3 ms·
If you're interested in corporate governance, you might enjoy reading the book "Pay without performance" One of the points it makes is that shareholders have v
by michaelt 6y ago
If you're interested in corporate governance, you might enjoy reading the book "Pay without performance"
One of the points it makes is that shareholders have very little power in practice, as even if you own a million dollars of Apple shares, that's only 0.00007% of the company. Not exactly enough to force through a motion on your own.
And if you think you'll build up a coalition to get a majority? Good luck doing that when you can't even find out the names of other shareholders.
Minority shareholder lawsuits? They're actually a negligible force; rare, unlikely to succeed, and low impact even when they do.
And that's without getting into 'preference shares' that grant CEOs outsized voting rights.
The book argues management can neglect shareholders' interests with impunity for these reasons.
- _bxg1 6y agoWell there are two kinds of public shareholders, right. There may be a small number who own large enough shares to bother attending board meetings and voting, and then there are the millions with pensions, 401ks, index funds, etc. I think you're talking about the latter, who have the same issue but a slightly different version of it. In their case, the "ill-informed management" comes down to "price goes up, buy, price goes down, sell". Through share price they wield an extremely blunt version of the same weapon. This is almost worse, because it very explicitly cares only about the short-term price. It's also a much harder problem to solve, because you can't just tell those people "think long-term and ethically when you're exercising your impact on the marketplace!". No matter how ethical they may be as individuals, most of them probably don't even know which companies they have stakes in, much less whether those companies are heading in the right direction!
- WalterBright 6y ago> it very explicitly cares only about the short-term price. There is no short term price in stocks. Stocks are valued at their perceived long term value. If shareholders suspect a company is sacrificing the long term for the short term, they're going to dump the stock until the price of it drops to reflect that. This also implies that if you can reliably detect that a company is eating its seed corn before everyone else does, you can make a mint shorting it.
- prewett 6y ago> There is no short term price in stocks. Stocks are valued at their perceived long term value. Hogwash. Pretty much every company on the S&P 500 dropped 30% around March. Did their perceived long-term value change 30%? I doubt it. I think most people were fully aware that most companies in the S&P's 10 year value wasn't going to change much; certainly not 30%. Yet, it dropped 30%. And then the next month it has risen back up to about 10% of its all-time high. I don't think people seriously thought that Apple, Coca-Cola, Pepsi, etc. suddenly dropped in value 30% and then suddenly rose 20% (yes, I know, technically it was more). If you can have swings of +/- 30% over a period of two months, I don't think the value is reflecting the long-term prospects. There is both short-term AND long-term pricing in stocks. "In the short-run, the market is a voting machine. In the long-run, the market is a weighing machine." Ben Graham
- goatinaboat 6y agoHogwash. Pretty much every company on the S&P 500 dropped 30% around March. Did their perceived long-term value change 30%? Double hogwash. That pricing reflected that people suddenly needed cash right now and was irrespective of what anyone thought about long term value. I will bet most of the sellers bitterly regretted it but saw no option but to sell at whatever price they could get because they had urgent immediate needs.
- _dps 6y agoYes, one good way to think about this was that there was very little change in the value (fully discounted long term etc.) of stocks but a large change in the price (current exchange rate with other participants facing temporal constraints) of cash.
- prewett 6y agoRight, that's my point: prices don't perfectly reflect long-term value. You give an excellent example of why the currently price might not reflect long-term value, which I need to remember for next time!
- 6y ago
- coredog64 6y agoI think there’s a third class: Institutional investors like CalPERS or NYSLRS. CalPERS has something like $300B in assets. When they talk, companies listen. While they might be implicitly in your first group, attending significant meetings AND ensuring long term growth are primary responsibilities.
- rdtwo 6y agoCalpers is like a king with no pants everyone pretends to respect them but they are as dumb as money gets
- WalterBright 6y ago> even if you own a million dollars of Apple shares, that's only 0.00007% of the company. Not exactly enough to force through a motion on your own. And it shouldn't be. The board has only 24 hours in a day, not remotely enough time to debate every motion from every shareholder. However, as a shareholder, you can dump your stock, which does send a message when many shareholders do this.
- michaelt 6y ago> as a shareholder, you can dump your stock Indeed - but brundolf laments about the lack of shareholders "bothered with [Boeing's] nuances or long-term health" and having only a single one-bit message is not conducive to nuance.
- megablast 6y agoSends the message that it’s time for the company to buy more of their own stock.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]