6 ms·
fragile ... the word is fragile. We've built an insanely fragile economy. Take a look. There's been no war. 100% of the (not so great) US infrastructure that wa
by PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago
fragile ... the word is fragile. We've built an insanely fragile economy. Take a look. There's been no war. 100% of the (not so great) US infrastructure that was there before SARS-COV-2 is still there. We've lost about 100k people, which is horrific but in the scheme of things at "USA" scale, and with the skewed demographics, not much of a hit to the economy.
And yet the economy is staggering and it's likely to get worse. Why? Because people have stopped doing things
We've built an entire economy around people doing things they don't really need to do. In and of itself, that's not so bad, but we've also built an economy with so little resilience, so much fragility, so little spare capacity that the mere fact of people stopping doing a bunch of stuff has the potential to cause complete economic disaster for, what 15-20M Americans?
This is utter insanity. It's like claiming that the only vehicle you need is an F1 race car because of course that's all you need: lean, fast, stripped down, powerful and ultimately focused on increasingly one thing. Meanwhile, it's totally obvious to anyone with a pair of eyes that it's a completely unsuitable design for anything except racing on a specially built course, and that the smallest thing is capable of destroying it.
We've built this insane economic system despite the blinding obviousness of calamities like pandemics, wars, storms, unrest, climate change and so on. The "system" will continue to function (very probably), but at what cost and to how many?
- bluedino 6y agoFragile? We basically locked people in their homes. Shut down every imaginable business except those deemed "essential". Closed all retail and restaurants. What would you expect to happen?
- keithnoizu 6y agoBuying starbucks, etc. People who work at one cafe spending money at another cafe, etc. is the economic version of busy work. It doesn't really impact the countries ability to produce food and goods. Yet with out it the economy grinds to malaise that may last for years. That is pretty fragile.
- czbond 6y agoYou both have valid points; I think OP is talking about the U.S. economy being built on consumerism, materialism, and need to spend for growth. Growth requires the citizen base to continually spend more.
- gopalv 6y ago> Growth requires the citizen base to continually spend more. If the stimulus bill had gone directly to that, then this might have made a lot more sense. Forget UBI, the trillion dollars in PPP, if it was put into people's checking accounts as a reverse payroll tax might have had a very different (& aligned with consumerist values) economic result. As in, take the "employee as a cost" out of the employer's books & turn every extra employee just extra hands to work at your business, just paid for by the negative taxes (this punishes the under-the-table payment tax dodges directly). The fact that they gave PPP, without actually putting money into a paycheck absolutely sucked if your goal was to stop the money from slowing down in the economy. A dollar I spend turns into many more dollars spent, than a dollar I saved. But if I know I'm out on the street once that number drops to 0, I won't spend right now, even if it is a necessary purchase.
- ravenstine 6y agoFragile, because corporations that have millions or billions in cash flow don't have the kind of savings to keep people staffed and make debt payments. No, we little people are supposed to "save for a rainy day" and flood the stock market with our 401ks while big business gets to grow grow grow, make little to nothing in profit, and bolster stock prices with corporate debt. This isn't just about big business. Small businesses notoriously operate on very thin margins. Though that's not necessarily because of debt, but because what it takes to run a business today takes a considerable amount of overhead. I know that the idea of saving money seems cliche, like some obsolete thing your grandpa might say, but we're going to have to wake up to the fact that if we want to finance everything with debt then we're going to be penalized every 10 years when there's an adjustment or a catastrophe that forces one. The catch 22 there is that using less debt also means less growth, and we've all gotten used to unprecedented amounts of growth.
- MattGaiser 6y ago> No, we little people are supposed to "save for a rainy day" We really aren't. Between government pension plans, unemployment insurance, and all the welfare programs, I would challenge whether this is a real expectation at this point.
- throwlaplace 6y ago>and all the welfare programs hn right now is a great source of metadata for who to avoid when applying/hiring. i'm scraping all of these covid and economy threads for vile conservative comments and matching to names and making a "red flag" list. @gmail me if you want access to the list.
- ravenstine 6y agoIt's pretty despicable to show up in a thread where we are having an honest discussion, tag people as conservative(I think you mean "heretic"), and offer your blacklist to employers. Heck off.
- flatline 6y agoExcept all retail and restaurants have not closed. I live in a state that has had one of the most aggressive and successful responses to the virus, and people are still out and about in nice weather. The big box stores and groceries were open the whole time. Most restaurants have been open for take-out only, the whole time or most of the time. Smaller retailers are now allowed to re-open. People have been ordering a ton of stuff from online retailers. Commerce has slowed, and if everything somehow went back to normal next week we'd see the effects of just this initial slowdown for years to come. We are a service-based economy that depends on continual consumer growth that will never come back the way it was. The deep systemic impacts of all this have not really started yet.
- ianleeclark 6y agoWell, it would seem that if we close down all the non-essential businesses, and the economy immediately hemmorhages 10s of millions of jobs, that most of what we're doing isn't essential. In some bizarre twist of fate, an enviable hegemonic position has been squandered: where Americans could have cemented their dominance by doing likely anything else, we instead de-industrialized ourselves into a service-based economy specializing in shuffling the same 300$ around between 300 million people while nose-diving off a cliff the second the invisible hand comes knocking.
- spamizbad 6y agoWhat state requires you to stay in your home?
- jondubois 6y agoI think that it's definitely fragile in the sense that there are a lot of people going through hardship at the moment. When so many people need to rely on friends and relatives to survive, it means that capitalism has already broken down. The system has already failed. Now we just have to wait and see the results of this weird socialist system that we just created.
