4 ms·
What's the line between "we have the best burgers in the world," and actually lying? You'll notice that Mr. POTUS said "less than substantially," whch barely me
by whatshisface 6y ago
What's the line between "we have the best burgers in the world," and actually lying? You'll notice that Mr. POTUS said "less than substantially," whch barely means anything. Maybe he thinks 2% is "more than substantially." You can't lie if you phrase everything in a way that doesn't say anything.
- JMTQp8lwXL 6y agoThe phrase does indeed say something. "anything less than substantially fraudulent" means near and total fraud. Claiming ~100% of mail-in ballots are fraudulent is baseless and untrue.
- whatshisface 6y agoI just don't see how you can go from "anything less than substantially" to 100%. You can't go from "substantially" to any percentage. For an example, I could pull the same trick on your comment. I could try and convince people that "does indeed," implies 100% confidence, and then I could point out that since from a Bayesian perspective you should never reach 100% confidence, you can't know what you're talking about. Obviously nobody would buy that, because it's not you that wrote down 100%, it was me.
- JMTQp8lwXL 6y agoWhat does 'substantial' mean? "of considerable importance, size, or worth.". We further constrain the definition with 'anything less than'. So what we're saying is, 'of an especially considerable importance, size of worth'. Okay, well, what does that mean? It has to be a number large enough to influence the election result, but there's no evidence election results have flipped elections due to enough fraudulent mail-in ballots. With this interpretation, the numeric quantity does not matter, but the impact does, yet it is still untrue.
- gjulianm 6y agoYou're getting entangled in the details. It's clear from his tweets that what he means is that mail-in ballots will cause a rigged election. We shouldn't trust rigged elections, so he's saying that if the election includes mail-in ballots, it will be untrustworthy. In order to make that reasoning (you could say that arguments are not false or true, they're just arguments) he's using false (CA will not be sending ballots to "anyone") and unsubstantiated (mail-in ballots have been working for years without extended robberies and forging, why would this be any different?) claims. You can search and reason about the words so that "technically" he isn't lying. But the actual message he's sending is very, very clear.
- UncleMeat 6y agoHe obviously doesn’t think it is 2% because 2% in California would be nowhere close to “rigging the election” (his words).
- pfraze 6y agoIt's pointless to quibble about what POTUS is getting at. He clearly intends to claim "mail-in voting is fraudulent." The question of whether it's a lie has more to do with whether his claim is accurate.
- dboreham 6y agoSo "dark patterns" are ok?
- colejohnson66 6y agoThe difference is that everyone knows “we have the best burgers in the world” is subjective, and therefore, not true. When it comes to statistics (read: not subjective measures), it’s possible to lie.
- ken 6y agoSpecificity. It's an existing exception in advertising law (or so I've been told). Anyone can claim "we have the best burgers" -- and many restaurants do -- because it's non-specific. Ironically, if you were to attempt humility by claiming "we have the second-best burgers", that becomes a specific claim, and you'd need research to support it. "The Governor of California is sending Ballots to millions of people, anyone living in the state" is a specific claim, and would need to be supported. It's a different category of claim than merely boasting "I am the best president".
- duskwuff 6y agoThere's also some room in the law for puffery in advertising, which includes the use of vacuous statements like "the best".
- foogazi 6y agoNo what Mr. POTUS said was > There is NO WAY (ZERO!) that Mail-In Ballots will be anything less than substantially fraudulent Translation: 100% certainty that Mail-In Ballots are substantially fraudulent Where do you get the 2% from? > Maybe he thinks 2% is “more than substantially” We don’t know what he thinks - we know what he wrote. And he didn’t write a “maybe 2% chance of fraud” He specified a 100% certainty of substantial election fraud