3 ms·
The description of “shake” is something that I would expect to have “in the West” as well, by now, but still... nothing. Connecting to someone’s online identity
by toyg 6y ago
The description of “shake” is something that I would expect to have “in the West” as well, by now, but still... nothing. Connecting to someone’s online identity when meeting or soon afterward is still somewhat awkward - either rely on old-school phone numbers, which are long and error-prone, or on names and usernames you can misspell.
I get that it’s hard to do this while respecting the more privacy-oriented sensibilities “we” have, but surely it’s not impossible. Is there anything I’m missing, like some cool app that teenagers use...? LinkedIn, for example, should absolutely add it.
- john_miller 6y agoIt existed, but was shut down after the company was acquired by google. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bump_(application) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bump_(application)
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> LinkedIn, for example, should absolutely add it Did they try a digital business card that went nowhere?
- toyg 6y agoIf they did, I didn't even see it. I am a heavy business-card user, and I still lack a good app to do that with my phone - which seems silly.
- Ensorceled 6y ago"Shake"? You mean "bump" don't you? This has been tried numerous times before ... https://thenextweb.com/apps/2011/01/23/5-mobile-apps-that-could-kill-business-cards/ https://thenextweb.com/apps/2011/01/23/5-mobile-apps-that-co...
- toyg 6y agoBump had bootstrapping problems (if I have it but you don't, it's useless), and it was also not particularly reliable at the time because of hardware quality. To be clear: I don't think this sort of thing alone is enough to bootstrap on its own in a market with established social networks, but I don't understand why such social networks don't offer it as a feature.
- salawat 6y agoCould someone explain why the guy who pointed out Bump existed and was discontinued after acquisition by Google got downvoted into oblivion, aside from the fact it was apparently more tooled for facilitating NFC file transfers? Seems a bit odd.
- ShamelessC 6y agoIsn't "shake" described as a way to meet strangers who move their phone's in a specific way? How do people use this to connect to each other online after meeting in person?
- pas 6y agoEmail. Or take a photo of a QR code, or take a photo of the email address. Or take a photo of the phone number. Or call the other one to confirm that you've typed the correct number, and the other party will be able to instantly save your number too. I think this problem is not that big of a problem. After all, worst case, you can just hand out a paper business card. There's rarely a need to get someone's contact details without even knowing who they are, at least their name, etc. And when we have their name and we can link them to something (a common friend, a company), we can usually find them quite easily. Or am I mistaken? Are there examples where bump/shake would be really that useful?
- toyg 6y ago> Email Awkward to spell and to remember, unless you write it right there and then and get the other to proofread it. You also get a single piece of information, not even a full name. > QR code Pretty uncommon where I live (Northern UK), particularly outside geeky circles. > take a photo of the email address This is occasionally done but it's annoying (you have to transcribe it later) and again is unlikely to carry any other data like the guy's name. > Or call the other one to confirm that you've typed the correct number It takes time out of the conversation to proofread the contact name as you save it, and you're then lacking email - yeah you can get it with a phone call, which is already pretty awkward ("can I call you to send you an email to organise a call"), and again spelling an email over the phone is pretty bad and error-prone. > worst case, you can just hand out a paper business card. That's what I do, but apart from the environmental impact, you then have to print and store a bunch of cards and every time you change job it takes weeks (or months) to get new ones (and cringe at their design). Dunno, maybe I'm more sensitive to this because my name is difficult to spell for English people, but I do wish I could avoid having to drag with me stacks of thick paper. > Are there examples where bump/shake would be really that useful? Trade shows, sales events, all the way to going to a bar and it turns out some guy is a decorator you might call on.
- pas 6y ago> Trade shows, sales events, all the way to going to a bar and it turns out some guy is a decorator you might call on. Hm, in my experience for sales stuff you need a card. There's no real way around it. And that's only halfway there, the real thing is when you make the other party take a picture of the card, or .. if you ask their email and send them a hello with your signature containing your info. (Yes, it's awkward, seems dumb, but works exactly because the effort the other party put into it. Just taking a card and putting it next to the other taken cards is just a one-way stop-shop to a dead lead - IMHO.) Decorator guy? Just type it into your phone. Or send yourself an email with call decorator guy, Tim, [number]. or something. Sure, maybe there will be some amazing system/solution/app that does this. (Technically it's easy. For example you can just fire up a Bluetooth BLE beacon - eg. a Eddystone URL one. You can switch broadcasting on/off with a toggle. https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=net.alea.beaconsimulator&hl=en https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=net.alea.beaco... And others can scan for them easily.) But it seems to me the biggest hurdle is simply that people don't want that. They want maximal certainty that they get the info from the person they are actually talking to. (NFC could help with that.) ... and let's say a trade show can start with everyone setting up their contact app. And I think some already do this. (Some already hand out name tags after all.)
- majormajor 6y agoThis seems like one of those things that sounds nice, but isn't special enough to supplant the existing good-enough-for-most-people methods that are already must more entrenched (phone #, email, in-app QR codes come to mind first). Especially since there isn't a single "online identity" for most people in the US, and as you mention sharing selectively is arguably a feature, not a bug. There are lots of examples of "good enough" stuff preventing adoption of newer tech across the world. I see stuff like the weird US checking account clearance system in this bucket - it would be really expensive to replace, so despite there being newer, better systems elsewhere, it's seen as "good enough" - or the relatively slow uptake of electronic payment in Japan even as cash-based vending machines were far more ubiquitous than elsewhere. That's a lot of infrastructure to upgrade, so advantages have to be extreme, not just present.