3 ms·
The existence of the aether isn't borne out by experiments; rather, we have justification in believing in its non-existence. The algorithms of AI of decades pa
by kazinator 6y ago
The existence of the aether isn't borne out by experiments; rather, we have justification in believing in its non-existence.
The algorithms of AI of decades past still work.
That's a big difference.
E.g. SHRDLU can be built today and you can have a conversation with it about its world of blocks.
Algorithms are artifacts of mathematics. To calculate distance between two points, we still use sqrt(dx^2 + dy^2); it doesn't go out of fashion due to advancements in topology.
- angry_octet 6y agoFine, plum pudding model of the atom then. It isn't perfect, but we don't throw out the name physics. I don't get this hate for new techniques being classified as AI. Just because they learn distributions instead of using classic prolog?
- kazinator 6y agoThe techniques aren't that new; all that is new is having the gigabytes upon gigabytes of RAM to run them, not too mention CPU power, and scads of data. I knew what a neural network was, and understood it as part of AI, when Wham! was in the Top 40 charts. The hate isn't for the "new" techniques, I think; just for the posers who claim to be AI experts because they know how to use some Python library or whatnot. You don't have AI creds if you have no background in the symbolic stuff.
- angry_octet 6y agoWe'll have to disagree. You can be perfectly well credentialled without having years of studying techniques that aren't very successful. It is really rewriting history to pretend that old style NN and backpropagation is the same as modern systems -- implementation techniques matter.