11 ms·
>It really is a public web space that is operated by a private company No, it isn't, any more than a store is a public space because it has windows the public
by krapp 6y ago
>It really is a public web space that is operated by a private company
No, it isn't, any more than a store is a public space because it has windows the public can see into. You have to sign up for a Twitter account and accept their terms of service to post on the site. It's a private platform run by a private company for its own private business interests.
- Zecar 6y agoTwitter has over 300 million monthly active users. That is roughly equal to the entire population of the United States. You can't see any reason why they shouldn't be allowed to have total control over political discourse with no accountability? No reason at all?
- phkahler 6y agoYou have to pay the old telephone company and it's a lot more private communication than Twitter. Yet they had common carrier statis, which is how we should want ISPs regulated. Where twitter and friends fit simply hasn't been defined yet.
- komali2 6y agoThe argument falls apart at the ISP level - why does the UN consider internet a human right, but not, specifically, access to Twitter? It may seem like there's no distinction at all but it is there and it is important.
- threeseed 6y agoMuch better examples than Twitter. If I have the right to every website then how about password-protected ones. Do I then have the right to demand that Apple give me access to everyone's iCloud website ?
- rbanffy 6y agoBecause you need a phone to phone someone, call an ambulance or the police. You need an ISP to get to the internet. You don't need Twitter.
- sneak 6y agoForget Twitter, and substitute “gmail deliverability”? Without that, you cannot run a business.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rbanffy 6y agoDo you need Twitter to interact with your bank? To pay your taxes? To buy groceries? Is it the only way you have to reach your family?
- sneak 6y agoWhen my Twitter account was suspended recently after 12 years, I also lost access to my DM history, including usernames which I had not memorized. For some of my friends, Twitter was the only contact information I had for them. I have now totally lost the ability to communicate with those friends in the midst of a global emergency, even if I make a new account (which itself would be subject to immediate termination at any time), because I don’t know their usernames. A few of the closest ones fortunately noticed my absence without prompting, went to my profile, saw it suspended, went to my website (I presume it helped that my username, @sneakdotberlin, describes my website address), and emailed me. As for the busier or less attentive friends? No word yet. :( You can’t export your data or do “data takeout” from a suspended account, sadly, and you can’t view your DM history either inbound or outbound. EDIT: Also, I do need Twitter (and a high follower count) to meaningfully interact with my bank or my airline’s (or Google’s) customer service department. The 1-800-i’m-a-schnook line doesn’t seem to get things done.
- rbanffy 6y ago> You can’t export your data or do “data takeout” from a suspended account, sadly, and you can’t view your DM history either inbound or outbound. This is a big problem.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- MrJagil 6y agoI think that’s a simplistic view. No one is arguing Twitter is comparable to a store with a display window. The reality is that Tweets are broadcasted to billions of people. It’s a new reality. It’s a newspaper where anyone and everyone is authoring anything, including presidents, and with the roll of a die, the message is amplified to a multiple of the expected audience. Twitter may technically be a private platform run by a private company, but the issue not one of semantics, it’s about ethics and morals and how we compose a society with mighty power imbalances, fortified by new tech.
- threeseed 6y agoNewspapers have restricted what they publish for centuries. They don't allow libellous, defamatory, salacious or inappropriate comments for example. So it sounds 'new tech' hasn't really changed anything.
- rbanffy 6y agoNewspapers hire and pay people to write for them and exercise editorial control on everything that's published. That's very different from, say, a public restroom where people write on the walls. The owner of the restroom is not responsible for what people write on their walls.
- suff 6y agoIt would be, if the owner began editorializing the content, because the point at which they get involved, they lose neutrality, and therefore Section 230 immunity protection.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> Newspapers hire and pay people to write for them Newspapers also have zero obligation to convey the words of the President, and by frequently contextualise them.
- pnw_hazor 6y ago
- baddox 6y ago> No, it isn't, any more than a store is a public space because it has windows the public can see into. It is absolutely the case in the USA that private properties which are open to the public are regulated as "places of public accommodation" under, notably, the Civil Rights Act and the Americans with Disabilities Act. That includes privately-owned hotels, schools, restaurants, retail, and more. You're correct that this is directly analogous to a privately-owned website that is primarily geared toward accommodating the general public (like Twitter), but it makes the opposite point of what you intended. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_accommodations_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_accommodations_in_the_U...
- pnw_hazor 6y agoThe difference is that stores and malls invite the public in for a limited non-protected purpose - shopping or other commercial activity. Twitter invites the public in to exercise free speech, which in a public space would be protected. This invites an analysis that Twitter may be a quasi-public space that offers some 1st Amd. protections.