6 ms·
I've got a brand-new 2019 16" and am dealing with the widespread crashes on wake from sleep. Honestly, it's a harder decision to send it back than you might thi
by rayiner 6y ago
I've got a brand-new 2019 16" and am dealing with the widespread crashes on wake from sleep. Honestly, it's a harder decision to send it back than you might think, for several reasons:
1) The hardware quality of other OEMs is bad too. Lenovo has really gone downhill. I sold my maxed-out X1 Carbon 7th Gen, which in less than a year: a) came with an LTE card that never worked for more than an hour at a time; b) had the display bezel start peeling off (it's a sticker!); c) developed a bunch of dead pixels; d) started randomly locking up; e) had weird issues with power usage, where some service related to the touchpad would go crazy and start using all the CPU.
2) Other laptop makers make design choices and trade-offs that I find unacceptable. For me, the 16" MBP is the perfect balance of power, weight, and battery life. It compromises by using a 3K screen instead of a 4K screen, and gets 11+ hours of light usage. Alternatives like the XPS 15 or Lenovo X1 Extreme force you to choose between an FHD panel and good battery life, or a 4K panel and substantially shorter battery life. The Surface Laptop 15" uses a 15W ultra-mobile processor in a machine that runs $2,800 when configured with 32GB of RAM, and has a battery half the size of the one in the MBP 16". Many 15" laptop vendors include a numeric keypad, which is a deal-breaker for me because it forces you to type at an angle to keep your hands centered in front of you when in the home position.
3) Touchpad and high-DPI scaling.
- sixothree 6y agoXPS 15
- rayiner 6y agoI'm seriously considering the new XPS 15. It hits much of the same great balance as the 16" MBP, and like the Macbook Pro, it has a 16:10 display. I'm gun shy, because of potential coil whine: https://xps-15.fandom.com/wiki/Coil_Whine https://xps-15.fandom.com/wiki/Coil_Whine > As Coil Whining is a big problem on this model we will try to find out witch parts are causing this noises. First we need to disassemble this notebook and identify the noisy parts. https://www.reddit.com/r/Dell/comments/8ptfu8/would_you_accept_this_level_of_coil_whine_dell/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Dell/comments/8ptfu8/would_you_acce... > I immediately noticed I felt slightly 'uncomfortable' when it was on, and within about 30 seconds realised that it was emitting coil whine at a volume/pitch high enough to physically bother me. It's like an ever-present noise that I can only imagine must be how low levels of tinnitus feels to people who have to deal with that type of thing. I am pretty disappointed to say the least. I might just assume that this is random internet griping, but I had this exact same problem on my last Dell laptop (admittedly, it was almost 20 years ago) and it drove me insane when working late at night. It's one of those little "quality of life" things I'm willing to pay extra for. (Not to say that Apple doesn't have quality-of-life issues, like randomly removing ports. But for the most part I find I can solve those issues just by throwing money at the problem. I can't do that with coil whine, or a non-centered keyboard, or a laptop that only offers either an FHD or a 4K display and no power-efficient compromise.
- ascom 6y agoThe new XPS 15 allegedly has a battery rated for only 300 cycles: https://www.notebookcheck.net/The-new-Dell-XPS-15-s-battery-is-rated-for-300-cycles-and-apparently-that-s-ok.466422.0.html https://www.notebookcheck.net/The-new-Dell-XPS-15-s-battery-... For comparison, MacBooks' batteries are rated for 1000 cycles.
- the_angry_angel 6y agoI switched to a XPS-15 9570 from a MBP of roughly equiv spec, but previous gen, after the last round of laptop shuffles at work - I went from MacOS to Windows at the same time in order to feel the pain of our environment under Windows. I'm not saying that it's a bad laptop. But there are just so many little annoying things about it after coming from the MBP and MacOS; * Trackpad is subjectively worse, but I can't tell you why beyond its just smaller - but I am objectively much less accurate with it and trigger tap-clicks when I don't mean to. The trackpad positioning is also slightly uncomfortable to use. * Fan noise - the fan curve has it ramping up earlier than a MBP * Windows was hosed out of the box (fine, fixable, but it wasn't a good start) * The "soft" covering results in so many fingerprints * Webcam on the bottom bezel is an awful angle Pros; * Great screen, touch is a nice add-on but found I rarely use it now * Keyboard isn't terrible * Power adapter isn't a brick Would I do it again. Honestly, not sure. My daily driver isn't the laptop and I just deal. If I had to use the laptop daily, I'd probably reconsider.
- hundt 6y agoI tried the XPS 15 7590 late last year before I switched back to Mac when the 16" MBP came out. It felt like absolute garbage in comparison. Trackpad was so bad I had to use the touchscreen to scroll. Internet stopped working intermittently. Display felt like far inferior quality (and, like you said, your choices are too few pixels or too many). It was honestly a confusing experience to me, like reviewers or other people who treat these machines as comparable were living on a different planet or something. Of course I don't expect everyone to like Macs and there's nothing wrong with preferring the Dell but I don't understand why the quality differences are not more widely acknowledged.
- pw 6y agoAre you agnostic about using Windows or MacOS?
