6 ms·
Given today's anti-free-thinker HN climate I'm probably going to get downvoted to oblivion for saying this, but I feel I need to say it. I don't think COVID-19
by dheera 6y ago
Given today's anti-free-thinker HN climate I'm probably going to get downvoted to oblivion for saying this, but I feel I need to say it.
I don't think COVID-19 research should be secretive, I think it should be a global effort, and I'm perfectly happy with the idea of any nation having open access to all COVID-19 research, vaccines, results, and (anonymized) data. There should NOT be a concept of intellectual property when there are people dying in droves from a disease. Please, China, Italy, Spain, everywhere, scoop up all the COVID-19 research you can find and act upon it to save lives. Copy ideas. Copy drugs. Re-do and verify tests. Immediately. Don't mind the courts. They suck, and are sitting in armchairs killing people by delaying the effort and enforcing intellectual "property".
- spacephysics 6y agoBefore sanctioning stealing, perhaps the problem is two fold. China wants to have the first vaccine for: * Becoming the first to market, to try and salvage their reputation * Using the vaccine as leverage toward the incoming sanctions for violating the Hong Kong treaty during UK handover, as well as the now-declared possible non-peaceful reunification of Taiwan * monetary gain * leverage against the US restricting/removing Chinese’s companies from the NASDAQ I agree research should be open, but it’s hard to say to what degree, and how that might effect the economics of it. Whether we like it or not, capitalistic driven progress requires a reward, and one of the few reasons pharmaceutical companies will take the risk of finding a vaccine is the potential for increased reputation, and being first to market. Without those incentives, it’s straightforward to not to take a massive monetary risk as others are all working on similar problems, thus the likelihood that your lab will be the first is slim. Further, the crisis is a worldwide pandemic, but if the rate of natural immunity is as high as some predict, the efficacy of these vaccines may lead to less ‘sales’ than initially expected. Oxford running out of people to test their vaccine on: https://news.cgtn.com/news/2020-05-25/COVID-19-disappearing-so-fast-vaccine-has-50-chance-of-working-QMLMMAUWJO/index.html https://news.cgtn.com/news/2020-05-25/COVID-19-disappearing-... China report about Taiwan has “peaceful” removed: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-china-parliament-taiwan/china-drops-word-peaceful-in-latest-push-for-taiwan-reunification-idUSKBN22Y06S https://www.reuters.com/article/us-china-parliament-taiwan/c... China breaking the handover treaty: https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2020/05/china-hong-kong-pandemic-autonomy-law-aggression/611983/ https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2020/05/ch...
- anthony_doan 6y ago> * to try and salvage their reputation Really? They just recently ban Australia trades because Australia inquire about Covid19 origins. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/may/13/australia-china-trade-tensions-raise-fears-over-future-of-agricultural-exports https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/may/13/australia-chin...
- AYBABTME 6y agoAustralia is heavily economically dependent on China, so it's not really comparable.
- dheera 6y ago> Oxford running out of people to test their vaccine on: https://news.cgtn.com/news/2020-05-25/COVID-19-disappearing-.. https://news.cgtn.com/news/2020-05-25/COVID-19-disappearing-.... I'm not a medical expert, but can someone in the know comment on this? Can I volunteer to get the Oxford vaccine in the US? Can I volunteer to fly to UK and get the vaccine immediately upon arrival?
- dunkelheit 6y agoThe problem is not the absence of volunteers, the problem is that as the first wave of the epidemic recedes, most volunteers won’t catch the disease by themselves and thus will add no information as to whether the vaccine works. And challenge trials (deliberately infecting people) are apparently a big ethical no-no.
- dheera 6y agoWhile that's true, it is still possible to get data by giving the vaccine to as many people as possible and seeing if the virus recedes faster than previous models predicted. If the slope of the trend suddenly buckles when people start taking the shots, there's a good chance it did something. Although I'm also strongly against deliberately infecting people, if there is a high chance there is no danger to take the vaccine, and a strong possible upside (i.e. possibly save lives in the next 2 weeks), I don't see why we it isn't okay to volunteer to take it today, even if it isn't a fully conclusive data point. Hell, if there are 5 candidate vaccines, and they are all non-dangerous, I'd love to take all of them just to protect my own life, even if that makes me not as useful of a useful data point. There's a nonzero chance the virus will kill me in 2 weeks, 4 weeks, 6 weeks, and I think it is only ethical to reduce that chance even if that means 5 shots (pun intended) in the dark. Of course, I see people downvoting me and it seems HN doesn't welcome this type of discussion anymore.
