5 ms·
I wouldn't mind so much working from home I think, but I'm privileged in that I'm a homeowner and have a desk in a bedroom away from the rest of the family; a l
by Cthulhu_ 6y ago
I wouldn't mind so much working from home I think, but I'm privileged in that I'm a homeowner and have a desk in a bedroom away from the rest of the family; a lot of people don't have this. So if remote-first becomes a thing, the workers have to be able to afford and live somewhere comfortably.
But if I were to work for a remote-first company, I'd expect them to pay a stipend on top of my wage, equivalent to the amount of money they save by not having office space. A quick Google indicates office space costs about $500-$650 a month per person (in Amsterdam, according to Google's summarized results from instantoffices.com), or between 150 and 450 euros / month per m². With that money, as an individual, you could also afford a spot in a co-working space if need be.
I think a $500 or €500 / month stipend or reward for working from home is fair; it's a decent amount of money, and I'm pretty confident it's still cheaper than renting an office - you don't just save on rent, but personnel as well, and things like support and maintenance contracts on the utilities, coffee machines, etc.
- badpun 6y ago> I'd expect them to pay a stipend on top of my wage Your wage is already arbitrary so you can just assume that it includes this stipend.
- aspenmayer 6y agoSince wages are typically part of a contract, which requires or implies a meeting of the minds, any new assumptions resulting in a new interpretation of the contract and its applicability may support an argument for renegotiation of said contract.
- anamexis 6y agoIn the US, wages are not typically part of a contract.
- blarglechien 6y agoOh, you do sign a contract, stating in details that you have no contractual relationship. ( 'at will' ) At least that was my experience in the last 6 years.
- codyswann 6y agoSo then, when you save money on something else, do you give a portion of it back to the company?
- jstummbillig 6y agoOn what, specifically? Generally, no. It's not like a company is giving away its money by not forcing their employees to commute. On the other hand, whether companies should have to pay for individual home office space is a reasonable question (They don't have to provide free lunch at work, they don't have to pay for the commute, both of which are just as or more important for you to be able to work in an office) and will probably largely come down to regulation and, in the absence of that, market forces.
- codyswann 6y agoShould is meaningless in this context. You're saying that, under certain circumstances, the company should pass on savings to its employees. Or maybe it should reinvest that savings into R&D in order to secure a more stable future for its employees. Or maybe it should reinvest that savings into marketing. Or maybe it should use it to hire more employees. Or maybe it should use it to increase the salary of its CEO who successfully led his/her workforce into a new paradigm while increasing productivity and cutting costs. There's a lot of "shoulds" in this world. Unfortunately, they're often mutually exclusive and usually subjective.
- kees99 6y agoGiven that "central" office expenses are taxed differently (more favorably) than payroll, it might make sense to pay "remote/wfh" office expense separately. That being said, how do you calculate the amount? Say, if I rent a 3-bedroom apartment for €1200/mo, and use one of the bedrooms as my home office, is €400/mo reimbursement fair? What about if I work from a living room? What if I own the place I live in? Can I include ISP expense too? etc...
- dijit 6y agoSolved in other societies already; In Sweden you can claim a tax deduction on the square meterage of a room that is used exclusively for work, but it must have a locked door. I live in an 82sqm apartment and I have a 2.5x2 (5sqm) room. So I can work out the percentage of the apartment that is office and file that as a deduction. In my case roughly 6%.
- bildung 6y agoVery similar rules apply for tax deduction of a home office in Germany.
- bregma 6y agoI don't have a door that locks anywhere in my home. Not even to the outside. Where I live (Canada) there is a similar deduction for a home office but no requirement about having a locking door. That would simple be unenforceable, since tax auditors have no right to enter your home to ensure deduction guidelines are being followed. We do, however, have a mountain of paperwork to file for both you and your employer to vouch that working from home is a necessary part of the job, and you have to be swear that that portion of your home you claim is not used for non-work activities more that some small amount of time. My estimate was around 5% of my home. I suspect there are going to be fireworks in the near future as tax legislation changes are debated, with the never-homers trying to quash the forward-thinkers and their changes to the system. I also foresee insurance companies jumping in to take their cut.
- 52-6F-62 6y ago
- pjc50 6y agoAll this talk of salaries overlooks the real reason why companies already spend astonishing amounts of money to move everyone to a premium office in an area of very expensive real estate and then damage their productivity by keeping them in a fancy but noisy open-plan office: conspicuous consumption. Every organisation inevitably ends up producing a quantity of what I'm going to call "boss-ness" for those in charge. It's a significant factor in compensation. This holds true across capitalist, communist, distributed, and even voluntary organisations, and can be seen in groups as small as a single person. All sorts of previously inexplicable things, such as executive travel, become easier to understand through this lens. Micromanagement and abuse of employees as well. Linus Torvald's free pass to be rude to people was also a part of his compensation, until it became far too expensive. As was sexual harassment of the female staff until that got mostly stamped out in the West; see Parton, D "Nine To Five" (1980), or the more recent Rubin case. Remote employees produce less "boss-ness"; you can't look out across your desk farm and see them, you can't look over their shoulders (unless you go for the "desktop sharing and webcam at all times" model, which some places have).
- MiroF 6y agoThis pandemic has made this observation abundantly clear to me at least. As David Graeber pointed out, there are a whole host of "bullshit jobs" out there.
- throwaway_pdp09 6y ago> I'd expect them to pay a stipend on top of my wage, equivalent to the amount of money they save by not having office space Now account for the money you don't spend commuting, and far more valuable, your lifetime saved by not spent commuting.
- specialist 6y agoThen add back dissolving boundaries between work and personal lives, always being on call, constantly being interrupted, exhaustion from conference call improv performance art, etc.
- meritt 6y ago> I'd expect them to pay a stipend on top of my wage, equivalent to the amount of money they save by not having office space Holy sense of entitlement. No, that's not going to happen. That's not how any of this works. You don't see companies paying outsourced workers $150k/yr due to the "amount of money they save by not hiring expensive talent in SF"
- dpc_pw 6y agoYou can expect whatever you want. That's what the salary negotiations are for. But I'm sure there would be plenty of people to out compete you. Just because company is saving money doesn't mean you get to pocket the difference, too.