6 ms·
>it’s about ethics and morals and how we compose a society with mighty power imbalances, fortified by new tech. But that's not what this is really about. This
by krapp 6y ago
>it’s about ethics and morals and how we compose a society with mighty power imbalances, fortified by new tech.
But that's not what this is really about.
This is about the President being angry that Twitter fact checked him and using executive power to create a chilling effect against any platform doing so in the future. It's about fears of a nonexistent conspiracy controlling the media becoming the basis for authoritarian laws meant to stamp out that menace - a phenomenon which never goes well, historically. It's about Americans hating "the left" so much that they'll support an obvious violation of the First Amendment as long as it silences their ideological enemies.
- akira2501 6y ago> This is about the President being angry that Twitter fact checked him and using executive power to create a chilling effect against any platform doing so in the future. That is the impetus in this case, but that doesn't mean it doesn't border on questions we've been slowly grappling with for some time now, nor does it mean we have to ignore that question. > the basis for authoritarian laws meant to stamp out that menace I'm not sure it's authoritarian to remove their liability protections, is it? In a sense, I think it's an interesting question, if you're willing to editorialize content on behalf of your users why should you get safe-harbor protection? You clearly are willing to put the man power and technology into it, shouldn't you then be liable for content posted on your site? > It's about Americans hating "the left" so much that they'll support an obvious violation of the First Amendment as long as it silences their ideological enemies. What's the obvious First Amendment violation here? If you act as a conduit for certain types of speech, you're liable for that speech. We're just bringing "content neutral providers" into the same realm that everyone else already was.
- krapp 6y ago>I'm not sure it's authoritarian to remove their liability protections, is it? If the intent is to punish critics and suppress the speech of party opponents, then yes. Any authoritarian can justify their actions in abstract and general terms, but context matters. >nor does it mean we have to ignore that question. We don't have to ignore it, but we also don't have to accept an autocrat's temper tantrum by fiat as an answer. >What's the obvious First Amendment violation here? The purpose of the First Amendment is to prevent the government from infringing freedom of speech - the President is attempting to use government power to infringe freedom of speech, to do exactly what the First Amendment was created to prevent. Granted, the First Amendment only explicitly applies to Congress, but I feel like if states can be accused of violating it (as they often were regarding quarantine and shelter-at-home orders) then the President can as well.
- 2019-nCoV 6y ago> If the intent is to punish critics and suppress the speech of party opponents, then yes. Any authoritarian can justify their actions in abstract and general terms, but context matters. This is literally what Twitter has been doing. Trump's order puts an end to it. > We don't have to ignore it, but we also don't have to accept an autocrat's temper tantrum by fiat as an answer. Exactly why Twitter needs to be stripped of their 230 protections. > The purpose of the First Amendment is to prevent the government from infringing freedom of speech - the President is attempting to use government power to infringe freedom of speech, to do exactly what the First Amendment was created to prevent. This is the government upholding free speech. Twitter's policies and their selective enforcement of such run directly contrary to the underlying tenets of free speech. This holds Twitter accountable for their "un-American" practices. Although it may be hard to see through the vitriolic debates currently raging, this will be a net win for the internet. This will encourage decentralisation in so far as there is now a soft power cap on these big tech companies.
