4 ms·
A code of conduct doesn't have the force of law to begin with, in what way is Youtube having one independent of US law? And if you're suggesting every instance
by krapp 6y ago
A code of conduct doesn't have the force of law to begin with, in what way is Youtube having one independent of US law?
And if you're suggesting every instance of moderation on Youtube's platform should be a civil or criminal matter, and that a court or some other agent of the state should decide on each matter rather than Google, how would that not still be censorship?
- guscost 6y agoIt would be censorship only with the consent of the governed, as it should be. Also folks, keep in mind that I am absolutely not saying that the government should regulate every video on YouTube, I am only saying that YouTube should lose its special privileges if it wants to play that game itself. It is a critically-important distinction that I feel is being missed here.
- downerending 6y agoThe point isn't that moderation should be a crime or tort. The point is that exercising editorial control for political reasons should exclude them from 230 protections. That is, they'd be considered a publication rather than an open forum.