- blhack 6y agoFragile by what measure? The US economy at least appears to be weathering the storm, and many experts expect it to start rallying in the next few months. I mean...we just faced a complete black swan event where people all had to lock themselves in their homes, and so far we seem to have avoided catastrophe (at least by many expert predictions). The US is extremely well positioned to avoid many of the negative effects that most countries are going to be seeing. We are the opposite of fragile, at least compared to other human economies. https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/united-states/2020-03-31/comeback-nation https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/united-states/2020-0... https://youtu.be/7IWdNPAOQDE https://youtu.be/7IWdNPAOQDE https://zoom.us/rec/play/uZV8drj9-z83SIDH5QSDAvcoW9XoKK2shHIa-6VbxBrmAXMCNQXzM7QUM-tVFGFLsNYcjYIXdbXBQ9vF https://zoom.us/rec/play/uZV8drj9-z83SIDH5QSDAvcoW9XoKK2shHI...
- samsonradu 6y agoI think it's quite early to say if it weathered the storm, there might be long-term consequences. Also not sure what to say about the experts calling a rally, specially when those 'experts' are politicians.
- blhack 6y agoWhich one of the experts I linked here is a politician?
- samsonradu 6y agoThe US State Dept?
- blhack 6y agoOne of these are hosted by the US state department, but the person talking is from JP Morgan, which they cover in the introduction. The person moderating is from the state department, but she isn't presenting anything, just moderating questions to the guest speaker, who is not a politician. The others are Peter Zeihan, and an essay in Foreign Affairs. These are not politicians.
- MattGaiser 6y ago> US infrastructure that was there before SARS-COV-2 is still there. The physical buildings and roads are still there. The people who use them are not, which makes it in practice not in place.
- blfr 6y agoWe've built an entire economy around people doing things they don't really need to do. Yeah, we've moved beyond subsistence. In fact, we've moved so far beyond subsistence that we can put the entire economy on hold for months and no one is in even remote danger of starving.
- throwlaplace 6y ago>no one is in even remote danger of starving like do you actually believe this? just because none of your friends are starving doesn't mean there aren't people that are https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2020/04/22/covid-19-could-detonate-hunger-pandemic-with-millions-risk-world-must-act/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2020/04/22/covid-19-...
- MattGaiser 6y agoI believe he is limiting his comments to the USA.
- throwlaplace 6y agodo you know what the number of people below the poverty line is in the US? https://www.npr.org/2019/09/10/759512938/u-s-census-bureau-reports-poverty-rate-down-but-millions-still-poor https://www.npr.org/2019/09/10/759512938/u-s-census-bureau-r... 38 million. 12% of households don't reliably eat https://www.feedingamerica.org/about-us/press-room/new-data https://www.feedingamerica.org/about-us/press-room/new-data people are getting evicted en masse soon https://www.nytimes.com/2020/05/27/us/coronavirus-evictions-renters.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/05/27/us/coronavirus-evictions-... do you really think "no one" is going starve to death in the US in the coming months? or even that many people aren't?
- smcg 6y agowe know all of these things are true. the system is set up to disenfranchise these people. none of it is because of lack of food capacity, and covid did not impact the food supply chain enough to stop the chain.
- refurb 6y agoMaybe you could spell out how we could create an economy that isn't fragile?
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoI could, but the margin on this page is too small to contain the proof. /fiddle with CSS Seriously? There are dozens or hundreds of amazing books on alternative economics. I wouldn't be the best to make the case, and certainly not the first. Do you actually want some recommendations (most of my own canonical ones are a bit old) ?
- nicksellen 6y agoYou can try this twitter thread from Kate Raworth https://twitter.com/KateRaworth/status/1239596817463103489 https://twitter.com/KateRaworth/status/1239596817463103489
- wayoutthere 6y agoThe word you're looking for is overoptimization. We built and optimized a system around the "happy path" but in doing so we cut off our fallbacks for less optimistic scenarios. This is market capitalism unrestrained. Any measures in place to account for "black swan" events get optimized out of existence in the name of short-term efficiency. And why shouldn't they when the government has shown that they will bail out companies over and over?
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoThe over-optimization is a part of it. But millions of people livelihood being dependent on, as someone posted above, "the same $300 moving from one person to another over and over again" is also a big contributor. We also have so little in the way of economic self-reliance anymore, at almost any scale. Certainly not individual or familial (which might not be a good goal anyway), but also not at neighborhood, community, city, state and to some extent even national scales.
- wayoutthere 6y agoI think this gets at another issue: our economy has a lot of pointless, redundant jobs that only exist because the economy needs to keep people employed. Cheap money policy at the fed was always intended to minimize unemployment, but many of those jobs were unnecessary. Those jobs won't survive the next couple years. The flip side of cheap money is inflation, and it's been building up in the economy since the 2007 crisis. The inflation has been hidden by stagnant wages and falling commodity prices from globalization, so it's led to "top heavy" inflation -- the value of a dollar has been shrinking as the supply of dollars has increased, but that extra supply of dollars has been almost exclusively concentrated in equity markets. Prices of goods have remained in check because the vast majority of people simply don't have access to most of the new money. See also all the US companies sitting on hundreds of billions in cash, stock buybacks, and corporate debt. I believe the US has 2 economies: one denominated in dollars, the other denominated in millions of dollars. It wasn't seen as "inflation" because most of the inflation indicators used by the federal reserve target the consumer economy. I think we're about to have a really bad decade as all this starts to unwind. The housing market is the first place this will hit (and we're seeing it already); capital will start to flow into REITs buying up residential properties and we'll see prices stay high even or even rise in an economy when they shouldn't be. All but the wealthiest individuals will be priced out of the market (this is already the case in many cities). That means more renters, higher rents, and zoning laws that prevent new housing starts. The two economies will start to bleed together in the margins between the millionaire economy and the individual economy -- with disastrous results for the people of the country.