4 ms·
I don't have a firm opinion on whether the lockdowns were good or bad, but: it bothers me more that no one seemed to even consider alternative options, opportun
by keiferski 6y ago
I don't have a firm opinion on whether the lockdowns were good or bad, but: it bothers me more that no one seemed to even consider alternative options, opportunity costs, or second-and-third-order consequences.
It feels like the powers that be are playing whack-a-mole, incapable of seeing beyond the immediate problem. It doesn't bode well for a potential future (hopefully avoidable) pandemic that has far higher death rates. The Black Death, for example, is 'estimated to have killed 30% to 60% of Europe's population.'
- dan_quixote 6y agoI'd venture to say that our initial reaction to lock down early-on was prudent. The scant evidence available at the time indicated the possibility of a much worse outcome than we have now. I think the problem is a lack of constant re-evaluation. Politics has solidified the desire of many people to make the "correct" decision and stick to it. Why can't we be comfortable with making a decision with partial information and treating it like a ship that needs occasional course-correction?
- riskneutral 6y agoThe problem is that we cannot agree with which way we should sail the ship. Our navigator showed us a map that said "there be dragons" and told us to steer far off course putting us into a perilous situation of being adrift and lost at sea. Now we cannot agree which direction looks less stormy and whether we should try to head back to land or continue to starve at sea.
- dan_quixote 6y agoMost definitely. To further the analogy...picking the heading is a democratic election. The remaining 3/4 years of an election cycle are spent undermining the choice of heading.
- crystalmeph 6y ago> It doesn't bode well for a potential future (hopefully avoidable) pandemic that has far higher death rates. I think that if COVID19 was more deadly, we'd have a lot more agreement on implementing lockdowns, and not nearly as much politicization of the issue. I think that the polarization we are seeing regarding lockdown policies is because COVID19 sits right in the middle of what the population at large thinks of as "very dangerous." It's not quite half-and-half, but I think it breaks down like this: I think it's fair to say that a very large minority looks at a disease that mostly targets the elderly and infirm and thinks, "why don't we take measures to protect the vulnerable populations who aren't getting out much anyway, and let the rest of the world get on with life?" This isn't just about "making money" to these people, it's actually about living your life, and accepting what is in reality a pretty small risk for most healthy people. One the other hand, a not-quite-supermajority believes that a disease which is 10-100 times deadlier than the typical flu when looking at raw fatality numbers is worth significant cost and effort to suppress. This would also include a significant portion of people who are themselves elderly or infirm, and they don't want to risk society neglecting to protect them if everyone else is allowed to go about their business. It could well be that if the fatality rate really was > 3%, you would have a hyper-majority in favor of taking action, which means we would have all been in agreement about how to react, really locked down hard and eliminated it by now.