4 ms·
Why is that? Bailing out Boeing every now and then is almost certainly cheaper than bailing out a rail operator to the tune of tens of billions of dollars every
by rayiner 6y ago
Why is that? Bailing out Boeing every now and then is almost certainly cheaper than bailing out a rail operator to the tune of tens of billions of dollars every year, and still having them teeter on the verge of insolvency: https://skift.com/2018/03/05/frances-rail-system-is-falling-apart/ https://skift.com/2018/03/05/frances-rail-system-is-falling-...
> Underused stations on expensive tracks are one of the many reasons France’s vaunted rail system is insolvent, subsisting on life support from the state. Rail operator SNCF runs an annual deficit of 3 billion euros despite receiving 14 billion euros of public subsidies annually—just under half the defense budget. Its debt, at 45 billion euros, equals the national debt of New Zealand.
- pen2l 6y agoUh, please stop downvoting rayiner. He didn't say anything wrong or kooky, on the contrary he provided an interesting, substantiated counter-point not often heard around these parts. Do you people _want_ HN to become an even worse echochamber? Secondly, it makes it hard for me to read because it's light-colored text on light background. So knock it off.
- simias 6y agoIt's important to point out that it's low speed, aging infrastructure that's a big problem for French rail. Bullet trains make a lot of money and in general people complain because as a result the SNCF invests a lot more into the high-speed infrastructure than to maintain the old, slow, regional lines. The high-speed axes like Paris<->Marseille or the Paris<->Bordeaux are definitely not underused and the tickets are quite expensive, often more so than plane tickets but trains are generally a lot more comfortable and convenient (and about as fast or even faster door-to-door). More broadly the problem is whether you consider that the SNCF should be run uniquely for-profit (in which case they'd probably end up closing all the small regional lines and only run the bullet trains) or if it's a public service that can lose money if it provides an important service for the citizens (in which case it makes sense to maintain the local lines even if they lose a lot of money).