3 ms·
What a great article. In particular I like that in the middle it provides an excellent example of how Marxist theory and vocabulary is deeply steeped* in the V
by gumby 6y ago
What a great article. In particular I like that in the middle it provides an excellent example of how Marxist theory and vocabulary is deeply steeped* in the Victorian capitalist vocabulary of the industrial revolution and how that model of thinking still affects us today. Specifically, on HN and the press in general, despite the discussion of “tech” business, the vast majority of businesses are mostly or completely low tech in their operation.
I have a quibble with the headline writer (which actually relates to the above): that capitalism didn’t arise without “factories”: as the article shows, the tea production process would have been perfectly clear to Adam Smith. It was simply low tech (and the article is quite clear about this). In addition, though “factory” today means manufacturing, in the early days of European empires, the “factory” was the warehouse where goods were stored and financed (factoring accounts receivable is still common today). The factories of the Bombay Presidency were the first effective toehold of British expansion into India. Over time value add (labor/processing) crept into those warehouses as the goods were already there, leading to today’s meaning. The author seems to understand this so it’s only whoever wrote the headline that I am criticizing.
* apologies for the accidental tea metaphor