3 ms·
Simplicity is difficult. I use a comparison that I call "Nakamichi vs. Adcom." Those of us...of a "certain age"...will remember these as top-shelf stereo bran
by ChrisMarshallNY 6y ago
Simplicity is difficult.
I use a comparison that I call "Nakamichi vs. Adcom."
Those of us...of a "certain age"...will remember these as top-shelf stereo brands. They used to cost a bundle.
Nakamichi amps tended to be...engineer-friendly: https://audio-database.com/NAKAMICHI/amp/amplifier2.JPG https://audio-database.com/NAKAMICHI/amp/amplifier2.JPG
Adcom amps tended to be a bit simpler: https://www.hifiengine.com/images/model/adcom_gfa-585_power_amplifier.jpg https://www.hifiengine.com/images/model/adcom_gfa-585_power_...
Both were pretty awesome, but they definitely "spoke to" different crowds.
I think that the debates over which is better would never be resolved.
I like to take the tack of "Make it simple, but no simpler than absolutely necessary to get the principal task done."
This is really important in both usability and accessibility.
There's a famous quote from Josef Albers: "In design, sometimes one plus one equals three."
Every element that we add to a design; whether functional or ornamental, can have a combinatorial impact on complexity.
- ratww 6y agoOff topic, but I noticed something funny: the simpler amp looks is closer to what professional audio engineers use. We expect not having treble/bass controls in our mixing monitors because we expect their response curve to be as flat as possible. (In practice some have controls to compensate for room issues, but we rarely use, and just blame the room)
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoI'm not surprised. The Adcom amp relies almost entirely on its preamp, which, though simpler than the Nakamichi one, is a bit more complex. On the other hand, this is the Nakamichi preamp: https://i.pinimg.com/originals/b9/7b/d6/b97bd60bcbedd59ddf4ea972d17094c1.jpg https://i.pinimg.com/originals/b9/7b/d6/b97bd60bcbedd59ddf4e...