7 ms·
I feel sorry for the people who lose their jobs because of this, but I think less air travel would in many ways be a good thing for the world.
by mcv 6y ago
I feel sorry for the people who lose their jobs because of this, but I think less air travel would in many ways be a good thing for the world.
- fermienrico 6y agoAgreed. Furthermore, traveling is overrated - yes I said that. Traveling to other places IMP is not as fun as going to national parks and exploring nature right here at home. Just my personal take on it - I’ve travelled extensively and I don’t enjoy it anymore.
- hyperbovine 6y ago> I’ve travelled extensively and I don’t enjoy it anymore. But that's because there are so many other travelers. Conditional on survival, travel is looking more appealing post-COVID.
- postsantum 6y agoFrom my expericence, there are not that many places that you can't have all to yourself if you really want it
- ch4s3 6y agoSo because you don’t enjoy ANYMORE, other people shouldn’t be able to enjoy in the first place?
- fermienrico 6y agoYeah, I thought we are expressing our opinions on this site?
- ch4s3 6y agoYou are of course free to, but I think your opinion has an air of elitism and condescension, so I'm expression my own opinion to criticize it.
- fermienrico 6y agoHow so? Please read the comment again. Where is the exact wording that made you feel that way? I can correct it.
- ch4s3 6y agoYou were agreeing with the statement "I feel sorry for the people who lose their jobs because of this, but I think less air travel would in many ways be a good thing for the world. ". That necessarily implies that fewer people should be able to travel.
- vmception 6y agoYeah not all of us travel to compare national parks and nature. Bird watching in the Aleutian Islands would be a drag for most of us. On the other hand, events with friends, lovers, annual festivals (yacht weeks, film festivals, music festivals), getting immersed somewhere else so long that you take classes and go about the day to day with others in the class, actually enjoying taking cross country trains because they are a fast and viable form of transportation. Can't wait till that is viable again! Many of those things are possible in the US, many of the events are just not in the US and their original locations are better for it, there are also lots of people not interested or capable of coming here, who I like to be around.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- st1ck 6y agoEven if I agree with your argument, not everyone lives near nature and national parks. Many people live in cities without sea, mountains, canyons, forests etc.
- ch4s3 6y ago> but I think less air travel would in many ways be a good thing for the world. This seems overly myopic to me. Aviation accounts for at most 2% of global juman CO2 emissions during normal years. I think you could come up with dozens of arguments for why it’s a net good. For example, tourism has income allows small island nations to better financially prepare for rising sea levels far in excess of aviations contribution to sea level rise. Not only that, but travel exposes citizens of wealthy nations to the real living conditions of people in developing nations, which can have a number of positive political effects.
- adrianN 6y agoAviation has a relatively low percentage of total emissions only because globally almost nobody can afford to fly. For a rich person like you and me, a transatlantic trip is a good way of doubling your emissions for the year.
- ch4s3 6y agoA transatlantic flight of 6 hours on a Boeing 737 would emit about 540 kilograms for a single passenger. In the US per capita C02 emissions were 15.8 metric tons in 2017. So the round trip would account for ~1/15th of a person's yearly total. You could probably make that up by driving less, since a typical passenger vehicle emits about 4.6 metric tons of carbon dioxide per year. If you look at the UK, it's estimated that 20% of the nation's emissions are directly from heating and hot water, which is analogous to many areas of the US. This is largely due to old and poorly insulated housing stock. This isn't meant to be CO2 whataboutism, but rather to compare meaningful individual contributions to emissions. IMO aviation for most international travelers may be a large single contribution, but they do it infrequently and other activities could be moderated of modified to make up ground. I mention this to support my parent claim that aviation has numerous benefits, and they may likely outweigh their costs accounting for externalities. That said, I would advocate a carbon tax that prices emissions into things like gas, heating, flying, etc.
- makerofspoons 6y ago
- sodafountan 6y agoYeah that's not how it works, people losing their jobs and others being unable/unwilling to experience the world and travel is a very bad thing for the world.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoThere are other jobs, and I would like to see objective evidence that those wealthy enough to fly international derive more value from "cultural experiences" than not putting those metric tons of CO2 into the atmosphere.
- sodafountan 6y agoYeah that's very "woke" of you for saying that but there's really no positive way to spin this. When a pilot, or flight attendant, or engineer has to retrain and possibly leave an industry they've worked in potentially their entire life that causes pain and suffering. It doesn't surprise me that the HN crowd lacks the empathy to see the damage being done here, but say for instance someone told you couldn't code anymore, you lose your job, and you might have to pivot into another industry at a time when nobody's hiring and you don't even have the skills or training to get in the door. Then some pompous asshole online says "well ackchually this is good for the environment because computers consume energy and don't run off of the hot air I blow everytime I open my mouth"
- toomuchtodo 6y agoPlease don't conflate being realistic with being "woke". It sucks you've lost your job. Retrain or retire. I'm not without empathy, but America has chosen the lack of safety nets it exhibits. And I can appreciate the environmental benefits from the pandemic that we couldn't do ourselves as a species. I would be a huge fan of Medicare for All and more robust safety nets resulting from this carnage, but I don't expect it. People are irrational and selfish in aggregate, and when times are good they are entirely apathetic to the political process. Only under duress do they scream "do something" to the people they've elected who actively do harm to their constituents' interests.
- kyuudou 6y agoLess military activity, air and otherwise, would be exponentially more effective. No one wants to kill their golden goose, though.