- thephyber 6y ago> This is literally what Twitter has been doing. Trump's order puts an end to it. Debatable, on both points. There have been studies[1] that show that accounts are banned, but it's not necessarily because they are conservative accounts or conservative content. In a civil or criminal case, causation must be established. In this case, the president is making it very much more expensive for certain companies to defend themselves. This EO is more likely to hurt YouTube than Twitter because it has the ability to get the Federal Government to no longer approve grants to Google subsidiaries and for government agencies to stop advertising with them. > to be stripped of their 203 protections. You mean The Communications Decency Act, Section 230? > Twitter's policies and their selective enforcement of such run directly contrary to the underlying tenets of free speech. That's interesting. Government law enforcers and prosecutors have the ability to use prosecutorial discretion. Are you saying that the government should be able to select who they prosecute, but that private organizations should not be allowed discretion to enforce their own contracts? If ISPs (where content in a pipe is pretty close to comparable to Common Carrier standards) can't be held up to the standards of Net Neutrality, how can social media companies (where content is much more subjective to interpret as violations of their contract)? > this will be a net win for the internet That remains to be seen. I can see it being another tool where the executive branch gets to unilaterally change the definition of which internet companies get protections, not leveling the playing field. > This will encourage decentralisation in so far as there is now a soft power cap on these big tech companies. More likely there will be some obvious "unintended consequences" similar to what happened after Trump signed the FOSTA bill in 2018[2] (hint: multiple dating sites, including Craigslist sections, closed up shop). It will very likely increase the cost of being a user-generated content host to the point that only a very select few companies would do it and they will all require arbitration clauses in the ToS to avoid extremely expensive litigation of the CDA230 rules. I expect a handful of forums and lots of news comments sections to close due to this "free speech" Executive Order. [1] https://www.cjr.org/the_media_today/platform-bias.php https://www.cjr.org/the_media_today/platform-bias.php [2] https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2018/03/23/596460672/craigslist-shuts-down-personals-section-after-congress-passes-bill-on-traffickin https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2018/03/23/596460672...
- anigbrowl 6y agoIf you act as a conduit for certain types of speech, you're liable for that speech. There's some merit to that position, but things like adding a fact check (which you might or might not agree with) do not incur any sort of civil or criminal liability. You make good points, but we should also engage with the reality that the president and his supporters are demanding a quality of representation/protection for their political views that they don't have any particular entitlement to, and for which no mechanism currently exists in law; it seems (going by the general tenor of their arguments over the last few years) like they want to bring back the 'Fairness Doctrine' that obtained for broadcast media up to the Reagan era to create some protected space for their viewpoint.
- perl4ever 6y agoI didn't know the Fairness Doctrine was a mechanism to prevent the juxtaposition of opposing views.
- thephyber 6y ago> to prevent the juxtaposition of opposing views The way I interpreted it, your parent comment was arguing the opposite of the way you framed it. It's a long run-on sentence, but the `;` is meant to be interpreted as "start a new sentence that is related to the previous one"
- perl4ever 6y agoI don't know what it was arguing. It seemed to be implying that the Fairness Doctrine created a protected space. Didn't it do the opposite?
- visarga 6y ago> You clearly are willing to put the man power and technology into it, shouldn't you then be liable for content posted on your site? Power and technology can't curate content to the level where you are safe from lawsuits. What you're saying is that if they are willing to do a bit of moderation they should do total moderation.
- jjcon 6y agoAgain, this has been drafted since at least last summer and has little to do with the recent twitter news. https://www.cnn.com/2020/05/28/politics/trump-twitter-social.. https://www.cnn.com/2020/05/28/politics/trump-twitter-social.... > consistent with a draft order whose text CNN first reported last summer
- joshuamorton 6y agoIf it has little to do with the recent twitter news, why is it signed today instead of last week?
- Mirioron 6y agoThey were probably waiting for one of the social media platforms to screw up somehow.
- FireBeyond 6y ago1. That link is broken. 2. What was drafted last summer was legislation. Legislation that would likely not stand up to political or legal resistance. This is an executive order to make an end-run around all that "bureaucracy". > has little to do with the recent twitter news. This fails the plausibility test. This came hot on the heels of this incident, Trump _said_ it was related to this incident, and that he'd be doing this as result, and the last several years are packed with a multitude of examples of exactly that: Trump knee-jerking an angry response (words, actions, both) to those who he deems to have slighted him.
- jjcon 6y agoCan’t edit so here is the fixed link https://www.cnn.com/2020/05/28/politics/trump-twitter-social-media-executive-order/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2020/05/28/politics/trump-twitter-social... And no it wasn’t legislation it was a draft of an executive order from last summer as mentioned in this article.