3 ms·
> Machine learning won't be the answer either. Machine learning is just onother kind of software, you still need to set it up and maintain it. And you need data
by MattGaiser 6y ago
> Machine learning won't be the answer either. Machine learning is just onother kind of software, you still need to set it up and maintain it. And you need data to train it, which for these complex processes often there is none.
Machine learning will learn to set up, maintain, and train itself. /s
I understand the desire to have non-developers write code for themselves, but the problem is that the quality and reliability of that code can be utterly terrible and they don't have the expertise for the edge cases, so there would still need to be at least an intermediate developer overseeing these 20 part-time very junior people simply because some of those processes would eventually go haywire and do something dangerous or destroy some data.
- cm2187 6y agoThat may be the case but 1) how much of that is them using tools that are still too complex, 2) is bad code better or worse than no code at all?
- ivanhoe 6y agoML can't learn to understand the business needs of a company, that's something that even external human developers are always struggling with, and it can affect usefulness of application much more than occasional bugs. On the other hand non-developer employees might not be able to produce optimized code and they'll make rookie mistakes, but they know how their company works, they understand the business needs and processes. IMHO the win-win approach would be to have apps designed by employees with drag&dropping UI and wizards for setting the logic rules, and then to let ML analyze it and generate the high quality code based on that.
- schwartzworld 6y ago> I understand the desire to have non-developers write code for themselves, but the problem is that the quality and reliability of that code can be utterly terrible and they don't have the expertise for the edge cases, People should write code for themselves, and not all code needs to be good quality or have all edge cases covered. there's nothing wrong with someone making a tool for their job and handling the edge cases as they occur.
- sokoloff 6y agoYou just about perfectly described 75-95% of Excel sheets that run an enormous amount of business processes around the world.
- slfnflctd 6y agoMicrosoft Access could be a better tool for a lot of those spreadsheets, I might wager! It would teach user interface design, simple relational database concepts, data types (!) and more. I really wish MS hadn't turned this product into a dead end, seems like a lost opportunity to give aspiring devs a path to learning more capable systems.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]