3 ms·
Why not just make it opt-in? Lots of people would have done it right away and others would do it as they started to want new opportunities and/or got laid off.
by MattGaiser 6y ago
Why not just make it opt-in?
Lots of people would have done it right away and others would do it as they started to want new opportunities and/or got laid off.
Candidates who didn’t opt in probably wouldn’t be open to being contacted out of the blue anyway in a public manner.
They burned a lot of goodwill for nothing.
- jamestimmins 6y agoI suspect that this comes from tunnel vision and not interacting with enough casual users. Hypothetically, if the feedback they're seeing is that people desperately want jobs and will do whatever it takes, they may only be exposed to a subset that would have no qualms with making the info public. Especially if that subset is already out of work. I can imagine, in that scenario, not thinking about all the devs who signed up over the years and are no longer searching, or are searching but doing so quietly.
- hagy 6y agoAgreed. I could imagine how many of the most active users of their platform would be excited for any feature that improved their prospect of landing a job. Combined with the team's excitement for taking on LinkedIn and expanding their company, I could see how they'd fall into this tunnel vision. Initially I was quite unhappy with how their CEO blindly defended the decision on the earlier HN thread, but I gotta give him credit for changing his mind and drafting this earnest apology. Everyone is human and its easy to get caught up in your own bubble, especially when you've been excitedly executing on a vision with a team that also lives in that bubble. Still don't think I'll ever use their platform as either a member of a hiring team or as a job seeker. But at least this followup lessens my negative connotation for Triplebyte that developed over the previous few days.
- ammon 6y agoYeah... that's a much better idea. I can tell you what was going through my head on Friday (I'm not at all trying to defend this now). Basically, it was that for a credential to carry weight with recruiters, it needs scale. There's a bootstrapping problem. But that's not an excuse for violating people's privacy. Opt-in would have been a far better idea.
- weaksauce 6y agoIn the future it’s worth noting that it’s a terrible idea to take something away from someone when you promised them something else. This is privacy in this case. On others it’s offering something for free and then charging for it. Even if you wanted to make this an opt out feature the only sensible way to go about it is grandfathering in the old accounts into an opt in feature. Just like many companies grandfather in free customers while they charge new ones. This is the foundation of trust.
- everybodyknows 6y ago> take something away Quite true. T-Mobile is now forever to me the weasels that silently broke free Google Visual Voicemail in order to force me into their own, judging by the reviews quite crappy, paid app.
- ummonk 6y agoI've been through Triplebyte and am a fan of the mission. This was definitely a major screw-up, both for the opt-out and email dark patterns (I had skimmed the original email and assumed it was opt-in before I saw this thread), and for the subsequent doubling down in response to feedback. Glad you took some time to reflect and reverse course. I do think the bootstrapping problem is unfortunate - hopefully you can hit critical mass via opt-in.
- mlazos 6y agoNew features are almost never opt-in. It’s way more tempting to show a high user number in a status meeting than care about user privacy.
- fma 6y agoI'm not a user, but making the feature opt-in for existing users...and opt-out for new users would have seemed the make the most common sense. And this might go against the grain, but if I had to give up a bit of privacy and get an edge against a peer for job that I need...I'd likely do it. But it seems like a lot of complaints were from still employed engineers and having their employers find out.