regulated some way.
- rbanffy 6y agoIf you are using my product to harm others, I should have the right to try to minimize the damage you cause.
- username90 6y agoThis tool is not regulated, they could use it to cause harm. It doesn't matter if it was used for good this one time. And no, them being a private company doesn't matter. Currently they have a lot of power thanks to them having a lot of important users, and now that they are starting to use that power we need to quickly come up with regulations for it.
- perl4ever 6y agoYour tone is as if they were editing his message. I don't believe they were doing that in a way that would create any confusion as to what he wrote, were they?
- username90 6y agoIt doesn't matter, they didn't post a message like everyone else instead they made an official statement using their own privileged way. It is fine to do it on this message, I don't see the harm, but if this continues and people gets used to that blurb then Twitter will definitely start misusing it sooner or later. I don't think that companies should have this kind of power to influence public discourse, I might not agree with Trump but I really think that we need to limit the power big tech companies have.
- 6y ago