5 ms·
Here comes the real deal government-on-server censorship, not the fake stuff that they’re complaining about. Censorship platforms, even the “good guys” who onl
by sneak 6y ago
Here comes the real deal government-on-server censorship, not the fake stuff that they’re complaining about.
Censorship platforms, even the “good guys” who only censor occasionally or predictably or “according to law” (or whatever), are all vulnerable to this. The state can threaten them with guns and imprisonment, ultimately, and they have no immediate recourse. The content comes down. Maybe it gets restored later, after the election or war is over. Maybe it doesn’t. Either way, it comes down today. Neither Jack nor Sundar are going to jail to protect your hosting account showing videos of war crimes.
This is an inherent danger in all censorship platforms. Whether you like Jack or not, trusting him not to censor arbitrarily (while Twitter always has the technical capability) is not a reasonable choice for the society-wide message bus.
This failure mode is inherent in these censorship-possible systems, and it must be addressed if we are to maintain publishing that cannot be suppressed by the state during emergencies.
https://sneak.berlin/20200421/normalcy-bias/ https://sneak.berlin/20200421/normalcy-bias/
- vkou 6y agoIf the state is threatening the operators of a platform with guns, because the supreme leader does not like the things said about him on it, whether or not that platform of choice is censoring arbitrarily has long stopped being the most pressing problem for speech.
- sneak 6y agoThey never threaten with guns directly. It’s always “regulation”, which is code for “do what we tell you because if you don’t, then the men with guns will show up and shackle you”. The guns are implicit. The threat rarely needs to be so direct. Imagine what happens if Twitter continues to do the legal publishing things that Twitter does on twitter.com, and the state arbitrarily changes the liability protections of the CDA out from under them, and Twitter tells them to piss up a rope. Next, Twitter’s bank accounts will eventually get looted, and if they opt out of the traditional state-controlled no-burden-of-proof banking system[1] to continue operating and paying staff, you can bet your ass that their resulting shutdown will be at the point of a gun, because payments outside of that system are already illegal without a special license. That’s the only authority the state ultimately has: the claim to legitimately use violence to enforce the law: the law, as we are about to see, that can be changed arbitrarily by corrupt politician edict. (The last time I recall him doing so was by an EO that overturned decades-old published and written BATFE interpretations of existing federal law (and assurances related to same) regarding bump stocks. The lawsuit proceeds, but good luck to you while you rot in jail for years if you are in possession of a bump stock (which were legal for decades) in the interim.) [1]: https://sneak.berlin/20191119/your-money-isnt-yours/ https://sneak.berlin/20191119/your-money-isnt-yours/
- deathgrips 6y agoTwitter is being threatened because they are arbitrarily censoring people.
- raverbashing 6y agoIt's a private platform
- deathgrips 6y agoYes, they are an unaccountable private platform that influence public elections.
- bzb3 6y agoWhich enjoys a high degree of unaccountability that other publishers don't have because they don't editorialise the content submitted by users. But if they start, and they started years ago, they should lose that protection.
- anontwitteruser 6y agoNo, that's not why they're being threatened. They're being threatened because they did something Donald Trump did not like.
- sneak 6y agoTwitter's been arbitrarily censoring people for years, myself included (I lost my account of twelve years recently). That's bad, though you can make the argument that they're entitled to do so on their own website. However, that's not at all why this is happening. Twitter didn't even censor the president, they just added a link below some lies he posted. He's been breaking their TOS habitually for some time and rather than ban him as they would anyone else, they made a special public TOS-exception for "newsworthy" bigwig public figures like him in their rules. The president gets to tweet things that would get you, a non-president, quickly banned from Twitter.[1] He's explicitly whitelisted as exempt from Twitter's usual control over twitter.com. Now, the federal government is going to actually censor Twitter on his order, simply because they had the audacity to amend information to tweets from an account that they declined to suspend out of courtesy despite it breaking their rules for years. [1]: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-intersect/wp/2018/01/03/the-3-loopholes-that-keep-donald-trumps-tweets-on-twitter/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-intersect/wp/2018/01...
- raverbashing 6y agoYes and the opposite of that is censorship by drowning the opposite message Non-censorship platforms: drinking water mixed with sewage Why does your email has an anti-spam filter again? Isn't that censorship?
- quantummkv 6y ago> Why does your email has an anti-spam filter again? Isn't that censorship? Spam Filtering is not censorship because it is acting on my behalf on the emails that I receive. As a private person, I have the right to apply any filters on conversations I am a direct part of. What I don't have the right is to apply my filters/opinions on others without their consent. Doing this would be censorship.
- Rapzid 6y agoYou may not realize that there is filtering occurring at the infrastructure level that you have no control over. Unless you run your own mail server and somebody sends mail directly to it, bypassing any other parties relays, you are most certainly not in control of all the "filtering" that occurs. Further, a lot of the major infra providers will shut your sh down if they think you are being a bad citizen(complaints, bounces, etc). Sure, you can find _some_ provider that won't; but DJT can find _some_ blog platform that will post his all his BS without fact checking it as well.