3 ms·
You can't just ignore the fact that people didn't conceive of fractions as the smallest field containing an integral domain with a specific equivalence relation
by Spivak 6y ago
You can't just ignore the fact that people didn't conceive of fractions as the smallest field containing an integral domain with a specific equivalence relation. They are an intuitive idea that has had its grammar formalized. It is absolutely beautiful to see fractions from the ten thousand foot abstractions but you can't skip to the end.
Also, looking at maths from this pure beautiful abstract lens is something that some people (hiii!) enjoy but it's also the common language for modeling problems in the real world. And sure, we do sometimes intentionally confuse the fact that modeling systems with maths is supposed to be descriptive but we have no choice because otherwise we're betraying the fact that the attempt to describe these systems is where the notation came from in the first place.
All this is to say that teaching math is hard and that the abstract "rules" view doesn't do it justice. It's practical for sure but it's also the reason you have lots of students who are good at pushing symbols around but not much else.