10 ms·
Caplan utterly overlooks culture and politics, and his analysis ends up extremely shallow as a result: https://www.vox.com/2014/9/13/6135905/open-borders-bryan-
by rayiner 6y ago
Caplan utterly overlooks culture and politics, and his analysis ends up extremely shallow as a result: https://www.vox.com/2014/9/13/6135905/open-borders-bryan-caplan-interview-gdp-double https://www.vox.com/2014/9/13/6135905/open-borders-bryan-cap...
> Not necessarily. "Low-skilled" is actually kind of a misleading term here. Even American high school dropouts have at least one key skill that immigrants generally don't: the ability to speak English. That makes it possible for immigrants to complement the labor of low-skilled, native-born workers, rather than replacing it. "Low-skilled Americans who are fluent in English in a place like New York City wind up supervising the low-skilled immigrants," Caplan says. "They wind up being the bridge, or the people who train immigrants in jobs that they wouldn’t even know about from their home countries."
The problem with this hypothetical is that Caplan overlooks that libertarians wouldn’t have any political clout in this new world order. Reimagine all of Caplan’s hypotheticals, except the Squad is in charge of everything. How long do you think they would stand for English language skills being a determinant of whether someone was entitled to a supervisory role?