- cscurmudgeon 6y ago> Given today's anti-free-thinker HN climate You should champion China to be more transparent about the origins of the virus. Even if it did not originate in a lab, shining more light on its origins will help prevent future outbreaks. China also actively prevented Taiwan from joining the WHO. This would have resulted in more free flow of information. Curiously, I was a labelled a racist for making this statement. > Please, China, Italy, Spain, everywhere, scoop up all the COVID-19 research you can find and act upon it to save lives. Copy China does not do anything for free. Let us not pretend that China is angelic. Have you heard of debt diplomacy? So we are excusing one of the most locked up countries in terms of information to hack into cutting edge research in a free society.
- zxcmx 6y agoYou didn't address what parent said at all. Parent said all COVID-19 research should be freely available to all as a matter of principle. What China does or doesn't do has no bearing on this.
- cscurmudgeon 6y agoDoesn't the origin and initial spread of the virus fall under COVID-19 research? Is it fair and ethical to ask country A to make free all research while being okay with country B hiding its own research on the same subject? Let us not whitewash unethical behavior with broad strokes of "freely available to all as a matter of principle."
- scarmig 6y ago> Is it fair and ethical to ask country A to make free all research while being okay with country B hiding its own research on the same subject? An American journalist toured the Soviet Union in the 1930s. Everyone he spoke to proudly bragged about the USSR and its accomplishments. But some things seemed off. He asked about the mass starvation, and his handler explained it was because the kulaks destroyed their food to spite the people. He questioned why newspapers would one day say one thing, and the next denounce the same as counterrevolutionary. His handler responded, there was no difference, he's just misunderstanding the context. Finally he asked about political opponents mysteriously disappearing when they stood against Stalin. Exasperated, the handler shrieked, "And you are lynching negroes!"
- mensetmanusman 6y agoSomeone should profit for figuring out how to stop COVID because otherwise there is little incentive beyond the government, and they don’t typically work nights and weekends. If China succeeds in stealing the solution, that will harm mankind because it will reduce future incentive to stop these things quickly.
- nineparts 6y agoNot to mention that if they find a cure before the world they will mark it as "strategical advantage" and not shared because it's of "national interest." At least based on their past history.
- request_id 6y agoAre we talking about China or US?
- mapgrep 6y ago>there is little incentive beyond the government, and they don’t typically work nights and weekends The government certainly doesn’t pull long hours. Beyond the military. They do pull some late nights and cold field deployments in the DoD. And beyond local police and fire. And state troopers. Law enforcement does go late and I’m pretty sure fire departments deploy all night. But of course those are not federal. There is, obviously, the FBI. Those agents are mostly not up at night though. Now, CBP and TSA staff air and sea ports pretty late but that’s different. The diplomatic corps also works pretty late hours if I remember my leaked cables correctly. But again, an exception. And they get to go to fancy parties. Obviously people in Congressional staff offices, political advisers in the executive branch, and so forth. But those folk are essentially politicians. FEMA. Pretty sure some of them stay up. Other than our armed forces and supporting staff (good morning NSA NSOC), police and fire departments, federal law enforcement, State Department diplomatic staff, staff for elected officials, and FEMA, no one I can think of right now in government stays up late. Intelligence community, forgot them, other than NSA and FBI. At least some of the 14 other members probably work late, I think? NGA, at least. But no you’re right, why would we want government scientists like those at NASA, CDC and the EPA working as leading exemplars of COVID research. Surely they are lazy. And they show good work does not happen without a profit motive.
- zachguo 6y agohttps://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-05-18/china-s-virus-vaccine-will-be-global-public-good-xi-says https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-05-18/china-s-v... China promised to give its covid-19 vaccine to WHO for free. If the accusation is true, it's basically Robinhood for poor countries.