6 ms·
> But most of the time we spend on the web today is no longer on the open Internet - it's on private services like Facebook, Twitter and LinkedIn. Ultimately t
by crazygringo 6y ago
> But most of the time we spend on the web today is no longer on the open Internet - it's on private services like Facebook, Twitter and LinkedIn.
Ultimately there are three good reasons for this, which the author doesn't address at all.
The first is spam and abuse. The problem with a purely "open web" is that there's no solution to those, because of bad actors. The only solution we've found so far are centralized organizations which can run sophisticated machine learning and hire thousands of moderators.
The second is aggregation and discoverability. What good is it to publish if nobody finds you? Matching what people want to read, with the content they'll like (and not turning it into a firehose) is a really hard problem which, again, open standards basically do nothing for.
And then of course the third is monetization. There's a lot of amazing content on, e.g. YouTube, that wouldn't have been created if it weren't for monetization, because it takes content creators time that they'd otherwise have to spend at a job.
Now if we can create open standards that work as well as centralized solutions for all three of these... then we're talking.
- chisleu 6y ago> The first is spam and abuse Opt in systems solve these in open social media platforms, but introduce their own vulnerabilities such as information/reality bubbles and difficulty in growing networks. > The second is aggregation and discoverability Advertising takes many forms, including word of mouth. > monetization This is true enough, but most content on the internet isn't monetized by the creator via the platform, and there are many examples of creators who monetize independent of the platform. It also depends on how low you want to go w/ what you call the platform. Some pay for a platform in order to monetize. I don't have stats on this, so maybe it's experiential bias.
- ordinaryradical 6y ago> The only solution we've found so far are centralized organizations which can run sophisticated machine learning and hire thousands of moderators. I’m pretty sure HN, the site were literally posting on, does not have either of these, or at least not at that scale and yet it’s miles better than anything on fb or twitter so I’m not sure I buy this argument.
- chosenbreed37 6y ago> I’m pretty sure HN, the site were literally posting on, does not have either of these, or at least not at that scale and yet it’s miles better than anything on fb or twitter so I’m not sure I buy this argument. True. I like HN. By the look of it you like it too. When you say HN is miles better than fb or twitter I'd say that is a subjective judgement. I suspect that only a fraction of the people currently spending their time on fb or twitter would spend any time on HN. They're looking for something else. Something they don't get here. On another note I get the sense that the vast majority of users of those walled gardens couldn't give a hoot about the concerns raised in the essay. Those platforms currently deliver something of value to their target audiences (however that may be defined). So as long as they do that and no alternatives arise to disrupt their stranglehold things will remain as they are.
- munificent 6y ago> I’m pretty sure HN, the site were literally posting on, does not have either of these, As far as I know, HN does have two full-time employees whose sole job is moderation. I believe they also have some automated spam detection involved too. > yet it’s miles better than anything on fb or twitter so I’m not sure I buy this argument. This can be explained almost entirely by the fact that bad actors go where the greatest concentration of good actors is. Small communities are relatively safe with little effort required on their part, because they simply aren't a big enough target to be worth a bad actor's time. For a long time, it was taken for granted that "Mac didn't have viruses". It wasn't because Mac OS was somehow more virus-proof than Windows. It was simply that Mac was like 2% of the marketshare and thus just not a worthwhile platform for hackers to target.
- saagarjha 6y ago> HN does have two full-time employees whose sole job is moderation. I believe that number is currently one.
- the_af 6y ago"two full-time employees" is a significantly lower number than "thousands of moderators" like the initial post claimed. Thousands of moderators is not achievable by small, hobbyist sites. But one or two moderators is doable.
- syshum 6y ago>>The first is spam and abuse. The problem with a purely "open web" is that there's no solution to those, because of bad actors. The only solution we've found so far are centralized organizations which can run sophisticated machine learning and hire thousands of moderators. This is completely false on 2 fronts. The idea that these major services have solved spam and abuse is simply provably wrong. Further there are a number of ways stop spam and abuse on decentralized systems, in some ways these are better than on the centralized platforms. >The second is aggregation and discoverability. What good is it to publish if nobody finds you? Matching what people want to read, with the content they'll like, is a really hard problem which, again, open standards basically do nothing for. Here is a valid point, but there are some cool tech coming out that solves this, things like Lbry for example >And then of course the third is monetization. There's a lot of amazing content on, e.g. YouTube, that wouldn't have been created if it weren't for monetization, because it takes content creators time that they'd otherwise have to spend at a job. This is amusing, given the massive levels of demonetization on YouTube i think you are overstating the value of YT ad revenue in the modern area. Most YouTubers today seem to make the bulk of their money from outside sources like Sponsored Videos', Merch Sales, Direct Donations, etc.
- kiddlethorp 6y agoThe only correct solution to spam and abuse is to empower governments to charge people with offences when they commit them. This means national isolation, since the US can't extradite a fraudster in Russia and vice versa. Aggregation and discoverability is easy. Talk to people. Don't think about publishing, think about being part of a community. Monetisation can be solved by doing it the old-fashioned way. Standards aren't necessary; just make it possible to do small anonymous transactions. Don't ask them to log in and sign up before you'll take their money. Just take their money. Internet busking.
