3 ms·
>Just a thought experiment, does Youtube need to be as big as it is? A few scattered moderation complaints compared to wholesale rate limiting of incoming cont
by colechristensen 6y ago
>Just a thought experiment, does Youtube need to be as big as it is?
A few scattered moderation complaints compared to wholesale rate limiting of incoming content... I can only imagine the madness of content producers if YouTube tried that.
>Youtube has near perfect knowledge of the warm data of their operations, and use it to optimize user frustration rather than minimize it
YouTube content moderation isn't human spaceflight. Having a goal of never failing is, well, a very inexperienced way of thinking about failure. On the order of half a million hours of new video content a day goes on YouTube, or something like 6 million uploads.
Let's just pretend that the moderation decision is only made once on upload, you make 6 million decisions a day, how many ridiculous decisions are you going to make every day?
Do you think that number is ever going to be zero? The reality is that there is an exponential relationship.
Let's just say you can double your cost to cut failures in half. If it's not that relationship it'll be something like it.
You can just keep doing it. Doubling your cost over and over, and you're still going to fail all the time. When a "one in a million" chance means something happens several times a day, well, you have to have a different attitude about failure.
And when you're just about the only game in town, whatever you do to mitigate failure is going to attract people trying to screw with you to upset you and your users, to take advantage. Not only are you trying not to fail every day, you're trying to avoid people exploiting those attempts. It's just reality that you have a popular service, there is going to be some nonzero number of very upset users with just cause to be upset. That's just reality.
- acituan 6y ago> A few scattered moderation complaints compared to wholesale rate limiting of incoming content I'm sure there is already some per-user upload rate limits in place to prevent gross abuse. It is a matter of playing with these parameters. Rate limits don't have to be distributed mindlessly equally globally. Just like in Hacker News or in Twitter, certain proxy variables like the account age and karma scores are used to assess abuse potential and certain capabilities of the platform is unlocked to the user. Most probably something like this also exists. Again, it is a matter of playing with these parameters. Additionally, "few scattered complaints" suffer from selection bias in telling what is actually going on. Not all policy (mis)applications transform into a complaint. If I had to guess, the ratio could be at least an order of magnitude but obviously we have no data on this. > Do you think that number is ever going to be zero? Zero complaints is a straw-man end-state. Of course there is going to be diminishing returns. You can aim to minimize user complaints at 80% to save from diminishing returns, or you can aim to maximize platform usage and ad revenue and take user frustration into account only to the extent it affects platform usage maximization. You can operate on either goals while paying attention to diminishing returns. Very simplistically, there is a relationship such that "for every x dollars we don't spend on reducing abuse, we lose y dollars in user frustration". Who decides the satisficing ratio between x and y? This optimization is done asymmetrically by these types of services and in general there is no way for us to say "wait a second, turns out you were abusing your users/letting them get abused more than you should while making a smidge more profit out of it" with such information asymmetry.
- colechristensen 6y ago>Zero complaints is a straw-man end-state. The comment of yours I was responding to >use it to optimize user frustration rather than minimize it It is not at all a straw man. You are criticizing nonzero optimization and encouraging minimization. To minimize is to have a goal of zero. What other definitions do minimize and optimize have in the dichotomy you are trying to make here?
- acituan 6y ago> To minimize is to have a goal of zero That's not what minimize means at all, hence my straw man argument. Minimize means reducing the amount as much as possible while still satisfying other parameters of your equation. Zero makes the whole operation nonviable as we agree due to diminishing returns, so it doesn't satisfy that definition. The dichotomy of optimizing user frustration and minimizing user frustration is basically a question of what parameter gets what valence in the whole objective function. Maximizing profit at the expense of user frustration is optimizing user frustration, meaning having the perfect amount of user frustration in which their leaving the platform and the cost of reducing the frustration is on balance. Minimizing user frustration means doing this the other way around and having a product that, as Google claims, serves "the user first". If you understood that to be zero, I hope it is clear now. At any rate my point doesn't hinge on what the minimal point is. It is clear that any goal other than optimizing user frustration will be an improvement to current situation as far as what users get out of the transaction, and it is unlikely to be adopted.
- colechristensen 6y ago> Minimize means reducing the amount as much as possible while still satisfying other parameters of your equation. > basically a question of what parameter gets what valence in the whole objective function You're splitting extremely fine hairs there, your difference between minimize and optimize seems to be not much more than how much you like a term "satisfying other parameters of your equation". >Minimize means reducing the amount as much as possible while still satisfying other parameters of your equation. You have to stop after "as much as possible". Adding a "while still" makes it optimization, your value judgment doesn't get to determine what does and does not fit inside the "while still" of minimize. Once somebody calls me out for a logical fallacy based on their own difficult to understand definitions of seemingly common words... if that can't be resolved there really isn't a point in continuing, it's not like we could really communicate anything much less make arguments if we can't agree what minimize means.