5 ms·
> This is what happens when you let the accountants run the business. You're shooting the messenger when the core issue is that Boeing, like all publicly trade
by rchaud 6y ago
> This is what happens when you let the accountants run the business.
You're shooting the messenger when the core issue is that Boeing, like all publicly traded companies do not have medium to long-term views for their business. It is always quarter-to-quarter. That is what management is judged on, because their job and their compensation is tied to maximize shareholder returns.
- manquer 6y agoWhile generally true, The medium term view is why they need to let go in the first place . I am guessing aircraft manufacturing is going to severely depressed in the medium term. Customers are delaying deliveries, canceling orders etc. Demand will likely not return to pre covid levels in even one year. Even if it does, airlines are not in any financial position to make significant purchases for few years. On top of it 737-MAX issues and resulting hold in manufacturing of that line has not left Boeing in a great shape.
- brobdingnagians 6y agoThis is one of the best arguments I can think of against having large corporations with "corporate person hood". It does enable large capital accumulation over time, but that capital accumulation eventually becomes so de-personalized in how it gets used that it becomes detrimental to society. A single private owner tends to care and have more purpose, more personal stake in real long-term growth, and can take the real risk of investment. Corporations, as we see more and more, get huge amounts of capital and then start gaming the system for short term executive bonuses.
- Retric 6y agoEconomies of scale are extremely valuable to the overall economy as mega corps tend to charge lower prices. Similarly, SpaceX as a high risk high cost investment is vastly more likely with group funding than a single private owner. Clearly there are some downsides, but managing them via laws and regulations is possible.
- ryanbrunner 6y agoThere's a cost associated with this as well though. Those lower costs don't come for free - they come from increased efficiency which translates to fewer workers and less money being redirected into local economies.
- sokoloff 6y agoIs more workers to achieve the same total outcome a desirable state? It seems like what you’re proposing doing there is literally wasting entire human work lives for zero productive output.
- ryanbrunner 6y agoIf you took this to an unrealistic extreme, where 100% of all jobs are automated, every cent of profit flows into the hands of owners and shareholders, and there's literally no job that labour can take, that's clearly and obviously worse. The flipside, where efficiency is at it's lowest, and every single product ever is hand-crafted with a tremendous amount of labour seems obviously bad too. Of course, those are both ridiculous extremes - the answer to what balance is healthiest for an economy I'm sure is immensely complicated. I'm just saying that efficiency doesn't come without costs, and we shouldn't design our entire economy completely around the interests of shareholders of major corporations.
- Retric 6y agoIt seems like your automated example allows a welfare state to provide a better quality of life than we currently enjoy. Having people do pointless jobs for the same income at that point seems inherently worse. That said, I have serious doubts that everything can be automated as that suggests all human labor would be providing zero value.
- BurningFrog 6y agoIf large companies didn't plan beyond the quarter, a lot more of them would be failing all the time. You can't even build a factory in a quarter. In reality larger companies usually prosper for many decades, because they do plan long term.
- rchaud 6y agoI think you're conflating job losses with not prospering. Boeing's stock is up on the news. Lost jobs = lower payroll = improved cash flow. That's the bottom line. Shareholders couldn't care less how you arrive there, just that you do.
- chaostheory 6y agoQuarterly pressure from Wall Street is not a good excuse. That just means that the CEO and other C-level execs are just ineffective leaders. People who are too far removed from the product, i.e. bean counters with little passion for the technology and industry, tend to make bad leaders for firms like Boeing.
- tryptophan 6y ago>like all publicly traded companies do not have medium to long-term views for their business Why do people keep repeating this garbage over and over and over? It just isn't true. Amazon literally didn't make profits for 10 years. Many other tech companies haven't made a cent yet, but investors are looking 5-10 years into the future for those. Some businesses just make bad decisions, others make good decisions. Overall the free market/public corporation system is a resounding success. Just because boeing messed up doesn't say anything about the rest of the system.
- cwhiz 6y ago>Overall the free market/public corporation system is a resounding success. We don't have a free market. The market is not allowed to implode. Mega corporations and banks are not allowed to fail. Boeing is not allowed to fail, and that fact, more than anything else, explains why they are such a poorly run company. Where you see a "resounding success" I see an absolute failure that is closer to a scam or a ponzi scheme than a legitimate system.
- cgh 6y agoBear Stearns, Washington Mutual, WorldCom and many others are evidence to the contrary. I'm not sure if Boeing will be "allowed" to fail if it's on that path, but your statement that "Mega corporations and banks are not allowed to fail" is simply false.
- cwhiz 6y agoYeah every decade or so we let a company fail just to set an example to the rest. WaMu, in particular, is a pretty hilarious example. We, the public, bailed out JP Morgan and with those funds they purchased WaMu at pennies on the dollar. What a deal!
- xyzzyz 6y agoBoeing is not allowed to fail, and that fact, more than anything else, explains why they are such a poorly run company. So the mass layoffs are just a mirage, and not a failure at all, are they?
- ChuckMcM 6y agoIn my experience at the executive level of a company this was never the case. There were always 1 year, 3 year, and 5 year plans in place. Long range plans get re-evaluated periodically because things change, both technology and markets but I have never experienced them being either ignored or thrown out in pursuit of the quarterly 'numbers.' That said, if your senior management doesn't understand all aspects of your product value, they will make poor choices both in the short term and for the long term.
- S_A_P 6y agoThis thread reminds me of one I saw on here this morning re: the netflix quikster debacle. I would imagine that it is easy to push a narrative that execs are greedy, short sighted and barely competent. I would imagine this can be true, but more than likely its a bunch of factors that aren't public that led to less than optimal decision making.