- ketzu 6y agoNot all spam is illegal, neither do I think it should be. National isolation would therefore not solve the problem entirely (if even for the most part) nor is it usually a desireable solution. How do you find that community? Discoverability is a huge problem and word of mouth is by far not enought to replace search engines. Your proposal to monetization seems to be an approach that hasn't succeeded in any way on the internet, despite people trying various ways. My personal feeling on the tasks is that your solutions are not very helpful to tackle any of those problems.
- naasking 6y ago> The first is spam and abuse. The problem with a purely "open web" is that there's no solution to those, because of bad actors. The only solution we've found so far are centralized organizations which can run sophisticated machine learning and hire thousands of moderators. Not true. It's the only solution when your focus is growth, and so you permit open signups from anywhere needing only something like an email address. This enables brigading, bots and abuse with fake and anonymous accounts. If a web of trust were involved, you have an introduction chain for every user, and a bad actor revealing themselves casts suspicion on the whole chain. You can revoke the whole chain in one go which is far more effective than picking bad actors and bots off one by one. The investment needed to sneak in is also considerably higher. So the status quo is not the only solution, it's the lazy solution focused on growing as fast as possible with no regard for the challenges that raises.
- jandrese 6y ago> The second is aggregation and discoverability. What good is it to publish if nobody finds you? Matching what people want to read, with the content they'll like (and not turning it into a firehose) is a really hard problem which, again, open standards basically do nothing for. Relying on a web of trust for signups makes the second problem far worse. If you're only creating a service for your friends and family it works great, if you want to expand it to the general public it is impossible. The encrypted email folks have been trying to get the web of trust to work for almost 30 years without success.
- naasking 6y ago> If you're only creating a service for your friends and family it works great, if you want to expand it to the general public it is impossible. Not impossible at all. Send out invitations and let them pull in their groups, as but one option. GMail was initially invitation only if you recall, and it was crazy popular even then. > The encrypted email folks have been trying to get the web of trust to work for almost 30 years without success. Web of trust has been working fine for all of those 30 years, so I really don't know what you're talking about. What hasn't "worked" is commercial buy-in by email clients and, more importantly, email providers who want to mine your data. People choose the free, easy email options (gmail, yahoo, etc.) without realizing how much personal information they're disclosing. So to claim that the commercial interests who are interested in violating your privacy and mining your information haven't bought into the web of trust is a pretty solid endorsement, not a downside.
- majormajor 6y agoThe pre-giant-conglomerate solution to those things was the (lack of) scale. Aggregation and discovery was low-volume stuff like web rings and humble links. Abuse had a much lower payoff due to the lower scale. Communities were mostly small, and abusers were small. Bigger communities were bigger targets, but could afford to pay people. If ten thousand people wanted to attack one of them, they could, for sure - but people having public discussions on FB or Twitter aren't immune to a group that size either. Scale and centralization hasn't had much benefit there. Monetization is certainly the difference. But is it worth it in its current form? If you want to reach a huge audience, these mega-platforms make it much easier to do so. You don't even have to persuade that many people, if the algorithm picks you up and starts dropping you in people's feed! I'd argue that the blind algorithm-driven promotion is the single biggest problem in the big social media and search platforms (Google, FB, Twitter, even Amazon 3rd party sellers). -- But I think the interesting thing people usually miss is that the old smaller internet is still there, for people looking for niche discussions and communities outside of the huge platforms.
- kerkeslager 6y ago> The first is spam and abuse. The problem with a purely "open web" is that there's no solution to those, because of bad actors. The only solution we've found so far are centralized organizations which can run sophisticated machine learning and hire thousands of moderators. False: there are plenty of old-school forums that still work just fine, with a handful of very hands-off moderators. There's a trend toward censorship in the big players, because it's more profitable to get thin-skinned users on their platform, but this is not at all the only way to create a healthy community. > The second is aggregation and discoverability. What good is it to publish if nobody finds you? Matching what people want to read, with the content they'll like (and not turning it into a firehose) is a really hard problem which, again, open standards basically do nothing for. I generally find things through a few bloggers who have a high signal-noise ratio in what they post. The idea that Facebook/Twitter/etc. do a better job than my bloggers is laughable. I left these platforms for a reason. > And then of course the third is monetization. There's a lot of amazing content on, e.g. YouTube, that wouldn't have been created if it weren't for monetization, because it takes content creators time that they'd otherwise have to spend at a job. On the contrary, I think the best content is almost always made because the person making it cares about what they are saying. "Hey guys make sure you like and subscribe! And by the way I've been playing Clash Of The Clans!" That's not content, that's advertising, and it's the poisonous result of monetization. Paul Harrell makes little-to-no money on his channel, Erowid survives on donations, Wikipedia authors are unpaid, Mother Jones and ProPublica are purely donation-based... and these are far better sources in most cases than any other sources of information on the subject. There is no case where ad-supported content does better than non-ad-supported content that I know of.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kixiQu 6y agoI want to suggest that all of this has more to do with you and your individual preferences than the way things work for everyone else. * what's the scale of the forums that work fine? * what if other people want to consume more content than "a few bloggers" produce and recommend? * when you say "does better", what do you mean? * is the best medicine made by pro bono pharmacists? are the best buildings made by off-duty carpenters? are the best movies made for free? with the best special effects? are the best novels free? the best graphic designs? would everyone agree with your assessment of what is 'best'? "I left these platforms for a reason." Yes, and other people stayed for reasons too.