3 ms·
Your assumption that the start of life was like what we see today is the problem. We know that RNA molecules form spontaneously, and many such molecules exhibi
by ncmncm 6y ago
Your assumption that the start of life was like what we see today is the problem.
We know that RNA molecules form spontaneously, and many such molecules exhibit enzyme activity. We know that an astonishingly short molecule suffices to copy other RNA sequences it encounters.
All we need, really, is for two of those to encounter one another in the right conditions, and in short order the seas are filled with really excellent copiers. (Better copiers, as they arise, reproduce faster, and soon dominate.) So, the starting condition of life is an environment brimming with RNA replicators, and numerous copies of whatever aids them. Any sort of encapsulation event is likely to include one or more replicators.
Encapsulation is necessary to preserve improvements in interaction between molecules, so we need spontaneous closed-membrane formation.
Curiously, there is no known instance I know of where a cell produces a membrane de novo. It always starts with what it got from a mother cell. Arguably it is not the nucleic acids that define life, but the membrane.
- jcims 6y agoSure there are many plausible series of events that lead from a dead planet to one shimmering with life. My main question isn't if it's possible...we have direct evidence that it is. My question is more related to the probability and how much of a 'happy path' that our little spot in the universe had to have in order to lead us to where we are today. Going back to the origin of my question, it's easy to say 'all we need is the right key and we can decrypt this file' and wave away the fact that all of the atoms in the universe could be recruited for the cause and not have a chance in hell to guess the correct key in all known time.
- ncmncm 6y agohttps://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3943892/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3943892/ describes an RNA enzyme (I count 63 base pairs) that replicates itself, in the absence of other things to replicate, so you don't even need two of them, to start with. The point is that we don't need to assume spontaneous conjunction of all the particles that make a complete system. We should instead guess that before there was what we would recognize as life, many of the constituent parts, at a scale much larger than atoms or amino acids, had arisen, many a result of pre-life analogs of living processes such as replication, driven to high populations by pre-life statistical analogs of natural selection. Then life becomes not a miraculous coincidence, but an inevitability.