2 ms·
The FCC is an executive branch department. So telling the FCC is not telling the courts. The FCC and FTC can make certain moves and it's up to Twitter to sue th
by chrisco255 6y ago
The FCC is an executive branch department. So telling the FCC is not telling the courts. The FCC and FTC can make certain moves and it's up to Twitter to sue the Federal Government to contend with them. And then, the courts get to decide on the matter. But until then, let's not pretend 230c is the most well-defined precedent in legal history.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> So telling the FCC is not telling the courts. “Clarifying” regulation specifically is a message to the courts on interpretation; directing executive agencies to craft clarifying regulation is directing subordinate executive officers to tell the courts.
- jki275 6y agoCourts aren’t part of the executive branch. Independent judiciary is supposed to mean something...
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Courts aren’t part of the executive branch. Correct but irrelevant. I can tell people things over whom I don't have directive authority. “Clarifying” regulations are exactly the executive telling the courts how the law should be interpreted. Courts can disregard them (and, in principle, will if they don't find them the issuing agency to have been empowered to enforce the law and thereby entrusted with that interpretive role, and even if they are authorized, they deference granted to them is not unlimited) but the fact that someone might not follow your direction to them doesn't mean you haven't given them direction.
- jki275 6y agoNo. EOs tell the EXECUTIVE BRANCH how to enforce laws. They do not tell the courts how to interpret them.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> EOs tell the EXECUTIVE BRANCH how to enforce laws. Yes, EOs tell executive branch officers what to do. One of the things this EO tells certain executive branch officers to do is to tell the courts how to interpret Section 230 by way of adopting “clarifying” regulations.
- jki275 6y agoBelieve whatever you want. Courts ignore executive orders - especially ones from republican presidents, essentially always.