5 ms·
The article has a very strong "throw enough sh__ and see how much of it sticks" tone to it. Mark Zuckerberg asking Xi for a baby name or American entertainment
by Barrin92 6y ago
The article has a very strong "throw enough sh__ and see how much of it sticks" tone to it. Mark Zuckerberg asking Xi for a baby name or American entertainment producers trying to play friendly with the Chinese market isn't really 'enabling the communist party' in any meaningful sense of the word. And Chinese media replaying some CNN clip isn't really evidence of anything either given that you can take everything out of context.
The one thing from the article I'd agree with is bad is Bloomberg interferring with the journalists reporting at his own company. There should be a strict line between Bloombergs other business interests and the editorial at the newspaper.
Otherwise I think there's a lot of confusion in the article between the conflation of the private market changing products to be popular in China, which is fine and simply reflects their status as a consumer, and actual propaganda efforts.
- speechisaright9 6y ago> The one thing from the article I'd agree with is bad is Bloomberg interferring with the journalists reporting at his own company. There should be a strict line between Bloombergs other business interests and the editorial at the newspaper. Should there be? The mantra we keep hearing is that private companies have no obligation to observe human rights like freedom of speech or freedom of the press. Don't like it? Why just start your own news service of course.
- woutr_be 6y ago> American entertainment producers trying to play friendly with the Chinese market isn't really 'enabling the communist party' in any meaningful sense of the word I think this is where a lot of people would disagree. Once companies give in to demands of censorship or anything that goes against our Western values, you're basically letting China know that they can get away with it. And to me, that's directly enabling their behaviour. On the other side, if you don't give in to their demands, you're essentially missing out on a huge market, so most companies pick money over morals. There's a difference between changing products to be popular in China, and censoring words to be allowed to operate in China. Sadly for a lot of companies, one cannot go without the other.
- 082349872349872 6y agoAs a capitalist in a third world country, it seems like in principle a bit of competition ought to be good for both the 2nd and 1st largest economies. Remember the Avis "we try harder" campaign?
- woutr_be 6y agoIn principle, competition is good, I agree. However, in this case, you need to give up your principles to even be allowed to compete. Look at what happened to the NBA, they didn't give in to China's demands, and just like that, they're out. The same goes for any company that's not willing to give up it's morals and values. That's not competition, that's just extortion.
- CountSessine 6y agoExcept this isn’t commercial competition - it’s a competition in values and the role of the state in people’s lives. It’s Enlightenment values vs thinly disguised fascism. It’s a competition, alright - just be careful which side you’re fighting for.
- 082349872349872 6y agoThankfully there are almost two hundred sides from which to choose. Il faut de tout pour faire un monde. Nie mój cyrk, nie moje malpy.
- KONAir 6y agoThe entertainment industry in a globalized market will act according to demands (and regulations if any left) in the market and nothing else. It is fascinating to watch as popcultures "values" slowly shift towards the bigger market that is China and create an awkward set of synthesized values (most recent and talked about being new Star Wars movies).
- bsder 6y ago> Otherwise I think there's a lot of confusion in the article between the conflation of the private market changing products to be popular in China, which is fine and simply reflects their status as a consumer I, personally, have a problem with this. It's part of the reason why Hollywood movies have devolved into such pablum--you can't risk pissing of China now that 1/2 of your income is due to the Chinese release. I no longer consider doing business with China to be "neutral". China doesn't regard it this way either--China is more than happy to throw it's weight around against American businesses--see Blizzard. So we should treat them reciprocally. It's time to disconnect from China.
- Barrin92 6y ago>It's part of the reason why Hollywood movies have devolved into such pablum--you can't risk pissing of China now that 1/2 of your income is due to the Chinese release. You also could never afford to piss America off, which is why every other protagonist in hollywood movies is some Tom Cruise lookalike who combats people who speak English in a broken Russian accent. Just seems normal to me, the only difference is that the other 95% of the world population now have enough cash to vote with their wallets and American companies learn what it's like to operate in a world where different cultures have different values. Sure you can disconnect from everyone, but that doesn't sound wise long term, in particular not for Hollywood.
- airocker 6y agoWhat if the "value" is bullying/stealing? I think the comment suggests "learn to live with it".
- woutr_be 6y ago> You also could never afford to piss America off, which is why every other protagonist in hollywood movies is some Tom Cruise lookalike who combats people who speak English in a broken Russian accent. This is different tho. You can produce a movie that pisses off people, and still have it play in theatres. If you make a movie that pisses of the Chinese government, not necessarily the people, then that movie won't even be shown in China.
- dntbnmpls 6y ago> The article has a very strong "throw enough sh__ and see how much of it sticks" tone to it. It's intpolicydigest. What did you expect? What you don't know what intpolicydigest is? Yeah me either. But the article is just the rehash of the same propaganda you see all over social media and "news" sites like foxnews, breitbart, etc. That china has some pull in media due to its potential lucrative market isn't news. But the idea that they have enablers is laughable. If they had enablers, we wouldn't have had nonstop propaganda about ughyurs, organs, coronavirus, etc for months on end. Israel, Saudi Arabia and britain have enablers in our media. China is on the outside looking in. But I have a sneaking suspicions intpolicydigest isn't going to run hitpieces on israel or saudi arabia. Speaking of enablers, I would love to see who the enablers of "intpolicydigest" are.