2 ms·
The units aren’t the issue IMO. You said: > What they meant by that is 1/3 (of the students at a table) + 1/3 (of the students at a different table) = 2/6 (of
by amluto 6y ago
The units aren’t the issue IMO. You said:
> What they meant by that is 1/3 (of the students at a table) + 1/3 (of the students at a different table) = 2/6 (of the students at those tables).
That’s not what ‘+’ means. Addition doesn’t mean “I have this thing and the other thing; please describe the result”; addition means a specific operation on numbers (or on elements of an additive group, or on numbers with units, etc). But you cannot fully describe 1 student at table of three people as 1/3. Sure, 1/3 of the students at that table are that one student, but if you want to add across tables, you need more information and a better description.
Explaining this in a classroom setting may be quite challenging indeed.
- heisenzombie 6y agoI think you guys actually agree more than you think -- You say "you cannot fully describe 1 student at table of three people as 1/3", which is true: What's missing is the unit (or dimension, I'm ignoring the difference here). You can only add two things if they have the same units, as per "dimensional analysis" [1]. So this is an entirely meaningless statement: [students]/[seats at table 1] + [students]/[seats at table 2] But you can fix the units with some multiplication (because dimensions do form an Abelian group under multiplication): ([students]/[seats at table 1]) * ([seats at table 1]/[total seats]) + ([students]/[seats at table 2]) * ([seats at table 2]/[total seats]) Which simplifies to: [students]/[total seats] + [students]/[total seats] Now that's a statement with meaning! Since I know that [seats at table 1]/[total seats] = 1/2 [seats at table 2]/[total seats] = 1/2 I've just derived the calculation that I really wanted to do: (1/3)(1/2) + (1/3)(1/2) = (2/6) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dimensional_analysis#Dimensional_homogeneity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dimensional_analysis#Dimension...