5 ms·
Still no one can answer the question of where do you charge one if you rent an apartment with no parking or a terraced house with no driveway. Don't get me wron
by gambiting 6y ago
Still no one can answer the question of where do you charge one if you rent an apartment with no parking or a terraced house with no driveway. Don't get me wrong, I'm planning to go 100% electric in the next few years, but then we're lucky enough to have a house with a double driveway - I have no idea how it can possibly work for people without dedicated parking.
- mongol 6y agoOne possibility is swappable batteries. So that there are places you drive, like a gas station, and a robot swaps the battery in a minute.
- gambiting 6y agoSure, but this simply doesn't exist. It's Sci-Fi at this point. A lot of countries are planning a complete ban on petrol/diesel new cars within 10-20 years, yet there are no such signs of such systems(and I suspect there won't be, since every single manufacturer uses different batteries of different shapes and sizes, in some EVs the batteries are simply not removable without hours of work first). Doing this would require standardization, and seeing as we're still in the early innovation phase, that would practically be suicide for the tech.
- pmalynin 6y agoTesla built some in California as a test bed
- exhilaration 6y agoYou'll need cities to do large scale deployments of streetlight chargers like these: https://electrek.co/2019/11/13/la-adds-hundreds-of-ev-chargers-to-streetlights-giving-renters-a-place-to-plug-in/ https://electrek.co/2019/11/13/la-adds-hundreds-of-ev-charge... I don't know if it'll require upgrades to the power grid. You've already got 240v in Europe, so that's only ~10 hours to charge a Tesla. But could it handle thousands of EVs charging simultaneously? If there's any place in the world that can do this it's Europe.
- gambiting 6y agoI still don't think that this will be anywhere enough. This is a street I used to live on: https://www.google.pl/maps/@54.9941128,-1.6077652,3a,75y,286.07h,83.41t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1s7cvbpIjZQUq7Z8XmmLrpmQ!2e0!6s%2F%2Fgeo3.ggpht.com%2Fcbk%3Fpanoid%3D7cvbpIjZQUq7Z8XmmLrpmQ%26output%3Dthumbnail%26cb_client%3Dmaps_sv.tactile.gps%26thumb%3D2%26w%3D203%26h%3D100%26yaw%3D120.73338%26pitch%3D0%26thumbfov%3D100!7i13312!8i6656 https://www.google.pl/maps/@54.9941128,-1.6077652,3a,75y,286... From top to bottom, it would fit about 40 cars - but there's only 6-8 street lamps? Ok, so maybe the council could fit a new charging post every 10 metres or so - but then the question is, with what money? There's hardly any cash to keep maintaining the roads at all, where would they find the money to dig up every single street in the city and put in charging posts? Even if they are paid, you'd wait a very long time to make your money back, and then there's another issue I have - at home, I can charge my car at about £0.12/kWh during the day and £0.05/kWh during the night. But public charging points I can see around at crazy expensive - like £0.30-£0.40 per kWh. At that point, it's literally cheaper to drive a good diesel.
- ChuckNorris89 6y ago1000x this! People never stop to ask themselves who will pay for the infrastructure needed to upgrade the existing public electrical networks in our cities to support everyone charging their EVs on the street. Lots of European cities are broke at this point and have much bigger problems to fix right now than EV charging stations and if private companies would install them across the cities, the charging costs would be high enough to make EVs ownership unappealing. Add the fact that EVs here are more expensive than in the US and you have the reason why most EVs right now are only owned by upper class people who can afford to have their own private charging station on their own property. There's a reason diesel ICEs, as dirty as they are, are still so popular in Europe. They're cheap to run. Ironically, as green as it may be, Europe will fall behind China and the US at mass EV adoption. Unless they'd be given away for free, expecting EVs to take over the market here in 5 to 8 years is dreaming at best.
- xyzzyz 6y ago
- jccooper 6y agoCharging at home or at work is best with electrics, but the gas station model is still possible. With a range of 500-600km and high power charging at 1000-1500kph, which is all being done right now, you can go somewhere and charge once or twice a week. It's not quite as convenient at 20-30 minutes, but it's possible; when combined with some sort of destination, like a grocery store, it's more time-efficient.
- gambiting 6y agoYes, except that as I pointed out in my other comment - public stations around me charge about £0.30-£0.40 per kWh(and I know that rapid stations near motorways charge even more) - at that price, it's literally cheaper to drive a diesel. Yes, we can make an argument that once people have no choice, they will pay that money to charge anyway. But privately-owned infrastructure has no reason to be free or cheap, except for the very initial period when say shopping centres are trying to attract EV drivers. Once they are essential infrastructure it's hard to see them being cheap.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoWhy would you you expect shopping centers to stop wanting to attract EV drivers? It's practically their dream to have everybody wandering around in the mall for an hour or more with nothing better to do than buy stuff because they're waiting for their car to charge.