- ebg13 6y ago> XPS 15 OH YES? https://www.google.com/search?rls=en&q=dell+xps+15+crashing https://www.google.com/search?rls=en&q=dell+xps+15+crashing https://www.google.com/search?rls=en&q=dell+xps+15+coil+whine https://www.google.com/search?rls=en&q=dell+xps+15+coil+whin... https://www.google.com/search?rls=en&q=dell+xps+15+battery+swelling https://www.google.com/search?rls=en&q=dell+xps+15+battery+s... https://www.google.com/search?rls=en&q=dell+xps+15+overheating https://www.google.com/search?rls=en&q=dell+xps+15+overheati...
- duxup 6y agoI have trouble measuring how many complaints are real at scale type issues anymore. I think you could find any popular hardware, particularly with any emphasis on performance where there aren't some issues logged.
- ebg13 6y agoYes, this is reality. But for some reason some people decide that they're absolutely certain about the huge scale of issues with Apple products while being absolutely certain about the lack of scale for issues everywhere else. It couldn't _possibly_ be their bubble.
- JohnTHaller 6y ago
- vardump 6y agoPersonal experience: XPS 15 overheats and becomes extremely slow. Maybe it's a user error... Touchpad hardware is good, but the software and adjustability... it's nowhere comparable to a Macbook.
- 72deluxe 6y agoWhat does task manager say is causing the CPU to be used so much that it overheats and thermally limits itself? Have you used Sysinternal's Process Monitor or Process Explorer or any of the tracing tools already built into Windows to see why it's slow? If you've got some service running behind the scenes and keeping the machine busy, of course it'll be "slow".
- vardump 6y ago> Have you used Sysinternal's Process Monitor or Process Explorer or any of the tracing tools already built into Windows to see why it's slow? Yeah, poked it a bit, took some ETW traces. Couldn't find any good reason for it to behave like that with a low CPU load.
- 72deluxe 6y agoThis sounds like a challenge!
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoHave you considered keeping the Macbook and running Bootcamp full time? (Or Linux, but I know Linux was in a bad state on new Macbooks as of fairly recently, don’t know if it has gotten better.)
- rayiner 6y agoI’m often away from a power outlet, so battery life is paramount. The battery life in Bootcamp is unacceptably short (3 hours) because the DGPU is always on.
- asdff 6y agoBootcamp drivers are in a sorry state. Expect battery life, performance, trackpad, display to all tank.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoI was recently using Bootcamp on a relative's 2020 Macbook Air, and I was generally impressed with how well everything worked. Especially the Trackpad, which I remembered being a problem under Bootcamp many years ago. If I didn't dislike Windows so much, I thought I could see myself using that setup full time. I didn't look at battery life though.
- 72deluxe 6y agoEven my old MacBook Pro 2012 in BootCamp is very poor under BootCamp. Getting the right drivers for it is the worst bit because who knows whether I should be using Bootcamp 5 or 6? The display brightness and volume keys no longer work. The discrete GPU is used all the time so battery life is very bad. The touchpad works fine though!
- Wowfunhappy 6y ago> Getting the right drivers for it is the worst bit because who knows whether I should be using Bootcamp 5 or 6 I mean, I'd use whatever the heck Bootcamp Assistant downloads for me automatically. I don't think I've ever thought about Bootcamp versions. Never had issues with brightness and volume keys either...
- csdreamer7 6y agoHave you considered System76? I have a similar issues with OEM's laptop quality years ago with both HP and Dell. System76 laptops have been a pleasure to use. The new Lemur Pro has a 10th gen CPU, does not have a numpad, and does have an FHD panel. They claim up to 14 hours of battery life on Linux. (21 hours coding on VIM.) https://system76.com/laptops/lemur https://system76.com/laptops/lemur https://www.fosslinux.com/36826/system76-lemur-pro-a-linux-laptop-with-the-best-battery-life.htm https://www.fosslinux.com/36826/system76-lemur-pro-a-linux-l...
- ptomato 6y agoIf he's (reasonably!) not happy with Lenovo's build quality, he's absolutely not going to be happy with Clevo.
- zitterbewegung 6y agoI had a friend who bought one and it stopped working after two years. Their build quality is worse.
- zamalek 6y agoA guy at work installed Windows on his MacBook. He claimed it was the best Windows machine around. I'm not sure if his tune changed after Retina, because I really do have to hand it to Apple there: their high-DPI scaling is flawless.
- stevewillows 6y agoI bootcamp'd Windows LTSC on my old late 2013 MBP. Your friend's experience is similar to mine. Everything is smooth and the magic trackpad 2 works flawlessly, which used to be an issue with Windows. I won't switch back to Windows, but if I ever need to, I'd definitely consider using a MBP for it.
- dzonga 6y agox1 carbon, yeah good. but the T-Series are better. any thin, laptop you're gonna run into the same macbook problems, due the design constraints of letting the laptop be thin and lighweight. I have a t490, hardware solid all around. though lenovo put clippers on the bottom panel. don't know why. I know previous models t480 etc didn't have clippers.
- ebg13 6y agoClippers?