5 ms·
You have to pay the old telephone company and it's a lot more private communication than Twitter. Yet they had common carrier statis, which is how we should wan
by phkahler 6y ago
You have to pay the old telephone company and it's a lot more private communication than Twitter. Yet they had common carrier statis, which is how we should want ISPs regulated. Where twitter and friends fit simply hasn't been defined yet.
- komali2 6y agoThe argument falls apart at the ISP level - why does the UN consider internet a human right, but not, specifically, access to Twitter? It may seem like there's no distinction at all but it is there and it is important.
- threeseed 6y agoMuch better examples than Twitter. If I have the right to every website then how about password-protected ones. Do I then have the right to demand that Apple give me access to everyone's iCloud website ?
- rbanffy 6y agoBecause you need a phone to phone someone, call an ambulance or the police. You need an ISP to get to the internet. You don't need Twitter.
- sneak 6y agoForget Twitter, and substitute “gmail deliverability”? Without that, you cannot run a business.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rbanffy 6y agoDo you need Twitter to interact with your bank? To pay your taxes? To buy groceries? Is it the only way you have to reach your family?
- sneak 6y agoWhen my Twitter account was suspended recently after 12 years, I also lost access to my DM history, including usernames which I had not memorized. For some of my friends, Twitter was the only contact information I had for them. I have now totally lost the ability to communicate with those friends in the midst of a global emergency, even if I make a new account (which itself would be subject to immediate termination at any time), because I don’t know their usernames. A few of the closest ones fortunately noticed my absence without prompting, went to my profile, saw it suspended, went to my website (I presume it helped that my username, @sneakdotberlin, describes my website address), and emailed me. As for the busier or less attentive friends? No word yet. :( You can’t export your data or do “data takeout” from a suspended account, sadly, and you can’t view your DM history either inbound or outbound. EDIT: Also, I do need Twitter (and a high follower count) to meaningfully interact with my bank or my airline’s (or Google’s) customer service department. The 1-800-i’m-a-schnook line doesn’t seem to get things done.
- rbanffy 6y ago> You can’t export your data or do “data takeout” from a suspended account, sadly, and you can’t view your DM history either inbound or outbound. This is a big problem.
- thephyber 6y agoThat example seems like something you can fix yourself by keeping offline backups of content that you need (general gd practice for all digital content). More impactful would be access to any accounts which you only have access to with Twitter/Facebook/Google/etc federated login (like OAuth). It's very significant if you can't access your email/cloud/DNS accounts if you make a gray area ToS-violating comment/video on YouTube.
- 6y ago
- phkahler 6y ago>> Forget Twitter, and substitute “gmail deliverability”? Without that, you cannot run a business. I was going to say it's not really about access but censorship. Using gmail as an example is nice because I do appreciate their spam filtering which spammers might consider a form of censorship (lack of deliverability). And yet I'm against platforms like twitter censoring things. The spam situation quickly leads into another set of arguments with me about traceability.
- sneak 6y agoI imagine this is because you haven’t been bitten by missing critical emails due to gmail’s overzealous spam filtering. This has happened to me multiple times. Most people would likely never notice the opportunities they missed as a result of such. I’m talking about real live false positives, on important messages from real live human beings. Additionally, gmail spam folders even well run, nonspam, properly configured and secured mailservers AFAICT simply for not being part of the wider deliverability cartel.
- CamperBob2 6y agoThat arguably changes when the President starts to use it as a primary means of communication with the citizenry.
- rbanffy 6y agoThey didn't remove his message. They merely pointed out it was misinforming the public. Speaking of which, shouldn't we make it a crime to lie or substantially mislead the public while holding public office?
- CamperBob2 6y agoYeah, I don't disagree with their actions in this case -- if anything, they didn't phrase it strongly enough. ("Get the facts about voting by mail," as opposed to "Caution: this Tweet is unadulterated horseshit.") But I also think that the more Twitter is used to disintermediate political communication, the more it starts to look like a vital public utility. It's tough to say where the line will or should be drawn. I don't envy Jack Dorsey's position, that's for sure. As far as making a law that prohibits politicians from lying to the public, I don't see a way to write a law like that without making the situation even worse.
- Izkata 6y ago> "Caution: this Tweet is unadulterated horseshit." Except it's not. Trump is right here; most of the confirmed voter fraud is on mail-in and absentee ballots, despite being less used than in-person in the past decades. Switching everyone to mail-in will cause a sharp uptick in voter fraud.
- jessaustin 6y agoI hear this from friends who are Limbaugh fans, but I'd like to see some other source. Many people on the Left seem to think this whole "voter fraud" concern is a fig leaf for denying minorities their voting rights. When I've listened and asked follow-up questions, the Left's narrative seems more plausible.
- salawat 6y agoThat's actually kind of funny right there. Politically, internet access is being championed as a fundamental human right (I.e. being classified as a need). Yet we still have people trying to define what activity on the Net constitutes the necessity that access is supposed to fulfill. I understand where you're coming from though. I just wanted to point out the amusing dichotomy that stood out in my head.
- rbanffy 6y agoRight to access the internet is much more important for allowing someone to interact with the government through their various websites and to access sources of information that allow people learn and to fully exercise their rights. As much as Twitter is important, it's not nearly as important.
- berryjerry 6y agoIf you have followers on a twitter you have already built then it is just as important, especially if you have 20 million followers you stand to lose if twitter just decides they don't like you. For many it is your job, your livelihood, and your outlet to the world. For people and companies it may be the only way to reach out for collaboration with someone who you do not have a phone number yet and a twitter follower count is often used as a indicator that you are who you say you are, a filter of sorts. Since you can't go and meet every stranger in person elsewhere it is a requirement to have. Some people may not use twitter or only follow and never tweet but a lot of people use it as a necessity for communication, their personal well being, and businesses. Like it or not Twitter is worth billions for a reason and that reason is it provides a necessity for many that they cannot get elsewhere. The sheer size of Twitter already self-perpetuates their monopoly over that method of communication. It doesn't matter that you can go to Facebook if Twitter bans you. Take another industry for example such as TV. Disney bought Fox but was forced to sell Fox Sports because otherwise Disney would have had close to a monopoly on sports content as it already owned ESPN. Note it was not TV, it was only sports, a sub section of TV where they were deemed to have too much control. The internet monopolies just haven't had to face a determination of what is and isn't a subsection of social media but to be sure they are monopolies of public discourse.