- xyzzyz 6y agoPrivately owned infrastructure has good reason to be cheap, that is, competition from of their privately owned businesses. Food distribution network is much more essential than EV charging, and yet food is now cheaper than ever. What matters is not how essential something is, but rather at what cost the service can be provided. If a charging station can expect many customers use it, which will quickly amortize the capital costs of construction, you’ll see charging prices at those stations go not much higher than the operational costs. Otherwise, if the prices are high, this incentivizes new businesses to enter the market and undercut existing producers. Lots of essential infrastructure is cheap because of competition, like for example electricity generation. There is no reason to believe EV charging will be different. Of course, it might also turn out that while electricity costs are low, other costs of running charging business are high. If that’s the case, that doesn’t bode well for EV adoption in among people who don’t live in houses.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> Still no one can answer the question of where do you charge one if you rent an apartment with no parking or a terraced house with no driveway. The first customers are people who can install a charging port where they normally park their car. That's probably more than half of car owners, and gets you to at least a double digit percentage of cars as electric. At that point there are enough electric cars that a charger starts getting installed anywhere there's a lot of parking. Then more people can buy EVs, and do, so more chargers get installed. By the time most cars are electric they'll be everywhere.
- RandallBrown 6y agoYou charge at charging stations that are nearby where you live, just like people do with gas stations now. You can charge while you get groceries (or a haircut, or dinner, or whatever) and then go on with your day. Certainly not as convenient as charging at home, but not impossible.
- Hypx 6y agoStill surprising how members of this website are still mostly blind to the obviousness of fuel cell cars. Just turn that excess electricity from renewables and convert it to hydrogen, powering a fleet of hydrogen powered vehicles. Solves all infrastructure issues being brought up. Furthermore, it's possible to power large vehicles like semi-trucks or ships, even aircraft at some point in the future.
- gambiting 6y agoOn the other hand, I'm constantly surprised how anyone anywhere still thinks that fuel cell cars are a good idea. There is zero elemental hydrogen on Earth. 99% of the one we use is a byproduct of fossil fuel industry. Yes, you can produce it from electrolysis, but not only the hydrogen produced this way will never "break even" it's actually much worse than "even" since you then need to spend a whole load of energy to compress it and bottle it. Why not...just put the electricity into the existing grid and charge automotive batteries directly? After all, fuel cell cars are electric cars, direct combustion of hydrogen was experimental and extremely inefficient. That brings me to my next point - hydrogen has the smallest molecule of all, which means that it evaporates naturally through any container you put it in. 70kg lead bottle only holds 1L of hydrogen, and it naturally loses all of it in 2-3 weeks. So no underground carparks, garages etc because of the explosion risks. But finally - there is no infrastructure for hydrogen. It's like trying to build a network of petrol stations....from scratch. And batteries are definitely good enough to power larger trucks, it's just the cost that's prohibitive(enough cells for a large semi would cost many times more than the truck itself).
- Hypx 6y agoI must inform you that you're mostly spreading ignorance or obsolete information with claims like those. Most of the claims you're making are either wrong or many years out of date. > There is zero elemental hydrogen on Earth. Not actually true. As I understand it, reserves of natural hydrogen do exist underground, similar to how helium is sometimes trapped underground in certain formations. These could potentially be huge source of hydrogen, although right now it's just speculation. > Yes, you can produce it from electrolysis, but not only the hydrogen produced this way will never "break even" it's actually much worse than "even" since you then need to spend a whole load of energy to compress it and bottle it. Since we live in a world of zero priced, and sometimes negatively priced renewable electricity, this is a non-issue. In fact, it's irrelevant. The biggest motivation for green hydrogen right now is the fact that we have far more green energy that we can use for large stretches of time on the grid. We're currently "curtailing" that electricity, which is a fancy word meaning that we're throwing it away. Turning what is in effect a waste product into a valuable new fuel is a big gain. > Why not...just put the electricity into the existing grid and charge automotive batteries directly? After all, fuel cell cars are electric cars, direct combustion of hydrogen was experimental and extremely inefficient. Largely because we can't match production with demand. As I mentioned above, we have huge surpluses during parts of the day, but also we have huge shortages at other times. Using hydrogen as a load balancer is an excellent idea right now. We can do this to a certain extent using batteries or pumped water, but we quickly run into the limits of these technologies. Hydrogen can be stored in far larger quantities than any battery in the form of underground salt caverns. > That brings me to my next point - hydrogen has the smallest molecule of all, which means that it evaporates naturally through any container you put it in. 70kg lead bottle only holds 1L of hydrogen, and it naturally loses all of it in 2-3 weeks. So no underground carparks, garages etc because of the explosion risks. Carbon fiber tanks have long since solved this problem. We know this since you can buy FCEVs right now, and they are perfectly fine vehicle with none of the above issues. Indeed, I've seen quite a few hydrogen skeptics review these cars, and while they maintain their skepticism of the idea of hydrogen, they seem to be at a loss at describing any kind of real shortcoming in the technology itself. > But finally - there is no infrastructure for hydrogen. It's like trying to build a network of petrol stations....from scratch. This is changing. There are now hundreds of hydrogen refuel stations around the world, and many more being built. This is particularly true in Asia, where governments in that region have sponsored huge hydrogen infrastructure buildouts. > And batteries are definitely good enough to power larger trucks, it's just the cost that's prohibitive(enough cells for a large semi would cost many times more than the truck itself). There many problems with battery powered semi-trucks. Cost is one of them, and weight is another big one. Furthermore, recharging them in a few minutes is a huge selling point, and batteries cannot deliver on that need. FCEVs are a much better answer for long-haul trucking than BEVs.