4 ms·
I remember this quote from Larry Sabato, famous political science professor from UVA: "online education is something you want other parents' children to do". P
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
I remember this quote from Larry Sabato, famous political science professor from UVA: "online education is something you want other parents' children to do".
People who think college is just about, or honestly even primarily about, learning various subjects show a deep misunderstanding of what college is in my opinion. Online learning will of course have a place, but in a world where there are both in-person and exclusively online options it's not hard to imagine which experience top students (not to mention the rich and connected) will prefer, and this will only lead to more inequality in higher education.
- troughway 6y agoNot only that but I'm surprised the article doesn't mention, in light of companies adjusting pay for people who "work from anywhere", that the validity of a degree itself may end up playing a part. What if online degrees end up being valued less over all? It won't surprise me if NYT changes it's tone some years from now and reflects back on "what could have been". Not the first time, not the last time.
- ddrt 6y agoSounds like snake oil when you put it that way.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- non-entity 6y agoHonestly a lot of the newer and "innovative" online programs I've seen, even from legitimate institutions, sound very suspicious when I read about them
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- DoreenMichele 6y agoI was a top student. I have taken online college classes. I didn't find them inferior to in-person classes in terms of teaching the material. In some ways, they can be better (though they are also gameable -- on the other hand, kids have been gaming the system since time immemorial). From what I have read, elite colleges are a place where personal connections are made. Co-founders are often people you met at college and bonded with at college. This never did anything for me, personally. Maybe I went to the wrong schools. Maybe I'm the wrong gender. Maybe there's some other factor I'm missing. From what I have read, the strongest argument for attending college in person at an elite school is because of the personal connections that can result. Off the top of my head, I don't know of data explicitly stating this mostly applies to male students, but I would not be shocked if that was the conclusion of some study. There is, after all, the old tradition of saying a woman is going to college to "get her MRS." In other words, to get married and then to supposedly "do nothing" with her degree while she raises kids and supports her husband's career.
- btrettel 6y ago> From what I have read, elite colleges are a place where personal connections are made. Co-founders are often people you met at college and bonded with at college. I took a business law class (intellectual property law) during my (nearly complete) engineering PhD. I found the culture in business school to be really odd. The class was a mixture of law students, MBA students, and STEM students. You were required to bring a name plate, which I found really weird as a STEM person. To me a class is about learning the subject, not the specific personalities of each student. Later it all clicked to me: A MBA is partly about making personal connections and the name plates help with that. I had a similar experience in the business school startup class I took until the drop date. The basic lesson of the class seemed to be to not spend a lot of money until you're confident your product will be profitable. (Or at least that's the main thing I remember.) The class had name plates, and was fairly heavy on social gatherings to talk with others. Learning seemed secondary to me. The class had a few days where people pitched different business ideas they had, and I realized that I had little in common with everyone there from the pitches, so the chance of making a genuine connection seemed low. I had no problem dropping the class. Personally, I think I'd network better in other contexts.
- runawaybottle 6y agoOnline is just a delivery mechanism, an implementation detail. There is still the rigor of getting accepted into a program, proctoring exams, quality of teaching staff, guiding projects, grading, feedback, and curriculum progression. If we get hung up over the fact that physical lectures are not happening, and is now being delivered via digital tools, then that says a lot about the value of that program, that it loses it’s power soon as we modify one simple parameter. We can adjust that one parameter for probably over half of all degree programs, and keep the requirements for necessary physical things like lab work.
- nordsieck 6y ago> If we get hung up over the fact that physical lectures are not happening, and is now being delivered via digital tools, then that says a lot about the value of that program, that it loses it’s power soon as we modify one simple parameter. > We can adjust that one parameter for probably over half of all degree programs, and keep the requirements for necessary physical things like lab work. That's not the only parameter you're cutting out, though. You're also removing the "hallway track" to use conference parlance. It's definitely possible to make friends online, but it's much easier to make friends with people you spend a lot of time in person with.
- Buldak 6y ago>online education is something you want other parents' children to do This is true of a lot of college alternatives, from online classes to state schools to vocational training. Everyone insists that we should view these as viable, even superior options. But it's hard not to think that when push comes to shove most parents still want their own kids to go to Harvard (and are willing to go to some lengths to make that happen).
- akhilcacharya 6y agoI agree, not sure why this was downvoted. Peter Thiel (not someone I admire) had a good point about this - when Michelle Obama (someone I do admire) says that community college or your state school are fine places to get an education, it isn’t advice meant for Sasha or Malia.
- rdtwo 6y agoBut part of that is because they are part of the elite with the resource stockpile that comes with that status. If you are starting with zero or -30k then the math for community college ain’t so bad
- thebradbain 6y agoI agree — it’s not that online-learning has to be intrinsically, objectively of lower quality than traditional college education (indeed, some online-first courses I took for fun now offered on Coursera were better than I remember some of my in-person courses), but to think that college is only courses misses the point: it’s the opportunity to grow not just academically, but, just as important, socially and independently — at most schools, you’re meeting with peers from all over the world (or at least from outside your hometown), have direct interactions with professors renowned in their field who are (in my experience) eager to personally introduce you to opportunities you wouldn’t know about from searching the internet, and access to a vast collection of resources much more restricted to the public. To say college is just getting a degree is to miss out on all of the non-purely academic opportunities colleges offer. But aside from all of that — it’s also where many (not all) young adults go after high school to figure out who they are, who they want their friends to be, and what they want to do, as for most of them it’s their first taste of living as their own fully independent person. Something has to fill that vacuum.
- akhilcacharya 6y ago> Something has to fill that vacuum. There’s always the military or a peacetime national service program.
- thebradbain 6y agoBoth of those would seem to imply the virtual exclusion of anyone who is not a US-citizen
- akhilcacharya 6y agoNon-citizens are free to join the military for the record. It’s one of the more accessible ways of becoming a citizen on an accelerated timeframe.
- brightball 6y agoMet my wife and most of my best friends in college. I can’t even fathom the hole that a purely online experience would have left in my life.
- fish45 6y agoI'm going into college next year and while I've always loved online learning, I would be devastated to have college fully remotely. I'm not sure how badly it would effect me in terms of academics; I didn't really do much 2nd sem anyways, but I need to move out and learn to live on my own.
- coffeefirst 6y agoCorrect. There’s also a value in getting away from where you’re from and meeting entirely new people. The prices are too high, but I can’t be convinced that it’s possible to replace that kind of immersive experience with the internet. Besides, after two months of running virtually all communication over Zoom, does anyone still think video for everything is good enough?
- drewcoo 6y agoYou didn't say what you do think the point of college is. Just that unnamed people other than you misunderstand it. Granted, college is not just about gaining certification by authorities. But that's only your claim if I am very charitable. Your claim instead is about learning. Even spending money, meeting new people, and drinking irresponsibly can be learning experiences so I also have no idea what your claim actually is. Or why people seem to agree with you.
- downshun 6y ago> "online education is something you want other parents' children to do" Perhaps a degree is a proxy for measuring parental investment